2 ms·
I understand the SAE levels, I am saying that extreme interpretations of that sentence is silly. J3016 is about a driver automation system on an otherwise norma
by kube-system 4y ago
I understand the SAE levels, I am saying that extreme interpretations of that sentence is silly. J3016 is about a driver automation system on an otherwise normal automobile. It's not about the inherent physical capabilities of the vehicle. Level 5 doesn't require a vehicle to have studded tires to operate on ice, amphibious capabilities to operate in floods, or other extraordinary physical capabilities beyond the normal abilities of an otherwise typical underlying vehicle.
We have a while before we get anywhere close to having to consider this -- but at some point we're going to have to come to terms with the fact that a significant problem with human drivers is that they often choose to operate their vehicles in conditions beyond the safe capabilities of the vehicle given particular conditions. Neither road conditions nor the laws of physics disappear at any SAE level. These things are always something that will be taken into account.
There will always be some amount of risk that cannot be determined in advance. Even I do not know when the snow plow will go down my street, and that may determine whether I can fully make it home or not. I'm sure the folks at the SAE have driven in inclement conditions before, so it makes sense to interpret those definitions with a reasonable lens.