3 ms·
I think it shows market failure when someone can offer exactly the same service as a competitor (an S3 API) for an 80% lower price, and not almost immediately t
by londons_explore 4y ago
I think it shows market failure when someone can offer exactly the same service as a competitor (an S3 API) for an 80% lower price, and not almost immediately take over the whole market.
I think governments need to step in and require that compute platforms like AWS are split up into constituent parts, and there is no cost disadvantage to mix-n-matching between suppliers. Eg. VM's on Azure and storage across the road in AWS should not require payment of egress fees that wouldn't be payable within either providers network.
- fabian2k 4y agoFor storage you need trust, an S3 competitor doesn't help me if they lose my data or are unreliable. It takes time to earn that trust, and it's far from easy for small competitors to do that.
- vlovich123 4y agoThere's also performance / availability / capacity things to consider as well. It may be for some, but the $/storage isn't typically the whole story.
- adam_arthur 4y agoThere's a natural stickiness to cloud infra and SaaS which lends providers a pseudo monopolistic pricing power, even when competitors are present. Some regulation requiring a common API and one click solution to transfer between providers would help solve this. Needs to be implemented intelligently though
- londons_explore 4y agoOne simple way to do it would be if the FTC announced: > From January 1st 2023, we will consider it anti-competitive for cloud providers to price internal service bandwidth at a rate lower than internet bandwidth to a competing service.
- adam_arthur 4y agoYeah, a lot of thought needs to be put into the actual rule, but something along these lines... While accounting for unintended consequences
- throwaway48484 4y agoBig companies like Amazon, Google or Microsoft could set the price to zero, and their smaller competitors would be losing a lot of money each month? Basically an easy way to get rid of the competition Sounds like it would mostly benefit the large companies It would be better if internet was considered basic infrastructure and funded by taxes like roads.