4 ms·
This would be such a beautiful world if only people were more selfish!
by anigbrowl 4y ago
This would be such a beautiful world if only people were more selfish!
- WalterBright 4y agoThe beauty of the free market is that instead of suppressing selfish motives, it enables them in a way that benefits society. It's why Americans live the highest standard of living in the world. Socialism fails because it relies on altruistic behavior, which is in short supply in humans.
- anigbrowl 4y ago> in a way that benefits society So when accusations of price gouging arise (say in the aftermath of a disaster), you're saying that it's the government interfering while the people in the disaster area area are eager to pay top dollar for suddenly-rare commodities like water or hand sanitizer? If I see regular-seeming people complaining about prices, should I assume they're covert government agents?
- twblalock 4y agoThose things are often suddenly rare because people hoard them, which can be prevented by allowing supply and demand to properly work. Prices should go up if goods are in more demand. In addition, the higher prices will motivate sellers to send more products to the impacted area. That eventually leads to price stabilization at the intersection of the supply and demand curve, i.e. how things are supposed to work. Do the higher prices mean some people won't get any water? Yes! But if you artificially suppress prices, there will also be some people who don't get water, because other people will hoard it.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI don't need you to explain price theory to me, and also don't find your hoarding argument persuasive, for two reasons: one, much of the demand in the aftermath of a disaster is from people who need to consume a commodity and can't get any, and two, the hoarding behavior you describe is more likely to be by price gougers hoping to engage in arbitrage. > But if you artificially suppress prices, there will also be some people who don't get water, because other people will hoard it. Rationing the volume available for purchase by individual customers is the obvious solution, and seems to have worked out just fine in practice during things like the great toilet paper panic of 2020. I'm asking Walter how he explains the fact of people complaining about high prices in such a context, given his claim that it's government spoiling the price theory party. Why are the opinions of people who are priced out discounted?
- WalterBright 4y agoHoarding toilet paper is only of value if you can resell it. Hence the total amount available remains the same. If hoarding fetches higher prices, that creates tremendous incentive to increase the supply (and/or find alternatives). If hoarding is illegal, and gouging is illegal, the result is shortages. Every time, since there is zero incentive to produce more. Rationing has other problems. It is based on the idea that everyone has the exact same need for the product. Of course, this is absurd. The result is misallocation, as some get more than they need, others get less. If reselling is made illegal (as it usually is in rationing setups), then the person with extra just throws it away, and the person who doesn't get enough has to do without. How is that better?
- anigbrowl 4y agoThis seems irrational. The need for many commodities like TP or water is fairly homogeneous and predictable, and excess is typically just used later or shared rather than abandoned. It's better in that you can maximize the number of people who have a sufficient supply to get through the emergency. Again, I'm still wondering why you cite government as the opponents of free market pricing, when the objections often originate with people who are mad about the idea of paying $75 for a bottle of hand sanitizer: https://www.today.com/news/brothers-who-hoarded-17-700-bottles-hand-sanitizer-forced-donate-t176028 https://www.today.com/news/brothers-who-hoarded-17-700-bottl...
- WalterBright 4y agoUtility is maximized by allowing supply&demand to work. No two people have the same use for any commodity - rationing provides some people with too much and the rest with too little. Nobody gets just the right amount under rationing. > government as the opponents of free market pricing, when the objections often originate with people who are mad The government does what the people demand. The people demand the government outlaw gouging, the government outlaws it.
- opo 4y agoBefore all these price gouging laws, in natural disasters there used to be marginal producers (people with a pickup truck etc.) who would load up on some supplies like ice etc. and bring them to the area that was hit to make a quick profit. When the electricity is out and someone wants $12 a bag for ice it would anger many people who just want to keep your drinks cold - but you would think it is an incredible bargain if that way you can keep your insulin chilled: https://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/y2007/Mungergouging.html https://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/y2007/Mungergouging.... In the long run, high profits during a shortage also mean that suppliers in general will be incentivized to keep a larger stockpile of goods that have a good shelf-life since they know they will be able to make good money the next time there is a shortage (more than the storage costs). (Or the potential for high profits will incentivize spending money to be more flexible in production in case demand increases for a short time.) If you are going to literally make it illegal to try this, then you better have a government be willing to spend its tax dollars on creating a stockpile - when the pandemic started we saw that all the talk of the national stockpile the federal government supposedly had was greatly exaggerated.
- palmetieri2000 4y ago>It's why Americans live the highest standard of living in the world. Some Americans*, and far fewer than those that have some of the lowest standards of living in the world. And the US has greater wealth disparity than many other countries with living standards many would argue are at least equal. Altruism isnt necessary, education is. Education teaches people that the best way to prevent the most harmful acts in society is to make sure peoples needs are met, which capitalism and the free market routinely fails at. This is why US has worse crime than other developed nations even accounting for population, you fail to meet your citizens needs within the system so they do it themselves outside of it.
- nickpp 4y ago> Altruism isnt necessary, education is. Communists tried so hard to educate us into the "New Man". For the betterment of all mankind, of course. Of course, ignoring human nature tuned the whole "experiment" into a huge, predictable failure.
- palmetieri2000 4y agoAnd seeing Soviet Russian Communism as the only possible form of socialism is shortsighted and foolish.
- nickpp 4y agoCommunism failed everywhere was tried. Countries held as socialism success stories are either oil-rich (Norway) or got rich under capitalism then managed to stunt that growth with a hard left turn (Western Europe). They then fell way behind free-market economies and became dependent and vulnerable to Russian expansion-through-cheap-energy.
- WalterBright 4y agoAmerica's crime is due to drug abuse and the government not enforcing criminal laws. People aren't stealing food to eat, they're stealing alcohol and anything they can sell to buy drugs. Americans have the highest standard of living in the world. That's why the poor from everywhere are trying to get into the US. Do you watch the news about all those migrants pouring over the border?
- twblalock 4y agoSelfishness is inevitable. You can either try to deny it and end up with a broken system where people are still selfish anyway, or you can channel it toward beneficial goals.