5 ms·
If I may, David Foster Wallace (as so often) said it better: > “But it’s better for us not to know the kinds of sacrifices the professional-grade athlete has m
by gwern 15y ago
If I may, David Foster Wallace (as so often) said it better:
> “But it’s better for us not to know the kinds of sacrifices the professional-grade athlete has made to get so very good at one particular thing…the actual facts of the sacrifices repel us when we see them: basketball geniuses who cannot read, sprinters who dope themselves, defensive tackles who shoot up with bovine hormones until they collapse or explode. We prefer not to consider closely the shockingly vapid and primitive comments uttered by athletes in postcontest interviews or to consider what impoverishments in one’s mental life would allow people actually to think the way great athletes seem to think. Note the way”up close and personal" profiles of professional athletes strain so hard to find evidence of a rounded human life — outside interests and activities, values beyond the sport. We ignore what’s obvious, that most of this straining is farce. It’s farce because the realities of top-level athletics today require an early and total commitment to one area of excellence. An ascetic focus. A subsumption of almost all other features of human life to one chosen talent and pursuit. A consent to live in a world that, like a child’s world, is very small…[Tennis player Michael] Joyce is, in other words, a complete man, though in a grotesquely limited way…Already, for Joyce, at twenty-two, it’s too late for anything else; he’s invested too much, is in too deep. I think he’s both lucky and unlucky. He will say he is happy and mean it. Wish him well."
http://www.esquire.com/print-this/the-string-theory-0796?page=all http://www.esquire.com/print-this/the-string-theory-0796?pag...
(A quote I come back to on occasion, thinking about my essay http://www.gwern.net/The%20Melancholy%20of%20Subculture%20Society http://www.gwern.net/The%20Melancholy%20of%20Subculture%20So... )
- kevinalexbrown 15y agoI think the DFW was a little melodramatic here. I don't think the commitment to true excellence necessarily detracts from other possible commitments in the long run. E.g. DFW was a writer of singular ability, and he was, at various points in his life, dedicated to tennis, philosophy, and mathematics. More to the point, the time spent being great at CS doesn't seem to have limited this guy's future ability to do things like work at a startup. While I'm sure it was an unbalanced life during the period of dedication, suggesting that it's the dedication itself which reduces athletes to "shockingly vapid and primitive comments" goes a little far.
- gizzlon 15y ago"More to the point, the time spent being great at CS doesn't seem to have limited this guy's future ability to do things like work at a startup." I agree it has not limited his ability to learn new things, but of course it has limited his ability to work at a startup. Just think of all the things he could be better at, from social interaction to programming, if he had spent less time playing CS. I'm not saying he should regret it, I just think that we should all face the fact that we all make sacrifices. You can't have it all.
- FrojoS 15y agoExactly. And on top of that, CS was only popular for a brief period of time. Had it already been popular when he was a kid, like Tennis, then he would have probably been practicing at a very young age to become world class. And if CS was still as popular, he might be still playing it.
- cynest 15y ago> And if CS was still as popular, he might be still playing it. As of this posting there are ~52000 players currently playing CS according to Steam, with a peak in the past 24 hours at ~65000. For CS:S, the numbers are 38000 and 50000 respectively.
- onemoreact 15y agoThat's not all that popular for an online game. There are probably 20-100 times as many people playing Warcraft over time same time frame. It's about at the level of EVE online which is a vary nitch MMO. Distributed Systems Architect Jacky Mallett explained that “we hit a new peak of online usage, 63,170 users online concurrently” on January 23 http://www.pcgamer.com/2011/03/02/eve-online-has-over-360000-players-63170-simultaneous-users-in-january/ http://www.pcgamer.com/2011/03/02/eve-online-has-over-360000... PS: Considering the player base and ongoing subscription costs I would not be surprised if wow peak's at 2,000,000 - 3,000,000 players at the same time.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoTo be fair, sports players may be forced into that by needing to put in the often-mentioned 10 000 hours before they get too old to compete.
- jodrellblank 15y agoHe will say he is happy and mean it. Wish him well." What's that supposed to mean? He will say he is happy and mean it, but really he isn't? DFW committed suicide, I don't hold him as a great authority on what kinds of happiness are 'valid'.
- arctangent 15y agoDFW is comparing one-dimensional geniuses to people who are retarded in some way. (Mental, emotional, social... take your pick.) The person is happy only because they're so oblivious to the things that they're missing out on, and their very nature prevents them from gaining this knowledge. Were they able to know what they were missing then they might not be so happy with their limited existence.
- jodrellblank 15y agoImplying that seeing what they are missing out on and not being happy with their limited existence is better. But seeing what you're missing out on sucks. Being unhappy because you have a limited existence sucks as an experience. And it's not like you have an unlimited existence if you aren't a world class sports person, is it? You have different limits, but they aren't better or worse objectively. You can't trade tens of millions of adoring fans against a deep appreciation of city street planning and architecture and say one is undoubtedly better and the other certainly worse.
- praptak 15y ago> Were they able to know what they were missing then they might not be so happy with their limited existence. Attaching any weight to what you're missing out is a guaranteed way to make you unhappy and has nothing to do with what you do in life. Even with unlimited resources you'll miss out on most things that require huge time commitment, like being a pro athlete.
- shadytrees 15y agoDFW references this argument in his fiction, so I'll try to do it justice: I respectfully disagree. Depression does not stem from "I don't what happiness is". A depressed person is aware of happiness, of the fact that he or she right now should be happy because everybody else at the dinner table is laughing and having a great time, of the fact that he or she knows how to pretend happy and a great time while at the same time hating the pretension. Being depressed is constantly looking onto happiness but being denied access; being depressed is being depressed about the fact that you don't have access, which in turn makes you more depressed. I don't think the way DFW meant to end that sentence is "but he really isn't". That paragraph, that entire piece really, is about the audience's predatory relationship with athletes. That last paragraph is addressed at people who watch, not people who participate. Michael Joyce is happy; we should just be wary of the kind of happiness.
- Shivetya 15y agoI don't think the issue is confined to athletics, looks at the people who populate television. Groomed for their looks and outrageous behavior a very similar numbers strike out in the real world once their careers are over. Toss is all the abuse they put their skin and bodies through to maintain the persona they show to us daily.
- Shorel 15y agoTo be good at something you have to make sacrifices, but it doesn't mean the sacrifices are the kind of things we can look with contempt. Take for example a Formula 1 driver, or a violin player, or a guitar player. All they need to do is practice, and practice, and practice a little more. In fact, right now, I wish I wasted less time in my teens and twenties trying to be 'normal' and meeting girls and going to parties and all that stuff, I should have invested more time doing weird hacking stuff and learning vector algebra and physics. Normality is very overrated. That's what I'm going to teach my children.