5 ms·
Packing a backpack (2014)
- blowski 4y ago> Heavy equipment – tent, food, big jackets – above shoulder height, close to the back. I understand the "close to the back bit", but "above shoulder height"? I've always been told it should be distributed vertically.
- newaccount74 4y agoI think the idea is that you want to keep as normal a posture as possible. You need to lean your torso forward to move the combined center of gravity (body+backpack) over your feet. The lower the center of gravity of the backpack, the more you need to lean your torso forward to counteract it. If the center of gravity is very high, just a few degrees forward will suffice. So a high center of gravity should be more comfortable (but you lose a bit of stability).
- yencabulator 4y agoIt also makes a huge difference how close to that 33% body weight max you carry. What kind of backpack carrying people do affects what kind of advice they've heard. The weight of a military pack will absolutely send you toppling over if you lose your balance, and you need to start packing it a bit lower just to deal with uneven terrain. So you pack it a bit lower than what would be otherwise ideal, to stay on your feet. If you're carrying closer to 10-15% of your body weight, you can put it much higher without stumbling, and you get the benefits of the more upright posture.
- netfortius 4y agoBad advice if you are at high risk of, or already suffering of sciatica, which also benefits of hiking / active and long walks. Backpack center of gravity has to be as low as possible, under such circumstances. (Note: dealt with the issue for many, many years - controlled it with a lot of assistance from Dr McGill books)
- bosie 4y agoAny particular book/resource you recommend from Dr McGill? How do you combat it during work days if you don't mind me asking?
- netfortius 4y ago"Back Mechanic" was by far my favorite, but he has a lot of own articles and also certified specialists in his area of expertise, with specific techniques and advice. The "secret" was to know your body to the point of being able to anticipate harm before too late. Took me years to learn this part, as no book can teach how your own body works.
- bosie 4y agoCheers. Ordered. I do a bit of backpacking (photo gear can be heavy) and i have back issues. I alwyas backed it like deuter suggests. does the book mention why the center of gravity needs to be different for sciatica folks? do you stand/walk more than you sit during work hours now?
- jotm 4y agoIt's fine, most people need to learn it the hard way. And then the two wheeled trolleys many old people use look more attractive than funny.
- Prcmaker 4y agoIve tended to pack just like this, though got there through trial and error. I'll often pad between heavier items and the rear most of the pack such that it stacks them close to my back. (Edit for clarity: I pack like the second image, weight int he middle for good stability in harder terrain) I found it interesting on a hike recently, seeing my buddy's 15yr newer pack, how many little features made load carrying far easier. 'Load lifters' in particular, drawing the load forward towards your neck, made such a large difference to shoulder weight that I retrofitted them to my own pack on the trail.
- Lio 4y agoProgress in packs is weird. I still have a Karimore Jaguar from the early 90s (back when they were made in the UK) that seems to have most modern features you could think of. It weighs 1600g for a 66L pack which compares pretty well with modern rucksacks too. I’ve mostly replaced it with a modern OMM Classic 32 trail running pack. At between 430-630g. Again, that’s a design that originally goes back 1973. I think they got design nailed back then. I haven’t see much in the way of innovation other than slightly better materials.
- Prcmaker 4y agoI agree, my pack is the first I ever bought as an adult, an upgrade in volume, materials and comfort from my Vietnam era cadet issued pack. While there is quite the difference between those two, most differences to a normal modern pack are minor. I'm disappointed it's approaching time to replace it as it feels like home, but some of the fabric is rapidly degrading with repair seeming unlikely.
- chrisseaton 4y agoPeople ask me why do soldiers seem to do the opposite - with the bulk of their kit lower down their backs - it’s because if your kit is high up you can’t raise your head to look up when you’re lying down. I also think it’s strange to have your heavy kit up high even in a civilian context when you aren’t lying down - you don’t put the heaviest things on a top shelf normally. I tend to put my heaviest stuff supported by my hips, either on belt kit or lower down in my daysack or bergen.
- kitd 4y agoAgreed. Heavy stuff up high has a greater turning couple with any movement of the spine, putting uneven stresses on the back. Heavy stuff around the hips is much better.
