3 ms·
He will say he is happy and mean it. Wish him well." What's that supposed to mean? He will say he is happy and mean it, but really he isn't? DFW committed sui
by jodrellblank 15y ago
He will say he is happy and mean it. Wish him well."
What's that supposed to mean? He will say he is happy and mean it, but really he isn't?
DFW committed suicide, I don't hold him as a great authority on what kinds of happiness are 'valid'.
- arctangent 15y agoDFW is comparing one-dimensional geniuses to people who are retarded in some way. (Mental, emotional, social... take your pick.) The person is happy only because they're so oblivious to the things that they're missing out on, and their very nature prevents them from gaining this knowledge. Were they able to know what they were missing then they might not be so happy with their limited existence.
- jodrellblank 15y agoImplying that seeing what they are missing out on and not being happy with their limited existence is better. But seeing what you're missing out on sucks. Being unhappy because you have a limited existence sucks as an experience. And it's not like you have an unlimited existence if you aren't a world class sports person, is it? You have different limits, but they aren't better or worse objectively. You can't trade tens of millions of adoring fans against a deep appreciation of city street planning and architecture and say one is undoubtedly better and the other certainly worse.
- praptak 15y ago> Were they able to know what they were missing then they might not be so happy with their limited existence. Attaching any weight to what you're missing out is a guaranteed way to make you unhappy and has nothing to do with what you do in life. Even with unlimited resources you'll miss out on most things that require huge time commitment, like being a pro athlete.
- shadytrees 15y agoDFW references this argument in his fiction, so I'll try to do it justice: I respectfully disagree. Depression does not stem from "I don't what happiness is". A depressed person is aware of happiness, of the fact that he or she right now should be happy because everybody else at the dinner table is laughing and having a great time, of the fact that he or she knows how to pretend happy and a great time while at the same time hating the pretension. Being depressed is constantly looking onto happiness but being denied access; being depressed is being depressed about the fact that you don't have access, which in turn makes you more depressed. I don't think the way DFW meant to end that sentence is "but he really isn't". That paragraph, that entire piece really, is about the audience's predatory relationship with athletes. That last paragraph is addressed at people who watch, not people who participate. Michael Joyce is happy; we should just be wary of the kind of happiness.
- sp332 15y agoIt means he'll be missing out on a lot of things, but he'll still be happy. He won't feel the loss.