3 ms·
This is a fundamental confusion borne of the historical accident that resulted in digital computers being called "computers" instead of "switches" or "controlle
by kragen 4y ago
This is a fundamental confusion borne of the historical accident that resulted in digital computers being called "computers" instead of "switches" or "controllers" or "logics" or "coders" or "analytical engines" or "programmable data processors" or something.
Analog "computers" are a totally different kind of thing. You can't run a compiler, solve an equation, play chess, or encrypt a message on an analog computer. It's not that they do those things slower or more expensively or in more space than digital "computers"; they just can't do them at all. (Except by simulating a digital computer, of course.)
We call computers "computers" because the first ones were built to do what analog "computers" do: numerical integration of ordinary differential equations, like Modelica does. (Eventually they were faster and cheaper than analog computers at that, but it took 20 years in many cases, and even today, we use analog circuits for things like RF downconversion.) But they can also do those other things.
In theory, the relationship with quantum computers is kind of similar. Quantum computers can in theory do anything a reversible classical digital computer can do in a similar number of operations, and also some other things (though probably not, say, solve SAT in polynomial time.) And classical digital computers can simulate QC, but as with simulating a digital computer on an analog one, the simulation is so inefficient as to be infeasible in all but trivial cases.
But maybe that's backwards? Does it depend on your efficiency metric? Certainly you need quite a lot of GPUs to approach the cost of a dilution refrigerator. We'll see.
- somat 4y agoI suspect that if analog computers ever were developed to the point of being a universal computer(as opposed to the single case computers they were) the stored program and the interior operation would look a lot like what we call neural nets. A bunch of linear algebra nodes interconnected with weighted feedback curves to govern operation.
- kragen 4y agoUniversality is inherently digital.