4 ms·
The general problem with ion engines is that the exhaust velocity is too high. This makes them energy inefficient. Ideally, you want the exhaust velocity of a
by pfdietz 4y ago
The general problem with ion engines is that the exhaust velocity is too high. This makes them energy inefficient. Ideally, you want the exhaust velocity of a rocket to start out very low, then increase as the vehicle goes faster. That way, the ejected reaction mass is left stationary in the initial reference frame, with no kinetic energy (or, nearly stationary, with low kinetic energy). All the energy therefore goes into the kinetic energy of the vehicle.
This is also part of why using liquid hydrogen in the first stage of launchers is dumb, vs. using hydrocarbons.
- ben_w 4y agoGiven all frames of motion are relative, I thought it was more about gravitational potential than kinetic energy?
- pfdietz 4y agoAny frame of reference can be chosen, and energy is conserved in each. So choose the reference frame in which you are initially at rest.
- hedora 4y agoHmm. So maybe using this to accelerate protons would be better. (I also wonder what happens if a spaceship bleeds a measurable fraction of its weight in electrons, then tries to coast away from the resulting negatively charged cloud.)
- ben_w 4y ago0.05% of your total mass is electrons[0], so you can't do that even if you removed all of them. Well before you even get that far, your electric field strength exceeds the binding forces of the molecules you're made of, so you explode. Well before you get to the point of exploding, your net electric charge is too strong for you to eject more electrons, and any electrons in the ambient environment will fly towards you, producing a shower of deadly radiation when they hit your hull. [0] assuming you're mostly hydrogen; a bit less than half that if you're mostly made of heavier elements like Uranium