- tasuki 4y agoDisagreed. As the article stated, heavy stuff around the hips pulls you backwards. You have to lean forward more, and you're less nimble.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- makeitdouble 4y agoDeuter being an outdoor brand, they probably expect people to be leaning slightly forward when hiking most of the time, and strongly forward in hard slopes. Putting the weight higher balances better under that assumption. It works with messenger bags as well: you'll want them at different positions depending on how hard you're leaning or if you're walking.
- adwn 4y ago> I also think it’s strange to have your heavy kit up high even in a civilian context when you aren’t lying down There's a good reason for this, and it's right there in TFA. > you don’t put the heaviest things on a top shelf normally A backpack is not a shelf, and a person is not a wall.
- DonHopkins 4y agoI'm hoping Tom Bihn Bags will come out with a high quality knock-off of the spacious "Flextrek Whipsnake": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZAtzN_ScKXY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZAtzN_ScKXY But seriously, Bihn bags are extremely well designed, and are so well made they last forever! https://www.tombihn.com/collections/backpacks https://www.tombihn.com/collections/backpacks https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4873988 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4873988 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13684860 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13684860 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/washing-instructions-idiot-president_n_5893ef86e4b0c1284f253d61 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/washing-instructions-idiot-pr... Wash with warm water. Use mild soap. Do not use bleach. Do not dry in the dryer. Do not iron. We are sorry that our president is an idiot. We did not vote for him. https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/bihn-label/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/bihn-label/
- watersb 4y agoI've used my Tom Bihn Brain Bag every day for the past ~20 years. https://www.tombihn.com/collections/backpacks/products/brain-bag?variant=31808802848831 https://www.tombihn.com/collections/backpacks/products/brain... I have a larger camping-type backpack that I never use; I can fit 35 pounds of gear into the Brain Bag... although a sleeping bag takes up too much space. Haven't solved that yet. But a fully loaded Brain Bag usually fits fine as a carry-on bag for airline travel.
- jimnotgym 4y agoSidenote. I have had a Deuter cyling pack for around 20 years and it is still in perfect order. I am not exactly easy on gear either
- Eleison23 4y agoOnce upon a time I was homeless, and everything I owned needed to fit into a normal-size collegiate backpack, or I couldn't keep it. Fast-forward 20 years; retaining my packrat qualities, I began to realize I was overpacking every time I left home for an errand. I also seldom unpacked when I returned home, and I would just "let it ride" whatever was still in the backpack next time I went out. So I've tightened a discipline of keeping my bags empty while at home. I try to narrow down my mission each day: what is the core task I need to accomplish? Why do I really need to throw this item in the bag? When I return home, I evaluate each item by its usefulness to me. If I didn't even remember it, or think to pull it out, then it's gonna stay at home. I also try to use smaller bags. I picked up a nice electronics bag at a thrift store, and it fits my phone, keys, bus pass, wallet. So I don't drag around a duffel bag or backpack if I don't need it. Honestly, it's much easier to find something if I don't need to open a dozen zippers. It's easier to ride around on an e-Scooter if I'm not bogged down by 25lbs of kit. I also try to run drop-off errands more often. I'll take a bag of donations to the thrift store, or some recycling will go out. Then I can have the satisfaction of emptying out my bag, even discarding it and returning home lighter. This contrasts with packrats who will go shopping or picking stuff up every day and they just accumulate more and more stuff at home. You gotta balance that out at some point.
- rhn_mk1 4y agoDitching unused items isn't really that great of a strategy, as it becomes less and less useful as you approach items to handle less common but more critical situations. Like bandages, or spare socks, phone battery, a spare ticket, and similar. You won't need them 99% of the time, but if you need them, you REALLY need them.
- thfuran 4y agoSomehow I doubt there are many people out there blindly following this process to throw away their winter coat every summer.
