4 ms·
Looks up FSU on Wikipedia > After Cambridge University launched an online portal for students to anonymously report microaggressions, the Free Speech Union thr
by anigbrowl 4y ago
Looks up FSU on Wikipedia
> After Cambridge University launched an online portal for students to anonymously report microaggressions, the Free Speech Union threatened legal action. The portal was ultimately removed.[11]
I guess they consider some kinds of speech more free than others.
I found this article less than persuasive as it was clearly written to arouse rather than inform or supply context.
- devwastaken 4y agoReporting of microagressions infers punishment by the university for speech. There's always balancing.
- fennecfoxen 4y agoi would have you explain your sentence because it describes the concept of "reporting" as making an inference and i am no longer clear about how to interpret the words structurally i tentatively take it to mean that you did the inference, and it's punishment by the university, but i am not sure, because the mechanism by which the university affects paypal is unclear
- fennecfoxen 4y agoif anyone is watching I got annoyed at transient downvotes on this and i'm tired of getting annoyed at websites so i'm burning 12395 internet points and locking myself out of my account and throwing away the password
- smegsicle 4y agodownvoting is a microaggression
- minitech 4y agoJust another person misusing “infer” when they meant “imply”.
- kevingadd 4y agoNo, university policies produce punishment or non-punishment. Reporting is speech. Would you prefer that they report publicly and drag people into the court of public opinion without an investigation instead? Isn't that Cancel Culture?
- d110af5ccf 4y agoI doubt they were objecting to the speech itself as much as the system that had apparently been set up to facilitate it. Or in other words, you say "university policies produce punishment or non-punishment" and it seems to me it was precisely those policies that they were objecting to.
- DuskStar 4y agoIf someone says "here's a portal where you can report wrongspeak" my general intuition is that they are then going to punish people for wrongspeak.
- anigbrowl 4y agoPre-emptively characterizing certain sorts of communication as totalitarian without any exploration of its content or merits is one kind of rhetorical strategy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bauruine 4y ago>Would you prefer that they report publicly and drag people into the court of public opinion without an investigation instead? Yes thats exactly what free speech is about. It's the public that decides what it thinks about it and not some secret council.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI think you mean 'implies' rather than 'infers'. I'm not a big fan of the 'microaggression' concept (which seems to be an analytical tool that's been prematurely operationalized), but it's not hard to conceive of a person in a position of academic or social authority who habitually dunks on some outgroup in such a way that its members are scared to complain openly. I picked that example because I think it's notable that FSU didn't champion the idea of anonymous dissent and push for a more transparent but maximally inclusive solution; it seems they were OK with a particular kind of speech being shut down. Paypal's lack of transparency about why they're being rejected as customers is a bad thing, but then again Paypal is notorious for unilateralism and consumer hostility, as flea-market traders on eBay have long grumbled. I might be more sympathetic if this were an org with a long and nuanced history of arguing for a general set of values like the EFF (with whom I don't agree on every topic, but whose independence and consistency are well established). However my first impression of the FSU is that it's a more partial organization than its branding suggests.
- googlryas 4y agoSure, why not? Some speech can have chilling effects on other speech. It makes sense to prioritize the former over the latter.
- etchalon 4y agoSo, whose speech are we prioritizing, and why?
- fsckboy 4y agoTo truly believe in free speech you need to defend speech you disagree with. That's the ultimate prioritization.
- anigbrowl 4y agoWhat if the latter speech is exerting a chilling effect, perhaps by design? Anonymous reporting can be gamed or exploited, but it can also be an outlet for those who are scared of speaking openly because they might incur retaliation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoI don’t see this as some hypocritical indictment. I don’t think free speech organizations should be expected to treat all forms of speech equally and without qualification. Especially when we get to the point of actions, such as anonymously reporting people, being considered speech. When I think of free speech the context is usually the freedom of discourse and the ability to say controversial things - rather than the demand for total and unrestricted liberty.
