4 ms·
> And here's something wild: At those energies, there are only three forces of nature, not four. oh ok does this field just lack words to convey a shared conc
by yieldcrv 4y ago
> And here's something wild: At those energies, there are only three forces of nature, not four.
oh ok
does this field just lack words to convey a shared concept?
I often see these language anomalies only in reference to physics and outer spaaaace. Its like a bad attempt at skeumorphing when different words should have been used from the start.
Like in this article “Did you knooow, this is so interesting, that space-time has cracks!? I know right! at these energy levels electroweak force (appropriately named) merges!”
Why are PhDs communicating like this? How does this article conveyed a shared concept (the point of language) to anyone except a few people that went to the same school? who is this for?
- superb-owl 4y agoYes. Physics concepts are notoriously hard to communicate in natural language. You need to see the math in order to go any deeper than "spacetime cracks." I highly recommend Leonard Susskind's "Theoretical Minimum" course if you would like to go deeper, and see this fact for yourself: https://theoreticalminimum.com/ https://theoreticalminimum.com/
- EamonnMR 4y agoI'm actually reading his Black Hole War book right now and he does a great job of explaining things conceptually.
- roywiggins 4y agoThe universe doesn't really play nicely with human metaphors. That's why physics spends so much time deep in mathematics, because it turns out our metaphors don't line up with reality very well at all. Or, alternatively, mathematics provides a really, really intricate set of interlocking metaphors that you can train yourself to use, but most people haven't. So anyone without the right training is left with a relatively impoverished understanding (including me!)
- prometheus76 4y agoWe need ~~priests~~ scientists who speak ~~Latin~~ mathematics to interpret what truth really is because none of the rest of us have been trained. EDIT: I thought HN used markdown for comments, but I guess not. The double tilde is strikethrough in markdown.
- boomboomsubban 4y ago>We need ~~priests~~ scientists who speak ~~Latin~~ mathematics to interpret what truth really is because none of the rest of us have been trained No, we don't. Most people don't really need to know advanced physics. It's not like the knowledge will save you from eternal suffering, it's just interesting to some even if they have a shitty grasp on it all. We need educated teachers to train engineers so they can use the "truth" to develop new technology.
- prometheus76 4y agoMost people don't need to know advanced physics. We just need to follow the science, right? We can trust them because they are authorities with special training!
- boomboomsubban 4y agoI follow them by using my phone to type this message to you wherever you are in the world minutes after reading your message. I don't understand how most of the parts work to send this message, but I know that there are many scientific principles involved I could learn. I don't need blind faith in them. And they aren't hiding the information from me, I'm too lazy to spend the time necessary to learn it.
- roywiggins 4y agoI've taken math courses that were beyond me. This stuff is actually difficult, in ways that are probably irreducible. Once you get your head round a new mathematical tool though, it opens up others. But without that base understanding, that stuff would be incomprehensible. You can't jump over building understanding of the complicated underlying metaphors first. It's like first encountering, say, computer programming. Until you've got the fundamental tools of loops, conditions, and so on, the whole thing can feel like incomprehensible magic. And that's a system that was designed by humans to be more-or-less comprehensible. The universe doesn't have to be!