- dividedbyzero 4y ago
- helmholtz 4y agoIf you're a long distance hiker, Matt Shafter's video [1] is very useful. The sleeping bag, instead of going first thing in, kind of spreads _around_ the other heavier objects, which we try to keep close to the lower back / belly button level. Having done my own share of hikes, though, I will say that going ultralight right from the beginning has been a gift that has kept on giving. Seeing people carry heavy tents and stainless steel cooking gear and ridiculously heavy sleeping bags makes me quake in my shoes. I just couldn't do it. And then lastly, I really, really, cannot say enough good things about ease of access. I have shoulder pockets for compass/sunglasses. A bottom pocket in my backpack (Palante) for snacks and trash storage. Side pockets for water that I can reach without taking the pack off, and they're deep enough to not have the bottles fall out. A fanny pack for small items like chapstick, sanitiser etc. And finally _deep_ pockets in my shorts for my phone. NOT having to take my pack off makes me happy over and over and over again. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Ut4R4JMHEE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Ut4R4JMHEE
- WastingMyTime89 4y ago> Having done my own share of hikes, though, I will say that going ultralight right from the beginning has been a gift that has kept on giving. Seeing people carry heavy tents and stainless steel cooking gear and ridiculously heavy sleeping bags makes me quake in my shoes. I just couldn't do it. I agree but as soon as you cross one week of autonomy, food starts to be the bulk of your pack and you just can’t be that light for the first few days.
- jhickok 4y agoGoing ultralight improved my hiking experience so much that I went from "if this is it I don't think it's for me" to "I kind of forgot I had a pack on; anyway what a cool hike". I know it's not for everyone but I cannot imagine bulking up with luxury hiking items anymore.
- alistairSH 4y agoI do a bit of both. A few UL items allow me to bring some luxury along without being overly heavy. For example, I’ll bring a hammock or Helinox camp chair. Both around a pound. Having a place to flop by the campfire at the end of a long day is really nice.
- askvictor 4y agoI don't know if it's just my backpack, but there's not much chance to put heavier items close to my back, as there's not enough back-front space for more than one item for most things; maybe water bottles, but most other heavy items (tent) are almost as deep as my pack is.
- alistairSH 4y agoDepends on the pack and tent. Most modern 2-person backpacking tents are 1/2-2/3 the depth of a 30l pack. This was definitely NOT true when I was a kid. Tent and sleeping bag bulk and mass have come way down between the 90s and today. My pack, tent, and sleeping bag… https://www.osprey.com/us/en/product/exos-48-EXOS48S22.html https://www.osprey.com/us/en/product/exos-48-EXOS48S22.html https://www.bigagnes.com/Tiger-Wall-UL2-Solution-Dye https://www.bigagnes.com/Tiger-Wall-UL2-Solution-Dye https://seatosummit.com/products/spark-ultralight-sleeping-bag-series https://seatosummit.com/products/spark-ultralight-sleeping-b...
- pipeline_peak 4y ago
- InCityDreams 4y agoShould your 'white', be capitalised? And just a bit further on, is there a comma missing? Makes bollocks sense, otherwise. And also, tbh.
- pipeline_peak 4y ago> Makes bollocks sense, otherwise. And also, tbh. Someone with this many awkwardly structured fragments shouldn’t be giving grammar advice. And also, tbh.
- rascul 4y agoIt's been some years since I've looked into this, but from what I recall there are different packing strategies for internal and external backpacks.
- yencabulator 4y agoAnd that gets even more interesting as many Deuter backpacks are hybrids, with a rigid frame that leaves a cooling air pocket between your back and the pack, while looking like a non-frame backpack.
- rascul 4y agoSomehow I didn't realize that Deuter is a backpack manufacturer.
- alistairSH 4y agoProbably, though external frame packs mostly don’t exist any more. At least not in the normal consumer outdoor gear market (REI, etc). A fair chunk of the UL market forgoes a frame completely, and just uses some foam to add rigidity and padding. That’s usually for people going with a truly minimal base weight… Tarp tent, minimal quilt, possibly no stove (living off overnight oats and other things that can be consumed after soaking).
- rascul 4y agoInteresting. It's been so long since I've looked into this stuff that I didn't realize external frame packs were mostly gone.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]