5 ms·
This happened a while ago. Before renewables actually. Peaker plants only run some of the time. They charge more for their power because they need to cover the
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
This happened a while ago. Before renewables actually.
Peaker plants only run some of the time. They charge more for their power because they need to cover their fixed costs.
That's partly why people use gas plants, theyre relatively cheap to build, which matters when you are effectively acting as a backup.
We could in theory let these businesses gamble on how often they will be needed but grids/governments already found it better to pay capacity fees to these generators to ensure they are available if needed.
Notably, that money goes to the people who build the plant, not the fossil fuel suppliers, unless the capacity is actually needed.
But even those people are having their business model challenged because batteries that are installed to shift daily solar peaks can bid for the same peaks.
And as the gas gets burnt less, the price goes up, in a vicious circle that leads to more and more battery deployment.
- pfdietz 4y agoThe peakers are still needed for the last few percent that batteries can't economically cover. The price of power at those times will rise to the point that the peakers can still cover their costs, but it will be cheaper than having enough batteries to handle it. What's needed is to expose those prices to the end users so demand dispatch can handle some of it. Very low capacity factor peakers could be run with hydrogen (or other e-fuels) without greatly affecting their costs, since they'd use so little of it.
- tuatoru 4y agoIf grid battery prices fall another 90% (on trend, this will be in 10 - 15 years, and there is no reason to think that it cannot happen), the economics will probably be different. Need to skate where the puck's going, not where it is.
- pfdietz 4y agoHydrogen costs about $1/kWh of energy storage capacity when stored underground in solution mined caverns in salt formations, so that's a tough target for batteries to reach. Even a 10x reduction will not get them there. The higher efficiency of batteries also becomes proportionally less important as the cost of renewable energy itself declines. It will be interesting to see where the crossover point between hydrogen (and other e-fuels) and current batteries lies. There are also technologies that will fall between them, including certain battery technologies with low current density (Form Energy's batteries are in this category) and various flavors of thermal storage. The latter has the possibility of shifting over to reheat with hydrogen in emergency situations when the directly stored heat is exhausted.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoyou also have to factor in the cost of the hydrogen to burn which for green hydrogen isn't cheap.
- pfdietz 4y agoAs I already pointed out, for the last few percent this doesn't matter much, as the cost of the energy there is dominated by the capital cost of the storage system, not the cost of the fuel being burned.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIn a world where you are trying to cover the last few percent of zero carbon generation, green hydrogen wil be cheap enough to be used to make alcohol, plastics and a bunch of other things just because it's cheaper than natural gas or other feedstocks. So it's not really a worry, prices for grey/blue and green hydrogen should crossover this decade.
- ben_w 4y agoI think there's something missing here. Is that the price per unit stored, or the price per unit of capacity to store? Batteries cost $120/kWh of initial capacity, but they can be recharged between hundreds and multiple thousands of times before significant degradation, depending on the specific design? Picking x1000 arbitrarily, that adds 12¢ to the cost of electricity that goes via a battery today (a lot to be sure, but significantly less than the average domestic cost here). I think hydrogen electrolysis is about 60-90% efficient, so 1/0.9 to 1/0.6 times the electricity cost to make as gas (assuming the hardware cost is amortised to the point of being negligible), but that isn't as high as $1/kWh even for domestic electricity prices here in Germany. Square cube law implies large scale storage will be much cheaper than small scale storage, so I'm still expecting that to be lower than $1/kWh as delivered, though I can believe it might cost that to build the capacity.
- ncmncm 4y agoBattery cost is on the same downward trend as everything else, with new chemistries subtracting step functions. (Watch iron/air, zinc/bromine, antimony/calcium.) But for bulk storage, there are still cheaper technologies that cost only per MW to store or extract, not per MWh stored, like batteries. Tankage is cheap. The per-MW cost is for motor-generators attached to hydro turbine, air compressor, or winch; or for nitrogen liquifier and turbine; or for electrolyser and fuel cell or combined-cycle turbine. Storing in transportable tanks affords extra revenue opportunities.