3 ms·
Without commenting on the merits or lack thereof in this case, I think it would be useful to give some more information about the FSU: https://en.wikipedia.org/
by ben_w 4y ago
Without commenting on the merits or lack thereof in this case, I think it would be useful to give some more information about the FSU: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Speech_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Speech_Union
- parker_mountain 4y agoAs a queer person, the second someone gets "cancelled" and starts yelling about pedophiles, it almost always means that they are anti-queer. What a surprise that this crew seems very much in this boat. I'm not issuing judgement on if paypal is in the right here or not (although my knee jerk reaction is that they are not), but the age-old "they're pedophiles" canard is well past dog-whistling and into trainwhistling at this point.
- blipvert 4y agoI have yet to find an exception to your analysis.
- LAC-Tech 4y agoWhat is this, a counter dog-whistle?
- andirk 4y agoI call it a fog horn. In this case, I'm not hearing anything though. It may be someone with dissenting viewpoints, however hateful-seeming, or outright illegal behavior. As with most touchy subjects, I find the best path forward is to openly discuss without shutting down voices. I believe no one needs to prove they're _not_ a bigot, but one does need to prove someone else _is_ a bigot. Even that is a WIP stance for me.
- PuppyTailWags 4y ago> As with most touchy subjects, I find the best path forward is to openly discuss without shutting down voices. I try to follow this myself, but I do find myself giving exceptions to specific touchy subjects. For example, I don't understand how to approach a touchy subject where open discussion actually drives away people and therefore makes it an echo chamber. For example if a gay person left a community because people were openly discussing whether or not gay people are pedophiles and advocating for the castration and torture of gay people, and that the advocating for castration and torture of gay people wasn't being shut down, I honestly think that's a totally reasonable behavior on behalf of the gay person. And I honestly would disagree that this created anything even remotely resembling a "forward path" direction. But, in abstract, I still believe we should openly discuss touchy subject matters. I just find myself constantly running into actual application where I disagree that openly discussing a specific matter actually benefitted anyone, and found myself agreeing that the community would be healthier if specific topics of conversation were shut down.
- andirk 4y ago_most_ touchy subjects. There is no absolute. For some reason, I cannot handle a person speaking about a woman's appearance in the negative in front of her, and it's because I _think_ I am feeling her pain. I have told people to leave my house immediately for things like that. N-bombs, etc. That makes me a hypocrite, but I'm not strong enough to handle certain topics. I, myself, have accidentally said bigoted things and someone of the relevant marginalized community explains to me why it's hateful to say that, and I am so thankful for their words.
- genewitch 4y agoI don't know the context; with that said, are you sure you heard "hateful" and not "hurtful"? Hate is contextually charged. I know it's lost a lot of its meaning, but as someone who had a parent for whom english was a second language, I was taught not to misuse words like "hate".
- kevingadd 4y agoDoes it really count as a dog-whistle if it's audible to nearly any living human?
- ben_w 4y agoI think you may be overestimating human reasoning skills. I often don't even notice "arguments as soldiers"[0] in the moment, despite my interest in rationality, and that's a very easy way to get unrelated claims squished together like that. [0] https://www.lesswrong.com/tag/arguments-as-soldiers https://www.lesswrong.com/tag/arguments-as-soldiers a topic which I'm thinking about now because a few days ago I noticed half an hour too late that "you need to wear a mask while on public transport in Berlin" has shifted to the side effects of vaccines without me realising.
- decremental 4y ago
- brightball 4y agoAgreed. When there’s active attempts to expose young kids to overtly sexual behavior, it’s the people yelling “over reaction” who I’m most suspicious of. There are lines you don’t cross with kids. When people try to erase those lines it has to be called out.
- genewitch 4y ago"children are not merely small adults."
- ryan-c 4y ago> There's definitely something going on here that needs to be addressed. I'm glad you agree that transphobia should be addressed! > People aren't just making this connection for no reason. Indeed, this rhetoric is being used for fear-mongering and scape-goating in order to distract from certain problems and/or manipulate people into voting for fascists.
- ibeckermayer 4y agoSounds like a great organization standing up for the principle that forms the very foundation of civilization.
- esteth 4y ago
- d110af5ccf 4y ago> I suppose there's an argument that twitter etc are effectively "common carriers" ... I'm not sure I buy it though. On one side of the spectrum we have your private home. Obviously your having the ability to infringe on my freedom to speak in that very specific and limited venue doesn't seem to lead to any great societal ills. On the other side of the spectrum we have a government owned public square. I think it's clear enough that any regulation of speech there including informal coercion not to speak is quite likely to lead to significant political and social problems. Limitations on government power mitigate a lot of this but certainly not all of it. And then we have large corporate owned properties, both online and in the physical world, where the public is more or less permitted to gather but the regular protections don't apply. Presumably the problems caused by regulating speech are related to scale. So at what point should regulation apply? The concept of a common carrier isn't new. Twitter hosts prominent politicians from multiple large countries. It seems obvious to me that they crossed that line some point even if I don't know precisely where it lies.
- nibbleshifter 4y ago> It sounds like a bunch of folk > that are butthurt private venues don't want to listen to their racist, homophobic, or transphobic rhetoric. Basically this. Students Unions have the absolute right to refuse to platform people (and to oppose their platforming by the institution in which they operate), if those people being given a platform runs contrary to the wishes of the student body the Union represents. Nobody has a right to anyone else's platform. Making people platform your views is coerced speech.
- canistista 4y ago
- seaourfreed 4y agoGabPay.com is a competitor to PayPal. GabPay.com protects free speech.
- rvz 4y agoAlso AlignPay [0] is another alternative. [0] https://alignpay.com/ https://alignpay.com/
- encryptluks2 4y agoIs GabPay associated with Gab, cause if so then no they don't. They blocked me for posting liberal viewpoints. They care about protecting right-wing racism and promoting domestic terrorism.
- 10g1k 4y agoYep, Gab is as intolerant as any lefty platform, just at the other end.
- canistista 4y agowikipedia is not a source