5 ms·
I am in conflict with them because they have similar toxic entitlement: in their case, to private user data that does not belong to them. Homebrew embeds nonco
by sneak 4y ago
I am in conflict with them because they have similar toxic entitlement: in their case, to private user data that does not belong to them.
Homebrew embeds nonconsensual Google spyware that phones home with a unique identifier supercookie every time you use it. This correlates client IPs (geolocation) and allows Google to know your travel history. Rather than asking for consent, it is on by default.
They close issues about it without discussion, despite opt-out surveillance like this being deeply unethical (which is why Debian et al do not do it).
- Etheryte 4y agoI think you need to check yourself here. Homebrew is giving something to the world for free, that they do it on their terms is not entitlement, it's their right. If you don't like it you can go elsewhere. You thinking that you should have some input on what terms they give their work away for free is what's nose up entitlement here.
- sneak 4y ago
- ehutch79 4y agoHow exactly is it spyware? When you say that, i'm expecting to hear about keystroke loggers, or hoovering up session cookies or something.
- capableweb 4y ago> Spyware is software with malicious behavior that aims to gather information about a person or organization and send it to another entity in a way that harms the user—for example, by violating their privacy or endangering their device's security Definitions vary, of course. But generally I think GA could be seen as spyware unless you tweak it by removing information.
- akerl_ 4y ago> malicious behavior What’s the malicious behavior here? They’re tracking how much usage each homebrew formula has.
- capableweb 4y agoThe malicious behavior is gathering information about a person or organization. Opt-out makes this not great for user privacy, while opt-in would.
- elondaits 4y agoFor anyone wondering: Homebrew sends data to Google Analytics (https://docs.brew.sh/Analytics https://docs.brew.sh/Analytics) on installs, build breaks, and other events. It's an opt-out setting. Google Analytics violates the European privacy laws (GDPR). Although Homebrew sends a random Homebrew-only analytics user ID, Google gets access to the user's IP and behavioral data. Although Google claims to anonymize the user's IP address, laws like the GDPR intend to protect our private data even in the face of accidental leaking, hacking, and state-actors who could force Google's hand at storing and disclosing it.
- aliqot 4y agoGo does this too :/
- pdimitar 4y agoDo you happen to know if it's possible to deny-list a host/IP in my PiHole setup so Golang tools keep working fine but can't send analytics?
- akerl_ 4y agoYou don’t need anything that complex; just set GOPROXY to direct in your environment. More details here: https://proxy.golang.org/ https://proxy.golang.org/
- sneak 4y ago
- jeltz 4y agoJust because you are giving away something for free does not entitle you to break the law in Europe. I am more forgiving to people who give away something for free but it is not a carte blanche, morally or legally, to act like an asshole and break the law. Spyware vendors also give away their work for free and your Facebook account is also free. Does that mean these entities can do whatever they like?
- hk__2 4y ago> Spyware vendors also give away their work for free and your Facebook account is also free. Does that mean these entities can do whatever they like? Yes. (as long as they respect the law, like anybody)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wilde 4y agoThen don’t use it?
- jeltz 4y agoI did not know about this issue until now. But, sure, if you let me borrow your time machine.
- akerl_ 4y agoThe first time you run homebrew, it tells you it’s going to record usage analytics, with details on how to find out more or disable that behavior.
- JohnFen 4y agoBut does it tell you it's using GA?
- akerl_ 4y agoIt tells you it’s recording usage data, and links you to the docs that show where it goes, how to view the data yourself, how to opt out, and why the collect the data: https://github.com/Homebrew/brew/blob/68e895ad4d374b4a0022613a20bd046d6487dfd9/Library/Homebrew/cmd/update-report.rb#L95 https://github.com/Homebrew/brew/blob/68e895ad4d374b4a002261... https://docs.brew.sh/Analytics https://docs.brew.sh/Analytics
- mikemcquaid 4y agoPersonally, I find it toxic that you insist on posting this on literally every thread I see about Homebrew. Ironically, you demonstrate my point from the article. You feel entitled to Homebrew having different analytics behaviour and in demanding the time and effort from myself or other maintainers to make it behave how you want it to.
- sneak 4y ago
- ctrlmeta 4y agoI don't see the parent comment as necessarily an entitlement. They are not demanding anything in particular from Homebrew project maintainers. They are informing us -- the readers -- about the analytics behavior in Homebrew so that we can make an informed decision about whether we should continue to use Homebrew or choose an alternative like macports or nix. It read more like a public service announcement to me.
- mikemcquaid 4y agoHomebrew informs you about our analytics behaviour before we send any data with a link to the documentation (https://docs.brew.sh/Analytics https://docs.brew.sh/Analytics) which in turn links to the code on new installations and on existing ones if you haven't updated since we enabled analytics.
- watwut 4y agoPersonally, I find it useful when people let me know about spyware features of software - whether in open source or not.
- zach_garwood 4y ago