5 ms·
Tim Berners-Lee invented hyperlinks so that URLs can be shortened to a single word, character or even image while keeping them visible to the user if need to by
by prmoustache 4y ago
Tim Berners-Lee invented hyperlinks so that URLs can be shortened to a single word, character or even image while keeping them visible to the user if need to by hovering over it.
People using these kind of links shorterner are people using bad tools and bad UIs. This is that usage that needs to be corrected, and not by inventing things even more stupid.
- InitialBP 4y agoYou can't put a hyperlink on a magazine, the tv, or the radio. There are definitely reasonable applications of shortened URLs that apply outside of the normal day-to-day web browsing and applications.
- Semaphor 4y agoI agree, we sell PDFs with the ability to be printed, all links are short links (on our own domain, though) so they aren’t lost/inaccessible when printed.
- prmoustache 4y agoqrcodes are superior for most printed usage. It never occured to me to type an url from a radio or TV message and I've never heard anyone spelling an url from a url shortener. All TV/radio broadcasters will rather tell you check for more information in "name of the show" on "domain of the TV/radio channel" or their social media feed. They all have a web presence anyway.
- Volundr 4y ago> qrcodes are superior for most printed usage Disagree. I can't scan or type a QR code into my computer.
- prmoustache 4y agoUsuallt you don't deal with printed code when you are in front of a computer and even then it is easy to scan the code with your phone and paste the link on your computer.
- Volundr 4y agoI don't? I do most of my reading at home where I have multiple computers in easy reach. I'm also not sure how I'm "easily" copy/pasting between my phone/computer. Is this an iOS/OS X thing? Not everyone is in that eco-system.
- jcynix 4y agoQuite a number of apps allow you to easily copy/paste between Android phone and computer: - BlitzMail, via email - Joplin, via desktop client - Nextcloud/Owncloud - Termux, e.g. via ssh, rsync, ... Various messenger apps with desktop clients or web interfaces, e.g. Element (matrix.org) or Threema.
- Volundr 4y agoI run NextCloud on my computer and laptop, and just checked... no I can't "just copy/paste" from my phone to my computer, or at least if it can the interface is hidden to the point I can't figure it out. I'd have to scan the QR code, have it pop open my browser, select the url, long press to copy, navigate to the NextCloud app, create a text file, paste the url, save the file, open it on my computer, copy the URL, and paste it into my browser. Admittedly, sending it via e-mail or something would cut out a couple of those steps (still a far cry from "just copy/paste"), and is what I do on those rare occasions I do need to take a URL from my phone to my laptop, but you know what's even easier? Just sitting down at the damn keyboard and typing in whatever.com/coolthing. Why do I need two devices just to browse your damn website on a decent sized screen or buy your product?
- jcynix 4y agoWhile I agree that textual links and qr codes aren't the best solutions for certain tasks, the workflow you describe appears a bit too complicated. What I do: - scan a qrcode with a qrcode app (I use a version from f-droid) - choose "share as text" in the app - select the Owncloud app, which asks me what name the file should have No browser step needed on the phone. In the desktop's browser I navigate to the Owncloud, open the file just saved and click on the link. No cut/copy/paste involved. What I really do: - scan the qr code (or the text with an OCR app like TextFairy) - share the snippet with the Joplin app - open the Joplin desktop version and there's the link or text Or I actually use Blitzmail (share as text from some other app, which counts as the "cut" step of cut/copy/paste), then select the email arriving on the desktop and select the link (i.e. "copy" ) and "paste" it into the browser, where the last step is usually done by the desktop which offers a "open this link" menu for links in texts. Using the Blitzmail app serves as an easy record keeping device too, when I just send a whole text block containing a link, so I have the context at hand later, if needed.
- sph 4y agoThat's because desktop OS vendors still haven't integrated that feature. They just don't care. But it's not rocket science. Why the heck my iOS camera has a built in QRcode reader, but why doesn't Firefox or my webcam app on my PC? It's niche but I always come across it when setting up a new 2FA account and I need to save the code through the mobile app instead of my PC. Such bullshit.
- axelthegerman 4y agoCan't wait to watch people trying to scan QR codes from their TV with the selfie camera on a laptop or even desktop. Agreed that QR codes are better for mobile devices and sometimes useful on a laptop. But also QR codes can only be scanned as long as visible. corp.ltd/specialoffer is easy to remember and type on any device
- InitialBP 4y agoUnrelated recommendation - 1Password will scan QR codes and can store TOTP 2fa tokens for you. I assume other password managers also have similar features.
