3 ms·
I think Windows solved this much better than libc by separating the concerns: there's user32.dll providing a thin abstraction over syscalls, a couple libraries
by wongarsu 4y ago
I think Windows solved this much better than libc by separating the concerns: there's user32.dll providing a thin abstraction over syscalls, a couple libraries providing higher-level interfaces like wintrust.dll, and thirdly the C runtime library providing all the stuff mandated by C. You can easily ditch the latter, while still keeping the benefits of user32.dll (which cosmopolitan is doing).
- lgg 4y agomacOS essentially has the same distinction internally (libsystem_kernel.dylib), but that is not directly linkable and is instead re-exported via the libSystem umbrella which also exports libsystem_c.dylib. While you cannot link directly to libsystem_kernel.dylib, if you choose to ignore everything in libsystem_c.dylib and only use the syscall wrappers reexported from libsystem_kernel.dylib via libSystem it has practically the same effect on macOS (in fact, the resulting binary will be identical to what a hypothetical binary linked to just a single libsystem_kernel.dylib would be except for a single `LC_LOAD_DYLIB` command). Such a binary would have the system lib c initialized sitting in its address space, but for the rare binary that really wants its own libc that doesn't seem unreasonable.