7 ms·
This seems like a fairly predictable response at this point. The West has managed to pour enough weapons into the Ukraine that I gather Russia is being pressure
by roenxi 4y ago
This seems like a fairly predictable response at this point. The West has managed to pour enough weapons into the Ukraine that I gather Russia is being pressured. So the escalation spiral continues to wind up.
This continues to be very scary. The West's strategy here is stupid to the point where full scale mobilisation and war in Europe seems possible. This could have just been an Iraq 2.0.
- trasz 4y ago>The West's strategy here is stupid As opposed to the strategy of appeasing Russia, which resulted in the war we have now? Look at the numbers: half of Russia’s army is gone. Western armies, apart from Ukraine, hadn’t even entered the conflict.
- blub 4y agoWe cannot win against Russia and we cannot win against China. The performance of their regular army is not deciding, because they have an immense nuclear arsenal. It seems to me that we’re sticking our heads in the sand and either like to joke that their nukes don’t work, or that they won’t dare use them.
- scandinavian 4y ago> or that they won’t dare use them. What's to be gained by starting a nuclear war with the entire world? Or are you calling them stupid (China and Russia)?
- m000 4y ago> What's to be gained by starting a nuclear war with the entire world? Less than a year ago, the question was: What's to be gained by invading Ukraine? Putin is not stupid to start a war with nothing to gain.
- foverzar 4y agoAnd the answer is still "nothing". Russia doesn't really gain anything substantial. From Russia's point of view it is a huge price to pay for preventing another Turkey-Cuba missile crisis, except this time it is Ukraine instead of Turkey (which Russia considers even worse, given the recent revolution and government apparatus stability) and this time Russia doesn't have as much influence on American continent to deploy its own deterrent.
- m000 4y agoMy point is that the war in Ukraine showed that West has little understanding of Russia's point of view, what price Putin is willing to pay, what he perceives as a gain.
- foverzar 4y agoAh, yep, 100%, westerners impressions of Russia is something directly from fairy tales. I actually wonder if Russia somehow uses it as a part of it psyops. At least that clearly helped with the sanctions.
- trasz 4y agoExcept this point of view doesn't make any sense, because if NATO wanted to get their missiles close to Russia they could put them in, say, Poland, or Finland, instead of Ukraine. Russia's point of view is that Ukraine must be destroyed, because when it becomes more successful than Russia it would prove how terrible the Russian government is. Except this isn't particularly convincing, so Russia dropped in the Nazi ideology of "inferior Ukrainians", which kind of fits given their approach of leveling entire cities (cf Mariupol). An alternate theory would assume Russia for some reason _wants_ to lose. Because, honestly, it does look like that. If Putin wanted to make sure Russia remains isolated from the West for the upcoming couple of decades, "resetting" the situation back to late eighties to force its society to choose a different route instead... Except the whole idea seems too absurd even for them. Then again, none of this matters: we've tried appeasing Putin before, and it only provoked him to escalate. It was a logical choice to try something different this time - and it appears it worked.
- foverzar 4y ago> What's to be gained by starting a nuclear war with the entire world Who says it would be the entire world? At worst, it will be with a nuclear-capable fraction of the Western world (a really small part of the world) Besides, somehow I doubt that there won't be a very long and bloody escalation with tactical nukes - no one is going to press "end game for everyone" button until they themselves have lost completely.
- trasz 4y ago>We cannot win against Russia and we cannot win against China. China declared quite explicitly they don’t want this conflict. They also quietly joined western sanctions. As for Russia - given how the rest of Russian army turned out to be a bluff, why assume their nuclear potential is any different?
- foverzar 4y ago> They also quietly joined western sanctions. Are you sure that you don't stretch and projecy a few international Chinese companies with substantial business in the West on the whole of China?
- trasz 4y agoIt's not just Huawei that left Russian market. The entire Belt and Road infrastructure project is being redirected south to Kazakhstan. And Putin had to publicly admit China has "expressed concerns". To China, Russia is just a mafia-owned gas station. Nobody's going to fight for that.
