3 ms·
That’s an orthogonal point. The “speech” that the first amendment is primarily concerned about is political speech. That’s the code of the first amendment prote
by rayiner 4y ago
That’s an orthogonal point. The “speech” that the first amendment is primarily concerned about is political speech. That’s the code of the first amendment protection.
The first amendment by its terms applies to the government. But that doesn’t mean that states can’t provide similar protections from the conduct of private parties.
- scarface74 4y agoSo why stop at social media? Why shouldn’t the state control every website that allows comments including advocacy groups, religious groups etc?
- rayiner 4y agoBecause different things are different? We have different rules for say public restaurants versus private clubs?
- scarface74 4y agoIn that case, what makes HN different from Facebook? Should HN not be able to ban overly political posts? Why can’t Facebook claim to be a private club that you have to join?
- rayiner 4y agoHN seems like the archetype of an interest-specific club as compared to Facebook’s generic content platform.
- scarface74 4y agoSo now we do carve outs based on places we don’t want the government to intervene? So are Subreddits “interest clubs “? Why not just keep the government out of regulating private company’s content? Aren’t conservatives all about “small government”?
- tptacek 4y agoHow so? It's much easier to create an HN account and post than it is to create a Facebook account.