3 ms·
While the degree of economic extremism (perhaps better described as investment or fluency) seems to correlate well with intelligence, I think it's unlikely that
by anigbrowl 4y ago
While the degree of economic extremism (perhaps better described as investment or fluency) seems to correlate well with intelligence, I think it's unlikely that one can decide whether a given economic philosophy is the 'smarter' choice. Economic preferences may not be the outcome of pure rationality so much as differing values which in turn are based on different criteria of emotional satisfaction.
There is some evidence* that these value preferences are independent of experience and established quite early in life. It might be that a lot of theoretical sophistication is an elaborate rationalization of the axiomatic preferences rather than objective assessments of 'reality'.
It's also worth considering that preferential attachment and assortivity could lead to clustering of particular value systems at local, regional, or national levels. A policy which is 'natural' and 'efficient' in a society where one value system prevails might not work elsewhere, because the people there to be more competitive, or more cooperative, or more risk averse. Their aggregate economic outcomes would then be poorer because the policy is at odds with their social norms.
* https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.1600451 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.1600451
The speculated-upon correlation with big 5 personality factors in the current paper is intriguing and worthy of further research.
- thwayunion 4y ago> Economic preferences may not be the outcome of pure rationality so much as differing values which in turn are based on different criteria of emotional satisfaction. The dyadic games paper is interesting, but I think you're perhaps a bit quick to dismiss banal self-interest as a very likely missing causal variable. To what extent are extreme economic ideologies simply post-hoc intellectual justifications camouflaging basically self-interested preferences? There is a correlation between family socioeconomic status and IQ. What if it's merely that advantaged groups: 1. have the resources to provide the early life advantages that give an IQ boost, 2. have the resources to develop and defend coherent ideological systems that justify their allotment (eg, by funding think tanks and so on), and 3. tend to pass those social interests down to the next generation either directly (family-owned businesses/assets) or indirectly via cultural knowledge and connection (eg, doctor/professor/etc. kids are more like to become doctors/professors/etc.). In particular, - what economic beliefs do "non-extreme" people have? Are their beliefs non-extreme, or do they simply have a consistent bucket of (perhaps quite extreme) economic beliefs which don't have a clear name? What if all we're measuring here is that the children of professors have Brookings and an army of intellectuals to give names to things, while the children of business owners have AEI and an army of other intellectuals who also give names to things? - what happens to this result if we control for SES? I ask the first question because most people in my orbit from lower SES describe themselves as centrists on economic issues but actually have a haphazard bucket of deeply held cultural beliefs which are not located at the center of anything in particular.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Economic preferences may not be the outcome of pure rationality so much as differing values The definition of “pure rationality” in economics (and the broader social sciences)—and it's worth noting this is widely recognized as an obviously idealized and incorrect model, with controversy over whether and where it is useful even as a basic starting point or not—is that each individual: (1) has a “utility function” mapping the state of the world to experienced utility (satisfaction, basically.) (2) makes all decisions as if they had perfect knowledge of the outcomes that would result and how those outcomes map through their utility function, maximizing their personal experienced utility. So, basically what you have proposed as an exception to pure rationality as an explanation for economic behavior is actually fully encompassed within the definition of pure rationality, by way of the personal utility function.