- foverzar 4y ago> It's not just Huawei that left Russian market. Wow, it did? Huawei brand shops are open though. You can even buy a RosTest certified Huawei P50 Pro, which was released in August. In any case, this is just a fraction of Chinese business in Russia, the rest of which doesn't seem to go anywhere. Currently this looks more like political fluff, rather than anything practical. Shutting down AliExpress in Russia would be indicative, but nothing even remotely similar had happened yet. > To China, Russia is just a mafia-owned gas station. Nobody's going to fight for that. Doesn't look that way when looking at Chinese propaganda, but in any case, why would China FIGHT for Russia?
- blub 4y agoOn the mid/long term they want Taiwan back into the fold. And the US and oddly the EU seem to be ready to start a war over that. Which, like I’ve said we can’t win. The US and Russia were inspecting each-other’s nuclear stockpiles and are/were part of several disarmament treaties which are falling apart one by one. Is there any credible authority claiming that the Russian nuclear arsenal does not fulfill its deterrent role?
- 4gotunameagain 4y ago> Western armies, apart from Ukraine, hadn’t even entered the conflict. ..on paper. In reality Ukraine is infested with paramilitary organisations funded and trained by the west, fighting with western technology. Also calling Ukraine "western", is a bit of a stretch. This conflict and the subsequent propaganda has made us forget how backwards and corrupt Ukraine was, just to rally behind their support and not complain for freezing our assess to death this winter in Europe. Of course Putin is a deranged lunatic that should let go already. But the idea of a powerless Russia, or even worse, a Russia that is a puppet of China, is terrifying.
- trasz 4y ago>But the idea of a powerless Russia, or even worse, a Russia that is a puppet of China, is terrifying. This is already the case. Everyone knows Russia's military prowess was a bluff - that's why we've seen another attempt in Armenia; fortunately USA came and filled the power vacuum there. And of course Kazakhstan used that opportunity to humiliate Putin once again. Russia could theoretically balance between China and India. But it sounds like a complicated act, especially so for a failed state. I think it will end up with making sure Russia ends up being a puppet, but not a very useful one.
- r00fus 4y ago> In reality Ukraine is infested with paramilitary organisations funded and trained by the west, fighting with western technology. Do you have any cites for this?
- 4gotunameagain 4y agohttps://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2022/08/19/in-ukraine-the-mozart-group-marches-to-the-beat-of-its-own-drum_5994118_4.html https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2022/08/19/i... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/aug/05/mozart-group-western-ex-military-training-ukrainian-recruits https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/aug/05/mozart-group-w... https://www.injuredoverseas.com/u-s-private-military-contractor-killed-in-ukraine/ https://www.injuredoverseas.com/u-s-private-military-contrac...
- foverzar 4y ago> half of Russia’s army is gone Where did you get these numbers from? Russian army has 1 mil active personnel and 2 mil reserves. Even the propaganda numbers are much less than 200k killed/wounded, and that's including LNR/DNR combatants.
- trasz 4y agoThey can't keep territory because of manpower shortage, but they surely have a million others, they just can't be bothered to get them involved? :-D What you are talking about are the fictional numbers found in Russian documents. This war wouldn't look anything like it did if those numbers matched reality. (As for the numbers lost, see https://www.oryxspioenkop.com/2022/02/attack-on-europe-documenting-equipment.html https://www.oryxspioenkop.com/2022/02/attack-on-europe-docum...)
- HelloNurse 4y agoMeasuring military manpower by count of formally military personnel is naive or at least "on paper". How many of these soldiers have the vehicles, equipment and weapons to contribute effectively? If current invasion forces are running out of tanks, what should the reinforcements use?
