4 ms·
"Wire" is effectively the air passing around a cylinder. There is a lot of information about airflow around cylinders. Eg [1]. The top left diagram should b
by londons_explore 4y ago
"Wire" is effectively the air passing around a cylinder.
There is a lot of information about airflow around cylinders. Eg [1]. The top left diagram should be the one that applies with small diameters and the kind of airflow rates in a PC fan.
I would guess that all the other shapes have micro-scale sharp edges that leave vortexes which both slow the flow down and make noise.
[1]: https://i.ytimg.com/vi/pW0JfEBE9h8/maxresdefault.jpg https://i.ytimg.com/vi/pW0JfEBE9h8/maxresdefault.jpg
- jongala 4y agoI agree, it feels like a missed opportunity to not explore this. I'd love to see an analysis of the swirl design (or other commonly used manufacturer patterns), with the edges rounded or beveled on the intake face, exhaust face, or both. Like, even on cut or stamped grills, how much could performance be improved by e.g. sandblasting the finished piece from one or both sides and taking down the edges a bit?
- londons_explore 4y agoThe wire is only just laminar flow... I found a random PC fan and assumed a 1mm wire diameter, 2.3m/s airflow, and the reynolds number comes out at 36. That tells me if you were to get a 1000x really powerful fan, then the grille would start giving turbulent flow, and might no longer perform the best. Page with lots of details: http://labman.phys.utk.edu/phys221core/modules/m8/turbulence.html#:~:text=The%20air%20behind%20the%20cylinder,of%20approximately%202000%20to%20100000 http://labman.phys.utk.edu/phys221core/modules/m8/turbulence....
- simne 4y agoThis is 10 years ago article, coolers tech changed a lot since that. I even remember, when in mac clones used ultra-high-speed coolers, which now used only in rack devices. And yes, ultra-high-speed coolers, has much higher speed and make turbulence.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoI mean that's the main difference between the wire and all the others, really; the wire is round metal, the others are shapes stamped from flat metal. That said, my current PC has plastic "angled slats" at the back (outlet) and a honeycomb and mesh (filter) at the front, so it could be quieter. I'll keep it in mind if I ever buy a new one. I believe the wire one was the most common on older PCs (90's / 2000's).
- ridgered4 4y agoI seem to recall the wire covers being on the IBM XT power supply so I think they are the OG.
- londons_explore 4y agoAnd 'stamped from flat metal' has a cross section of a cuboid... And a cuboid is also the shape of a brick... And there is that old expression... "As aerodynamic as a brick...".
- Darkphibre 4y agoAh yes, just like the space shuttle. ;) "They took a high-performance business jet, added extra drag, and ran the engines in reverse to simulate a flying manhole cover." https://youtu.be/pfNQW4jToHE?t=340 https://youtu.be/pfNQW4jToHE?t=340
- carabiner 4y agoThe problem is you have very messy flow originating from the fan with a ton of swirl, so it is likely not like the top left diagram and more like the bottom two. It's totally unsteady flow, like in this CFD: https://www.automotivetestingtechnologyinternational.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/Lead-e1620818346517.jpg https://www.automotivetestingtechnologyinternational.com/wp-... Wind tunnels use honeycomb flow straighteners to take care of this. A full blown analysis might use computational aeroacoustics software that can calculate the noise generated from solid geometry in a given flow. This field has advanced considerably since when the article was published due to newer methods like LBM. It'd be beyond the scope of journalism like this, but it is no doubt done by companies with resources like Apple.