7 ms·
The Rest of the Story (Yammer & Scala)
- jbellis 15y ago"If someone asks me for an honest opinion of them or their work, in private, I feel morally compelled to be as honest as I can with them." I can vouch for that. Around a year ago I asked him for feedback on Cassandra and his response was both thoughtful and helpful. I appreciated that a lot. Thanks, Coda.
- djb_hackernews 15y agoIs that response public?
- johnx123-up 15y agoCan you share that Cassandra feedback, please?
- swah 15y agoHe wouldn't say that in public because it would be harmful to the Scala community, but everyone who read it is very glad for having read it. But if everyone thinks this way, those innovations will have one view on the web (where there is an image to care for) and another one of engineering departments, where people get real... and that sucks.
- nosequel 15y agoI think his point was that the original email was very particular to his use, and it might not have the same issues used by different people. So his public opinion of Scala wouldn't be him lying, it would be him generalizing it more. He was asked what the problems were so he answered. If it was a general post about the language, more care would have probably been given to point out both the negatives and positives. My .02 on how I read the various posts.
- technomancy 15y agoObviously he took the time to write this post in such detail because he hopes that its intended recipients can take action to address the issues he raises. It's not like there isn't already plenty of Scala bashing going around these days anyway.
- tptacek 15y agoHe's not even a little wrong about HN.
- DanielRibeiro 15y agoIn HN's defense, the original email contains relevant information, and it should get attention. Of course, it has to be understand in context, as things change (specially after such thoughtful email) and not every app has the same constraints as the Yammer. Not all of HN's discussion is keen on it, but often some of it has good signal.
- orenmazor 15y agoHe's not. And so I laughed when I opened this thread and the highest rated comment was a java vs scala post. Rather than a reply to his thesis.
- mhansen 15y agoA Java vs Scala post is far more interesting to me than discussing the "shut up about the tools and just work" thesis.
- CPlatypus 15y agoHe's not wrong, but at the same time I don't think anybody who so enjoys pissing contests on Twitter can afford to be too condescending about slapfights on HN. The last thing either place needs is more hipper-than-thou posturing.
- castaside72 15y agoPompous. If you ever tried to use Yammer's "API" you wouldn't be asking this guy for an opinion on anything.
- ShardPhoenix 15y agoWhy are the needs of the "Scala community" to save face more important than the truth?
- parfe 15y agoEvangelists sold a bills of goods to non-technical managers. Can't be letting something silly like facts or criticism get in the way of putting a pet language choice into production.
- weego 15y agoThe reality of the Scala community is that most of the major players (the Typesafe side) prior to commercialising directly were hoping for some level of popular adoption with devs that would bubble up into startups/SME and for whatever reason that hasn't happened. So now they are banking on the idea they can sell directly into large enterprise space as a one size fits all approach that involves cross training developers (as there are very few out there due to the mentioned lack of adoption). This is pretty risky and needs momentum that can easily be killed by negative stories. A lot in the original email is correct (I can't speak for the performance stuff as my skills are more webdev side of Scala), especially the way that libraries/OSS projects/sbt pan out. Something like Dispatch that is a fantastic tool and should be simple is a mess of functions-as-operators and poor to no documentation or examples to the point where for some things even reading the source code is not a lot of help. I'm not going to type out my thoughts on the shambles that was the sbt rewrite at 0.10+... just complete madness.
- michaelochurch 15y agoHere's why I, personally, prefer to put all my investment into languages like Scala and Clojure. Scala and Clojure, for their problems (which are not severe, but not to be ignored) have the advantage of being closer to the languages and approaches of the future, in which building comprehensible systems at very high levels of complexity/intellectual intricacy will be even more important relative to performance of executables. I expect that the problems of these languages (including performance) are going to become much less major over time, just as performance gaps between Java and C and between C and hand-written assembly have nearly disappeared. Spending another 5 years in Java means you're preparing yourself for a 1996 job in 2016. Why Scala and Clojure? Unfortunately, the 10-year forecasts for Haskell and Ocaml aren't great. I wish they were, because those are great languages. The reason: libraries and tooling matter, and they seem to be mattering more as the years pass (while differences in performance between languages narrow and matter less over time). Hiring and talent: It's true that you can't hire 50 Scala programmers per month. On the other hand, most startups are far away from being in a position to hire 50 programmers per month at all, much less 50 good ones. Choosing an "esoteric" language works both ways. On one hand, it reduces the total pool of ready developers. On the other hand, I know companies that use Haskell and Ocaml and are able to hire 60-75% of their in-office interviewers while remaining selective; this would be impossible for a Java shop-- there are just too many unqualified Java developers. Choosing a language like Scala or Clojure will do a lot of the filtering for you.