- foverzar 4y ago> They can't keep territory because of manpower shortage, but they surely have a million others, they just can't be bothered to get them involved? :-D Ergo mobilization, that, among other things, changes the way the military and military industrial complex operates and allows allocating resources and setting priorities more freely? > What you are talking about are the fictional numbers found in Russian documents. This war wouldn't look anything like it did if those numbers matched reality Well of course, this war looks like it looks cuz the reality of involved force does not match the reality of total force, ergo mobilization. > (As for the numbers lost, see https://www.oryxspioenkop.com/2022/02/attack-on-europe-docum https://www.oryxspioenkop.com/2022/02/attack-on-europe-docum...) Ugh, referring to some blog as a solid source is kinda wierd, but ok, I see > Russia - 6202, of which: destroyed: 3844, damaged: 143, abandoned: 303, captured: 1911 So, does this mean that you imply that Russia's army is only like 13000 total altogether?
- desindol 4y agoIt’s good that we finally stopped appeasing every dictator with some cheap energy.
- roenxi 4y agoWe're setting up a situation here where China will likely end up ascendant. The big thing the West has in its favour is control of financial flows and services which are a huge edge in long periods of peace. A serious war could break out and it appears neither China nor India are that worried about Ukraine. We're going to end up torpedoing all the systems that keep us wealthy and comfortable as Asia gets serious about securing itself and has a real reason to break away from the US's world order. Russia has a lot of energy to offer other Asian partners, China has motives to support this sort of war and India I don't know what they will decide to do but there are big opportunities here for them. And in exchange for these strategic blunders, we're getting ... war, corpses, money wasted building weapons and serious threats of nuclear war. This is a really bad situation for anyone in a country that speaks English as an official language. At least, probably a couple of other American satellites are worried too. We're not getting anything here in exchange for warming the situation up by arming Russia's enemies and laughing loudly at their government. Even if this hadn't led to a partial mobilisation of a nuclear power, sending huge numbers of weapons to a country famous for its corruption was a bloody stupid idea to start with.
- desindol 4y agoWe should really thrive to get a better history education into our school curiculums these comments are so malinformed it's actually dangerous.
- remarkEon 4y agoThe parent post is a little glib, but the concern about how China and especially India will react is accurate. There's somewhat of a tipping point happening in world history, as we edge into the post-9/11 era.
- yladiz 4y ago
- arianvanp 4y agoExtremely sad to see this blunt rethoric here. The amount of cruelty that Russia is causing in Ukraine (not the Ukraine) is enormous. If we don't fight back it will cause decades of suffering and pain. Spinning this to a problem caused by the West is extremely naive.
- remarkEon 4y ago>If we don't fight back Who is the "we" here? Edit: To make an attempt at preventing flamebait, I'm asking who the "we" is that is being asked to sign up to fight back directly against Russia, and whether or not there is a proper democratic feedback mechanism in place to support such a fight. I've seen war, and wish to see this one deescalate.
- roenxi 4y ago> If we don't fight back it will cause decades of suffering and pain. What has the West done that will reduce the amount of suffering? Who is suffering less thanks to the US's efforts to make the war more brutal? It isn't even that obvious that the Ukrainians would be badly off in some hypothetical world where they were conquered by Russia. They will definitely be worse off now that there is a partly mobilised army heading towards their territory. Russia is ramping up the destruction that they are going to unleash. In a predictable fashion, responding to actions by people who aren't interested in reducing suffering, calming things down or promoting peace. I don't fault the Ukrianian's for defending themselves, but the US deserves a lot of heat for the strategic mess they're manoeuvring in to.
- yladiz 4y agoSo you’re saying, let me check my notes… let Russia win because of reasons including “reducing suffering” and “Ukraine wouldn’t be that much worse off if Russia conquered it”. This feels like you’re basically saying that Ukraine is not an answer here, because their suffering has been reduced thanks to the west and obviously Ukraine doesn’t think they would be better off if they capitulated, and they’re the only ones who should be able to make that call. Excuse my Russian but idi nahui with that kind of thinking.
- Zanfa 4y ago> The West's strategy here is stupid to the point where full scale mobilisation and war in Europe seems possible. You're right about this. The correct response would have been an immediate complete embargo of Russia and boots on the ground support in Ukraine when the invasion started.
- foverzar 4y ago> The correct response would have been an immediate complete embargo of Russia Non-implementable > boots on the ground support in Ukraine Somehow I feel that these are implied to be someone else's boots, but definitely not yours.