- Dracophoenix 4y ago> Especially when we get to the point of actions, such as anonymously reporting people, being considered speech. So are whistleblowers like Deep Throat ate people you believe shouldn't have right to report and publish material? > When I think of free speech the context is usually the freedom of discourse and the ability to say controversial things - rather than the demand for total and unrestricted liberty. You have it backwards. Your pursuing permission not freedom. To have the freedom to speak of controversial subjects speech you must first have the freedom to speak. Freedoms are unrestricted by their very nature. While I'm not very knowledgeable of English Law, Cambridge University (and every other university in England) receives taxpayer funding. If keeping free speech on campus is a condition for such funding, then this isn't censorship, but a contractual matter between Cambridge and the English courts that Free Speech Union would like to have observed and enforced.
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y ago>”So are whistleblowers like Deep Throat ate people you believe shouldn't have right to report and publish material?” That’s quite different from what I was getting at. I am pro free speech, which includes journalists like you’ve mentioned. What I was getting at is, people can be pro “free speech” insomuch as wanting open dialogue of controversial or heretical topics while simultaneously finding some kinds of speech/actions chilling and opposing such things. And, they can do this without being considered fundamentally flawed hypocrites. I’ll propose a hypothetical/analogy. Envision it is the 1950’s in America and I support the rights of communists to speak on college campuses. But I do not support a system to report suspected communist sympathizers to the House Un-American Activities Committee. It could be argued that I’m infringing on the speech rights of the McCarthyites. But in my mind this doesn’t mean I’m anti free speech, because I’m ultimately opposing something I believe has a chilling effect on speech.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- z7 4y agoThe reference links to a Telegraph article quoting an explanation: >Toby Young, general secretary of the FSU, wrote to the vice-Chancellor claiming that the website and policy "proposed a system of policing speech and everyday interaction" which would be "inconsistent" with its duty to uphold free speech. He pointed out that section 43 of the Education Act 1986 requires universities to take reasonably practical steps to secure freedom of speech within the law for employees. "This policy, as you must be aware, would radically interfere with how your academics teach, argue with and learn from students, as well as how students interact with each other," Mr Young said. "It would mean academics and students were under constant threat of being reported and investigated for having committed some wholly innocent but perceived slight, which would inevitably have a chilling effect on interactions that, in a university, should be free and unguarded." https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/05/24/cambridge-removes-website-dons-can-reported-raising-eyebrow/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/05/24/cambridge-remove...
- BrainVirus 4y ago>I guess they consider some kinds of speech more free than others. False equivalency. Setting up a snitch website has little to do with speech and everything to do with administrative action. Clearly, many people here don't understand jack about why free speech is important. They just parrot that phrase when they feel it advances their pet ideology, literally not understanding what it means. They treat it as if it's just some clever construct made up by "the other side". This is how we get persistent false equivalency between communication and disrupting communication.
- bitwize 4y agoYes, and the FSU is parroting free speech when they feel it can help them advance right-wing ideology, including LGBTQ hate.
- origin_path 4y agoThe FSU routinely defends people on the left, including left wing academics.
- DoItToMe81 4y agoYeah, I've seen their supporters defend Corbyn and point out that malicious photoshops were spread to make it appear as though he was reading the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. Definitely doesn't seem like an exclusively right wing organization.
- anigbrowl 4y agoThat's quite a lot of loaded words, I hope you don't pull a muscle. Communication or disruption seems to depend very much on one's position in the communicative infrastructure; if efforts to challenge some prevailing orthodoxy are disproportionately penalized, then people are likely to seek other avenues. Likewise, if people perceive themselves as significantly endangered by some forms of communication, they have an interest in disrupting it. One could counter that they should argue an alternative point of view, but this presupposes that all arguments are made and evaluated in good faith, and that all disputation is substantive in nature, without any use of rhetorical figures or exploitation of cognitive biases. As we know to our cost, this is often not the case.