6 ms·

Anything you've learned worth sharing? How has your experience with Backstage been? Why did you choose it over other options? I might be working on a similar pr

Anything you've learned worth sharing? How has your experience with Backstage been? Why did you choose it over other options? I might be working on a similar project soon.

moralestapia 4y ago
Are there other good options? Edit: Thanks everyone!
- agmiklas 4y ago
  opslevel.com is worth checking out. (Disclosure — I’m an investor.)
  - kenrose 4y ago
    Thanks Andrew. (Disclosure: I'm a founder/CTO). Backstage is super configurable, but requires that you build your own developer portal. That generally requires a dedicated team of people at your company to think about dev workflows to support, building plugins, plus hosting/maintenance. At OpsLevel, we're focused on a much more turnkey solution. We want to get you up and running in under an hour, not weeks / months.
- deleted 4y ago
  [deleted]
- gsdatta 4y ago
  (Shameless plug) – founder of https://www.cortex.io https://www.cortex.io (YC W20) here! We build an off-the-shelf developer portal. Backstage is great if you have lots of time/very niche requirements, but most of our users need a system that "just works" to drive ownership/best practices without adding a ton of overhead
- tecleandor 4y ago
  We didn't have enough time for testing, but there's also Clutch, coming from the Lyft team. (Checking right now I'm not able to see a "releases" page with versions and that stuff...) https://clutch.sh/ https://clutch.sh/
  - jdwithit 4y ago
    First time seeing this, but reading the docs it looks more like a modern take on Rundeck[0]. A way to give developers one-click access to operational tasks. Rather than a service catalog and developer portal like Backstage. [0] https://www.rundeck.com/ https://www.rundeck.com/
- thisisbrians 4y ago
  We've just started using Atlassian Compass (https://www.atlassian.com/software/compass https://www.atlassian.com/software/compass) for our software catalog, but it appears to be much less featured than Backstage. We're taking a look at replacing it with Backstage, and curious if anyone else has notes on the comparison.
- password4321 4y ago
  Might find some near previous mentions: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=backstage.io%2F&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=backstage.io%2F&sort=byDate&ty...
- derkoe 4y ago
  Just saw this video where a similar platform is introduced https://youtu.be/Abdp_BnRIx0 https://youtu.be/Abdp_BnRIx0 This is the website https://kustodian.io/ https://kustodian.io/ It has more features including onboarding, access control, etc
x3ro 4y ago
It’s too early to say, unfortunately (which is why my initial post was not super useful, admittedly). All I can say for now is that, in all likelihood, a _lot_ of customization will be needed. Ask me again in two months :D

Anything you've learned worth sharing? How has your experience with Backstage been? Why did you choose it over other options? I might be working on a similar project soon.

moralestapia 4y ago

Are there other good options? Edit: Thanks everyone!

agmiklas 4y ago
opslevel.com is worth checking out. (Disclosure — I’m an investor.)
- kenrose 4y ago
  Thanks Andrew. (Disclosure: I'm a founder/CTO). Backstage is super configurable, but requires that you build your own developer portal. That generally requires a dedicated team of people at your company to think about dev workflows to support, building plugins, plus hosting/maintenance. At OpsLevel, we're focused on a much more turnkey solution. We want to get you up and running in under an hour, not weeks / months.
deleted 4y ago
[deleted]
gsdatta 4y ago
(Shameless plug) – founder of https://www.cortex.io https://www.cortex.io (YC W20) here! We build an off-the-shelf developer portal. Backstage is great if you have lots of time/very niche requirements, but most of our users need a system that "just works" to drive ownership/best practices without adding a ton of overhead
tecleandor 4y ago
We didn't have enough time for testing, but there's also Clutch, coming from the Lyft team. (Checking right now I'm not able to see a "releases" page with versions and that stuff...) https://clutch.sh/ https://clutch.sh/
- jdwithit 4y ago
  First time seeing this, but reading the docs it looks more like a modern take on Rundeck[0]. A way to give developers one-click access to operational tasks. Rather than a service catalog and developer portal like Backstage. [0] https://www.rundeck.com/ https://www.rundeck.com/
thisisbrians 4y ago
We've just started using Atlassian Compass (https://www.atlassian.com/software/compass https://www.atlassian.com/software/compass) for our software catalog, but it appears to be much less featured than Backstage. We're taking a look at replacing it with Backstage, and curious if anyone else has notes on the comparison.
password4321 4y ago
Might find some near previous mentions: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=backstage.io%2F&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=backstage.io%2F&sort=byDate&ty...
derkoe 4y ago
Just saw this video where a similar platform is introduced https://youtu.be/Abdp_BnRIx0 https://youtu.be/Abdp_BnRIx0 This is the website https://kustodian.io/ https://kustodian.io/ It has more features including onboarding, access control, etc

x3ro 4y ago

It’s too early to say, unfortunately (which is why my initial post was not super useful, admittedly). All I can say for now is that, in all likelihood, a _lot_ of customization will be needed. Ask me again in two months :D