4 ms·
> tradgedy of the commons, Communal ownership is not free market, hence the tragedy of the commons is not a failure of the free market. > ability of a large p
by WalterBright 4y ago
> tradgedy of the commons,
Communal ownership is not free market, hence the tragedy of the commons is not a failure of the free market.
> ability of a large participant to drop prices to eliminate competition then raise prices,
Has never happened successfully.
> inability of market forces to handle extreme tail risk like major natural disasters.
The free market does very well at rushing supplies into disaster areas. At least until the government put a stop to that with anti-gouging laws. So now, disaster victims have to wait around until the government gets its act together, which takes a lot longer.
- aeternum 4y ago>Communal ownership is not free market, hence the tragedy of the commons is not a failure of the free market. Ah yes so in this free-market utopia shall we purchase bottled air from Nestle for our breathing needs? Shall all aerospace companies pay a toll to the estate of Yuri Gagarin whenever they launch a rocket? He was the first in space so must have the most logical claim to the ownership rights. His estate could then help us avoid Kessler syndrome.
- WalterBright 4y agoIsn't climate change the result of communal ownership of the air? As for space, the orbits are full of dangerous space junk. A classic tragedy of the commons.
- aeternum 4y agoMuch of the most heavily polluted land in the US is privately owned, so I don't see how that eliminates the issue. I'd be much more concerned with issues like groundwater contamination, seeping gasses, and toxic waste dumping.
- WalterBright 4y ago> groundwater contamination, seeping gasses, and toxic waste dumping Are all not allowed in a free market. A free market does not condone damaging other people or their property. BTW, US military bases are on some of the most polluted ground because they polluted it.
- aeternum 4y agoHow would aviation, water-rights, or even building a railroad/tunnel work in your pure free market society? Can factories actually exist without 'damaging' the air or water runoff to other people's property?
- tdeck 4y agoSo your definition of a free market is one in which there is no possible resource that isn't owned and commodified?
- WalterBright 4y agoNo, I didn't say that. I did say that all communal ownership resources are subject to tragedy of the commons.
- anigbrowl 4y agoThis would be such a beautiful world if only people were more selfish!
- WalterBright 4y agoThe beauty of the free market is that instead of suppressing selfish motives, it enables them in a way that benefits society. It's why Americans live the highest standard of living in the world. Socialism fails because it relies on altruistic behavior, which is in short supply in humans.
- anigbrowl 4y ago> in a way that benefits society So when accusations of price gouging arise (say in the aftermath of a disaster), you're saying that it's the government interfering while the people in the disaster area area are eager to pay top dollar for suddenly-rare commodities like water or hand sanitizer? If I see regular-seeming people complaining about prices, should I assume they're covert government agents?
- twblalock 4y agoThose things are often suddenly rare because people hoard them, which can be prevented by allowing supply and demand to properly work. Prices should go up if goods are in more demand. In addition, the higher prices will motivate sellers to send more products to the impacted area. That eventually leads to price stabilization at the intersection of the supply and demand curve, i.e. how things are supposed to work. Do the higher prices mean some people won't get any water? Yes! But if you artificially suppress prices, there will also be some people who don't get water, because other people will hoard it.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI don't need you to explain price theory to me, and also don't find your hoarding argument persuasive, for two reasons: one, much of the demand in the aftermath of a disaster is from people who need to consume a commodity and can't get any, and two, the hoarding behavior you describe is more likely to be by price gougers hoping to engage in arbitrage. > But if you artificially suppress prices, there will also be some people who don't get water, because other people will hoard it. Rationing the volume available for purchase by individual customers is the obvious solution, and seems to have worked out just fine in practice during things like the great toilet paper panic of 2020. I'm asking Walter how he explains the fact of people complaining about high prices in such a context, given his claim that it's government spoiling the price theory party. Why are the opinions of people who are priced out discounted?
- tbrownaw 4y ago>> ability of a large participant to drop prices to eliminate competition then raise prices, > Has never happened successfully. I thought ISPs were notorious for temporarily dropping prices whenever a competitor tries to build out? Or at least I keep hearing anecdotes from people who think they've watched it happen.
- WalterBright 4y agoISPs are often granted franchise monopoly powers.