6 ms·
> Still, because there will be no increase in visas issued, there will be losers. Hosin “David” Lee, president of the Korean-American Scientists and Engineers A
by gwern 15y ago
> Still, because there will be no increase in visas issued, there will be losers. Hosin “David” Lee, president of the Korean-American Scientists and Engineers Association, said the bill would force engineers from South Korea to wait an additional two years in their immigration process to get green cards.
Didn't expect that.
- gms 15y agoYeah, basically Indians and Chinese gain but everyone else loses.
- Jayasimhan 15y ago..their unfair advantage.
- po 15y agoCalling something fair or not is applying your morals to the situation. This change means that each person gets treated fairly (in the mathematical sense) but each group does not. It is sort of like how in the US House is representation by population but in the Senate is equal senators per state. Wether that is good or bad is up to us as a society. It will certainly reduce the diversity of the types of people getting visas as more populous countries crowd out less populous ones.
- recoiledsnake 15y ago>This change means that each person gets treated fairly (in the mathematical sense) but each group does not. So, without this change, each group was getting treated fairly? Care to explain how multidecade wait times for the two biggest groups while the rest get visas in a matter of years is fairness? How is first-in first-out not more fair compared to discriminating on national origin? > It will certainly reduce the diversity of the types of people getting visas as more populous countries crowd out less populous ones. Not really. Employment based visas are a small fraction of the number of visas awarded each year. Diversity doesn't make much sense for employment based visas because companies hire based on need and employee talent, not race or language. Not to mention that India is so diverse with race, languages and culture that it's called a sub-continent. Lumping them into one 'group' like you did doesn't make much sense. Countries don't directly map one to one to diversity.
- mwerty 15y agoIt's 'fair' for the groups in the sense that each group gets to send in an equal number of people per year.
- pelemele 15y ago>Care to explain how multidecade wait times for the two >biggest groups while the rest get visas in a matter of years >is fairness? To be fair, each country gets quota for working visa based on a size of population. Unfortunately requests for working visa from those two countries outnumber that quota. This is the fact and everybody knows that. So if you are from country with more than one billion people where maybe 100.000+ ask for working visa per year you have to understand that the process can be complicated. And you have to understand as well that getting working visa here is a privilege, not a right.
- cooldeal 15y ago>To be fair, each country gets quota for working visa based on a size of population. Right now, that's not the case, each country is capped to 7% regardless of the population. Making it proportional to population would be much fairer than the current system. >And you have to understand as well that getting working visa here is a privilege, not a right. What a strawman. Maybe you should tell that to Mr. Lee who said the following: > Hosin “David” Lee, president of the Korean-American Scientists and Engineers Association, said the bill would force engineers from South Korea to wait an additional two years in their immigration process to get green cards.
- 15y ago
- klipt 15y agoOf course immigration is unfair. If you're born in Korea you may wait less than if you're born in China, but if you're born in the US, you don't have to wait at all! How is being born in the USA any less of an arbitrary distinction than being born in Korea?
- redbrick 15y agoThis a ridiculous argument. Nationality/Diversity based immigration is fundamentally different than qualification/skill based immigration. The US does both. Hence nationality should not be taken into account for skill based immigration.
- thewisedude 15y agoIs it not going to reduce the wait time for a majority of people at the expense of minority of people?
- lmkg 15y agoThere's the same number of people wanting visas, and the same number of visas being granted. The number of people who get an advantage should be equal to the number of people who get a disadvantage, in any particular year. Over multiple years, the total man-years of wait time should remain constant, although they could be distributed among a different number of people.