- steventey 4y agoJust wanted to chime in and say that QR Codes are next on the roadmap! Would be fun to learn how to build those
- sosborn 4y ago> qrcodes are superior for most printed usage. Agreed >It never occurred to me to type an url from a radio or TV message and I've never heard anyone spelling an url from a url shortener. It happens. How do I know? Every time I've included a url (shortened or not) in a radio/tv ad, I've gotten verified traffic. > All TV/radio broadcasters will rather tell you check for more information in "name of the show" on "domain of the TV/radio channel" or their social media feed. This is a best practice for sure, but we all answer to someone, and that someone might not care.
- stjohnswarts 4y agohow are they any better than url shorteners? Now I have to download a qr code reader, screen grab it, convert it with said app, and that opens in a browser
- blowski 4y agoAren't QR code readers built into Android and iOS?
- solardev 4y agoDepends on your OS, manufacturer, and version. In Android, it depends on your camera app (and version). Later Google Camera versions have that, for example, but earlier ones (as of a few years ago) did not.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI'm on PC at least 75% of my time and not on my phone. My phone is mostly for messaging, music, email, and killing time at the airport/airplane/wherever I'm waiting. I get the point about extremely long URLs though, but most of the time that's not an issue unless you're printing it out
- prmoustache 4y agoapart from the download that happens once, it is just a case of pointing your camera to the code and the browser open by the touching the screen once. Quicker than typing a shortened url.
- prmoustache 4y agoThey are better because you know the exact url you will reach before sending it to your browser.
- indymike 4y agoBitly exists because of Twitter and SMS character limits.
- tenacious_tuna 4y agoI run into similar problems in a corporate context. Being able to quickly tell someone "the provisioning portal is at corp.short/provision" is easily 10x more useful than "go look in the wiki for the link"
- reilly3000 4y agoSee also: golinks
- extra88 4y agoI don't know how long this has been true but all links in tweets are replaced with Twitter's own link-shortener links (t.co). No matter how short your link is, in a tweet it will consume 23 characters. https://help.twitter.com/en/using-twitter/how-to-tweet-a-link https://help.twitter.com/en/using-twitter/how-to-tweet-a-lin...
- indymike 4y agoThis happened after bit.ly and other shorteners started to have great financial success. Ecosystem annexation at it's best...
- bluetidepro 4y agoI think you underestimate how much separation there sometimes is on large teams with the people who run/build the website, vs the marketers who are moving fast. I've seen terrible devs who will claim it takes DAYS to add a simple redirect of dog.com/X to your long marketing url (cutting out services like this), but the marketing team can't wait that long so services like this are much more async in many contexts, too.
- solardev 4y ago100% this... I was our web dev working with marketing, and before I got there, short URLs/marketing links had to be manually created as new pages in Drupal sometimes, in a 301 redirect dashboard other times (what the hell), which meant submitting a ticket, waiting for it to get prioritized, etc., then making sure there were no conflicts anywhere. Switched it out with a cheap commercial short URL system with its own domain, and the marketers could login anytime and make their own URLs, see all the analytics, edit the destinations, etc. Everyone was much happier after that. It did indeed cut the wait from days to seconds, and plus they had real-time usage data after that.
- intelVISA 4y agoTerrible, perhaps, but very smart.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- EGreg 4y agoActually, link shorteners are just a symptom of the problem. The problem is the DNS system itself. It is the reason that your email address gets spammed, and the reason that you can DDOS websites, etc. DNS is a glorified search engine, and it is only really used for root urls like mydomain.tld . It's pretty much only good in two contexts: 1) for when people dictate a specific domain name verbally to someone, and even then, spelling errors can occur. 2) advertising a URL somewhere to a landing site. But you can just use a QR code that people can scan, or a link in a webpage. Everything else may as well be at non-human-readable domain names, in which case you can even use distributed hash tables instead of DNS. Perhaps one day browsers will allow plugins realize their own schemas, such as ipfs://hjkldfjhsdfkjgsdhfgsdf and the plugin would do the routing instead of DNS. Is that currently possible with standard browser extensions?
- blowski 4y agoI'm pretty sure my email gets spammed because bad actors exist in the world. I'm sceptical any technical solution will protect against that.
- EGreg 4y agoIt takes both. If people couldn't send a message to your email just by knowing it, then you wouldn't get SPAM. Instead, you could be giving out capabilities, to send you email. And if one of them was abused, you'd simply turn it off, and only accounts who used it in the past could continue to send. New ones wouldn't be.