3 ms·
I read through this thinking it was a bit pessimistic, so the twist didn't really hit me in the intended way. Like aren't we already projected to be at level p
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I read through this thinking it was a bit pessimistic, so the twist didn't really hit me in the intended way.
Like aren't we already projected to be at level population growth by 2100?
But it's the weird fossil fuel cultism that gets me:
> Besides the fact that we have never built any alternative energy infrastructure (dams, photovoltaics, turbines, nuclear) without extensive reliance on fossil fuels, it is not clear how non-renewable materials could be coaxed to maintain a renewable energy infrastructure for the long term.
What specific thing is it hard to do without fossil fuels?
Trucks? Steel? Concrete? Mining? Boats? Give me some details please as I feel you're wrong but you're being very coy about the details so I can't tell you why you are wrong.
More importantly, put a figure on it, what percent of the total absolutely requires fossil fuels which are today, right now more expensive than renewable energy.
What price would renewables need to get to in order to build those apparently necessary fossil fuels from the air with green electricity? This kind of puts an upper limit on the price of avoiding this doom.
edit: he does in fact link to more in depth fossil fuel cultism:
https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2022/06/shedding-our-fossil-fuel-suit/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2022/06/shedding-our-fossil-fuel-...
Apparently heating things is the Achilles heel of renewables. Just not possible without fossil fuels.
I mean we can literally make fossil fuels with electricity. So that doesn't seem a blocker anyway, but surely someone will figure out how to heat things with electricity? I mean there must be some way to work around the fact that putting too much electricity through metal will melt it? And how are we going to melt metal if the metal things we build to melt the metal also melt when we put electricity through them. It's a conundrum, but surely some genius will solve it.
Also, I didn't realise how correct I was to refer to this as cult-like:
> That leaves the question: if most of what we praise about ourselves is not so much us but our fossil fuel suit (we do look good in it, don’t we?), then what’s left when our empire loses its cladding? Just how feeble, pathetic, and dull are we, under that thick and powerful shroud?
He literally thinks we can't invent new things without fossil fuels. That's a very weird belief.
- AlgorithmicTime 4y ago
- suoduandao2 4y agoRegarding the question 'what specific thing is it hard to do without fossil fuels', the answer, from what I've seen of that side of the debate, is that the problem isn't technical but economic. To attempt to steelman the argument AIUI: If we replace the EROI of fossil fuels with the EROI of renewables, a much larger portion of the economy will have to be dedicated to generating energy. This will make everything more expensive, and a lot of activity we take for granted today will be too expensive to be maintained, even though it might still be technically feasible. Even the leisure time to invent new and better energy sources will be displaced by people needing more time to chop their own firewood etc[1], and free capital to invest in new inventions will similarly be much harder to come by than when we were all comparatively rich due to the fossil subsidy. There will be knock-on effects in the complexity of society, which is currently able to maintain a high level of complexity and specialization because the high costs of complexity (e.g. longer supply chains) is being subsidized by the low cost of energy. It's not a terrible argument, though it clearly is making a doomer assumption at every turn. Currently, google tells me that the EROI of crude oil and solar PV are ~20 and ~10 respectively - which does represent a significant tightening of the total wealth available if we contemplated switching everything today. The more optimistic counterpoint, is that the current EROI of fossils is diminishing, and will meet the EROI of renewables at some point, where by this logic the maintainable complexity of society would stabilize. Hopefully that still allows us to have a microchip foundry somewhere, though I haven't seen anyone reliably crunch the numbers one way or another. [1]pointing out that Nikola Tesla invented a lot of things while employed digging ditches is not part of a proper steelman.
- ElevenLathe 4y agoNaively, if our EROI halves, then we should be at worst half as rich, right? If that's the case then (again, very naively) you might expect that we would "merely" have to accept an average standard of living from when the world was half as rich, which would be about 2003-2004.Now, the world was much more very unevenly developed in 2003, so that doesn't mean rich countries won't have to come down while poor ones come up, but it doesn't sound apocalyptic to return to the Bush years in terms of wealth. That said, I think the naive interpretation is wrong. IMO most of the wealth we've been creating since the 19th century is mainly about the task of applying cheap energy to new problems: perfecting power looms, artificial fertilizer, transportation, etc. If the energy becomes twice as expensive, it's not clear that we would only be half as rich. We might in fact be much much poorer than our ancestors were before the cheap energy, because the biosphere (our previous primary source of low-entropy raw material) is in far worse shape than it was in 1800 and needs to support many more people. One hope is that green energy can actually exceed the EROI of fossil energy. If we can get high-efficiency, long-life (don't have to replace it for 100 years or more) PV, then it should be pretty easy to exceed fossil fuels' EROI. You have to dig more coal for every unit of coal-fired work, whereas you can manufacture a solar panel once and let it do unlimited units of work as long as it exists and the sun is shining.
- FollowingTheDao 4y ago> Also, I didn't realise how correct I was to refer to this as cult-like: I like his cult better than the cult we are in right now. We live in a weird death cult which focus on greed and ignores the sufferings of others.
- hosh 4y agoHave you heard Paul Levy’s talks or articles on Wetiko?
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoThanks, I’ll be sending an email soon.