4 ms·
How is tethered data access a "most basic" term of service, though? I mean, it's more or less by definition undetectable by the carrier. They can't (in the ge
by ajross 15y ago
How is tethered data access a "most basic" term of service, though?
I mean, it's more or less by definition undetectable by the carrier. They can't (in the general case) tell what you're doing with those bytes. But they sell them anyway.
The issue with tethering is practical. "Usually" desktop software uses "more" data than "mobile" software. Sometimes. So they outlaw it and try to sell it as an upgrade, but it's a fragile hack. It will always be a fragile hack.
That they write it into their contact verbiage doesn't make it inviolable. They have lots of other crap in there that people ignore routinely, I'm sure. Why is this one special?
- tptacek 15y agoIt's "most basic" in the sense that it's among the very first things spelled out in the terms of service you agree to when you sign up for data service with AT&T. How easy or hard tethering is to detect has zero to do with the validity of that contract.
- ajross 15y agoI honestly think you're flat wrong about that. Contract terms aren't like code. They have squishy validity that depends on interpretation. IANAL, obviously, but I think the ability of one side to even tell whether or not the contract condition was violated certainly does have an effect on whether that clause is enforceable. Companies put all kinds of crap into contracts. It's routine that this stuff turns out not to be enforceable when and if it goes to court. My quibble is that you're starting from a weird place in your argument: it's OK for Apple to pull an app because a different company decided to put something in their contract. And you wave that away by saying that it's "obviously" a violation. And I don't see the obviously part at all.
- tptacek 15y agoThe app doesn't violate AT&T's contract. Using the app does. You haven't read AT&T's contract, or you wouldn't have phrased your objection this way. Go read it and guess why I predicted you hadn't already.
- ajross 15y agoOK, timeout. Now you're just flaming. The words "an application which overtly contravenes one of the very first terms of the AT&T wireless terms of service" are yours, not mine. So now you've completely lost me. Can you explain from scratch why you think Apple is justified in enforcing AT&T contract verbiage on the rest of the iOS world? I just don't see it, sorry.
- tptacek 15y agoBy definition, "tethering" means "using your data service to enable another device to access the Internet". If you look at the contract --- which, again, respectfully, I don't think you've bothered to do yet --- there's no way you can accidentally violate the term. I'm just not interested in arguing with you about whether tethering clauses are enforceable or not. We both know that Apple wasn't going to allow this app into the store. Everyone here knows that. I'm also not interested in arguing about whether Apple has a legitimate interest in enforcing AT&T's contract. They obviously don't care whether you think their reasoning is legitimate, and they have far more arbitrary restrictions on app store apps than "designed specifically to contravene AT&T and Verizon contracts".