4 ms·
"The irony is that this is being posted in a heavily moderated forum." I don't think there's any irony in this. The moderation decision has traditionally been
by giantg2 4y ago
"The irony is that this is being posted in a heavily moderated forum."
I don't think there's any irony in this. The moderation decision has traditionally been up to those mods. What is fundamentally different with this (edit: "this" as in topic of the government forcing moderation through proposed legislation) is how it is now government mandated.
Personally, I feel that government mandates of censorship actually compells "speech" on the part of the mods/platform. This violates free speech principles, albeit from a different part than most talk about (suppressing speech vs compelling it).
- socialismisok 4y agoWas it government mandated? I could see someone making the case that the government "sure would appreciate if someone removed this meddlesome priest", but I don't see a mandate anywhere.
- r3trohack3r 4y agoThe article covers this and precedent.
- socialismisok 4y agoThe article does not suggest there was a mandate. It implies there was maybe a mandate but mostly just Biden saying things and the companies listening.
- r3trohack3r 4y ago> As the Supreme Court has long recognized and Justice Thomas explained in a concurring opinion just last year, “[t]he government cannot accomplish through threats of adverse government action what the Constitution prohibits it from doing directly.” > In 1963, the Supreme Court, deciding Bantam Books v. Sullivan, held that “public officers’ thinly veiled threats to institute criminal proceedings against” booksellers who carried materials containing obscenity could constitute a First Amendment violation. The same reasoning should apply to the Biden administration campaign to pressure tech companies into enforcing its preferred viewpoints. > It remains to be seen whether Bhattacharya and Kulldorff will be able to show that Fauci and Collins explicitly ordered tech companies to censor them and their Great Barrington Declaration. Fair - I’m overstating.
- lern_too_spel 4y ago"What is fundamentally different with this is how it is now government mandated [emphasis added]." {{Citation needed}} I can't find any government mandates of censorship that your comment complains about. This article is about how the administration said that Facebook was killing people by spreading misinformation, and the company felt shamed into changing what posts it promotes and how it tags them, realizing that doing so would also be more profitable long term. The government has said bad things about a lot of companies and has done so since its formation.
- giantg2 4y agoMy comment is not specific to the narrow focus of the article, but rather the larger conversation on this topic which which likely spurred this article. I'm referring to various proposed legislation that would mandate specific moderation, not something that has already occurred.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoWhat proposed legislation?
- giantg2 4y agoThere are multiple state level bills. The Journalism Competition and Preservation Act has content moderation provisions. There are also some international bills/laws that will affect the platforms too.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThat bill has nothing to do with mandated moderation and only modifies the rights of content creators (for collective bargaining), not content aggregators. Full text: https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/673/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/673.... If there are multiple state level bills mandating moderation, please point to at least one. I know of several that restrict moderation. https://www.politico.com/news/2022/07/01/social-media-sweeps-the-states-00043229 https://www.politico.com/news/2022/07/01/social-media-sweeps...
- matthewdgreen 4y agoIs it government mandated? Because everything turns on that. Politicians and government officials are allowed to have opinions, and even state those opinions: that's not a mandate. TFA clearly seems to want to cast these opinions as a mandate enforced by the power of law, but when you squint and try to find the evidence it's troublingly absent.
- giantg2 4y agoMy comment is not specific to the narrow focus of the article, but rather the larger conversation on this topic which which likely spurred this article. I'm referring to various proposed legislation that would mandate specific moderation, not something that has already occurred.
- towaway15463 4y agoAs if back channels or threats of unfavourable treatment don’t exist. Just because the government doesn’t put it in writing on the public record doesn’t mean they aren’t exerting other forms of power. In this case they did make statements both public and private and also engaged other parties to put pressure on. Asserting that this is “like just their opinion, man” is like saying the thugs that come into your store and admire it while saying “nice place, it’d be a shame if anything happened to it” are just expressing an opinion.
- thrown_22 4y ago>This is a lovely company you have, it would be a shame if we had to regulate it.
- evandale 4y agoWhat's the difference between a recommendation and a mandate when the government is delivering it through a private channel?