3 ms·
I think you are way overblowing this whole idea. Sure, peers matter, and yes, probably competitive people may tend to aggregate in some places but that does no
by epolanski 4y ago
I think you are way overblowing this whole idea.
Sure, peers matter, and yes, probably competitive people may tend to aggregate in some places but that does not lead to the implications and numbers you drive. It's mostly about bias and network.
> people who went to MIT were in a culture that pushed them the entire time, so they’ll have maximized their talent
It's funny you mention a university which publishes their own tests. I'd like to see a comparison with similar tests from less prestigious university. Calculus/analysis tests seem quite standard, where's the unusual push?
You seem to regurgitate university ads.
It's also funny how the article points how prestige...is much less of a factor for STEM than economics or law...maybe because stem needs results besides prestige?
- mod50ack 4y ago> Calculus/analysis tests seem quite standard, where's the unusual push? The tests in standard courses aren't really what's at play. It's about people and the ability to "run into" and work with those people gets people into research networks. Not all MIT students do that, of course, and it's not an absolute; many people come from less-prestigious schools, but the networking effects stack things against them coming from undergrad and afford them fewer opportunities to "walk into" those circles, depending on the resources their UGs have.