- brown9-2 15y agoI don't see how someone writing Java in 2016 would be stuck in a 1996 job. Is the same true of someone using C or C++ today?
- michaelochurch 15y agoIt depends what the person's using the language for. I'd say "no" for C. C is still the leading language for a lot of purposes: operating systems, runtimes for higher-level languages, device drivers, and applications where tight control of memory use is important. In these domains, C hasn't been supplanted yet-- not even close. I don't know that C++ and Java have substantial domains in which they're superior to other choices. C++ is a badly-conceived cross between C and high-level languages and Java is the worst of the JVM languages.
- melling 15y agoIt's good to see honest evaluations of technologies. It helps people better decide when something is mature enough to adopt for their organization, and helps in avoiding the landmines when they do. It also lets the the "owners" know what is impeding adoption so they have better focus. Scala is several years old now and really is gaining adoption in larger (ie conservative) firms. Scala is far from perfect and has some warts, but that's the type of technology that always seems to win. C++ vs Eiffel, Intel vs Motorola.
- martingordon 15y agoI'm curious to know why Yammer went with Scala to begin with (not to imply that it was a bad decision at the time). Was it Language of the Week the week they started building Yammer? Were they trying to follow in Twitter's footsteps? Were they a bunch of Java developers looking for something better than Java? Did someone on the team have previous Scala experience? Would Yammer be where it is today had they gone with Java (or another language, JVM or not)? Before running into the limitations described in the leaked email, was everyone happy with Scala?
- castaside72 15y agoTheir whole product is a ripoff of Twitter so that was probably it.
- foobarbazetc 15y agoNot just Twitter. Twitter and Facebook combined.
- headius 15y agoI can appreciate that having a personal opinion about Scala's use in one particular context belched out into the world is unfortunate, but I have to say that Coda's email reads like my laundry list of concerns about Scala. I could have written this email just by theorizing about Scala's shortcomings based on my short time playing with it. Except in this case, it's correlated with real-world stories. I like Scala, and I think it's the most powerful and flexible mainstream language available today. Unfortunately, that's the problem.
- donjigweed 15y agoWow. If this is Charles Nutter I'm surprised no one has commented on this. I'm sure someone could make the argument that as there is ample evidence that humans are much less rational than we typically care to admit, that we are feeling animals who also happen to think rather than thinking animals who also happen to feel, so it is that the creator of what it is today easily the most popular non-Java JVM language could conceivably be "blinded" by their own personal investment in a "competing" language. But I think the much more interesting fact about this comment is that the commenter is basically a fucking programming god. And he thinks Scala is too complex. If I was Colebourne I would be posting on my blog, a very short post, basically just saying "Hey, all you bitches telling me 'Yeah, yeah, yeah, you wrote a little date library, WTF are you again?' Does Charles Nutter carry enough weight for you?" My own personal viewpoint is that the Nutters and Colebournes are totally on the money. I remember reading a quote from Miguel DeAcaza talking about thread based concurrency programming models in the new N-core paradigm, he said it didn't scale, because "there are not enough PhDs in the world." Despite it's name, I don't think Martin's baby will in the end have lived up to it. Didn't scale, not enough PhDs in the world.
- SWengineer 15y agoYammer using or not using Scala isn't going to make or break the language. Adoption seems to be ramping up in organisations of all sizes: http://thecodegeneral.wordpress.com/2011/11/27/scala-adoption/ http://thecodegeneral.wordpress.com/2011/11/27/scala-adoptio...
- cfontes 15y agoI am getting more and more tried about this kind of arguments, I am studding Scala and I like it, It can be right for some things and wrong for others, it's just another tool in my toolbox like Java, JavaScript, Ruby... You gotta have tools, and be able to choose between a Hammer and a screwdriver when needed, that's the real "Hacker"
- rbxbx 15y agoCan't help but upvote half the replies in this thread. Sometimes I forget how many ridiculously smart people hang out around here. Happy to be amongst you all, even as a generally passive participant.
- jdefarge 15y agoCoda's opinions, even if leaked, were highly appreciated. This guy has invested a lot of time on Scala so it's in better position to say what he thinks about the language. In the end, it should help to fix imperfections and help the community.
- randysavage25 15y agoI would like to see a time where JVM languages completely overshadow and remove Java from the scene, leaving only the VM itself as a requirement. It's a terribly depressing tool to use, and it's frustrating when I have to refer to it when using Scala or Clojure, particularly in I/O .
- randysavage25 15y agoI would like to see a time where JVM languages completely overshadow and remove Java from the scene, leaving only the VM itself as a requirement. It's a terribly depressing tool to use, and it's frustrating when I have to refer to it when using Scala or Clojure, particularly in I/O .