4 ms·
But there are hundreds (?) of carriers worldwide, all of which support the iPhone. AT&T is just one of many. So I don't see what the AT&T TOS has to do with Ap
by crazygringo 15y ago
But there are hundreds (?) of carriers worldwide, all of which support the iPhone. AT&T is just one of many.
So I don't see what the AT&T TOS has to do with Apple's App Store. Five years ago, sure, but not now.
- tptacek 15y agoIt directly violates Verizon's terms of services too. We could (unproductively) relitigate whether Apple should police submissions to the app store at all, but as long as they do, they're obviously going to reject applications that violate the terms of the vast overwhelming majority of their US users carrier contracts.
- jonknee 15y agoIf they're set on policing, why not filter available apps by the capabilities you have? Going to the lowest common denominator seems like a bad compromise. They already filter by country and know who your carrier is, the parts are there.
- interlagos 15y ago>We could (unproductively) relitigate whether Apple should police submissions to the app store at all Transparent false dichotomy. This has nothing to do with curating versus anarchy. It is the standard of a subset of carriers in one country dictating policy for all Apple devices worldwide. Wasn't Apple the one who saved people from carrier influence and control?
- tptacek 15y agoNo matter how outraged anyone pretends to be about this incident, not a single person on this thread would have bet $50 at any odds on Apple not pulling this app out of the store. That's all I'm trying to say.
- masklinn 15y ago> But there are hundreds (?) of carriers worldwide, all of which support the iPhone. AT&T is just one of many. All of these carriers can enable the built-in access point feature of iOS. In fact, it's enabled by default so all of these carriers can not disable the built-in AP feature of iOS. > So I don't see what the AT&T TOS has to do with Apple's App Store. Five years ago, sure, but not now. The TOS in question have to do with tethering/cell-as-modem, not with the appstore, I'd guess.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- msbarnett 15y ago> But there are hundreds (?) of carriers worldwide, all of which support the iPhone. AT&T is just one of many. On the carriers which do not have a TOS forbidding free usage of the data plan for tethering, iOS's built-in tethering is already enabled, and this app violates the rule forbidding apps from duplicating built-in iOS functionality.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoThe only possible reason for this app. is to subvert a carrier's TOS, since iPhones have tethering capability built in.