3 ms·
As a little reminder in these difficult times ... this view of wealth is a practical but obtuse one. Wealthy is destroyed by war and disaster, or ground away sl
by roenxi 4y ago
As a little reminder in these difficult times ... this view of wealth is a practical but obtuse one. Wealthy is destroyed by war and disaster, or ground away slowly by consuming without creating.
Unless I've not noticed something big and physical happening, the US has lost very little wealth in Q2. One of two things is happening:
1. Wealth the US thought it had, was never really created.
2. It has recognised that wasteful activity was mis-identified as productive and the records are now being corrected.
Wealth is slow. If you think the $ values are wealth, you won't make good decisions. The dollars are to measure wealth. This wealth in all likelihood never existed, and people were deceived by very low interest rates driving poor book-keeping and planning.
- efficax 4y agoif the wealth never existed then how were some people able to cash out their equities on the basis of the valuation? it was real when it was real and now it’s gone. it isn’t that there is some core of real wealth and the markets are trending towards it but sometimes above or below it. wealth is just what the markets say it is at the moment that they say it, economies are wile coyote running past the edge of a cliff before they look down. that’s capitalism baby
- roenxi 4y agoIf I try and sell you the proverbial bridge, maybe I can con you out of a few thousand dollars. But the bridge is going to be less impressive than what I pitch to you. Because I don't actually own a bridge. That is basically what is happening in your scenario - although maybe there was some wealth, it was never as impressive as the parties buying it believed. > wealth is just what the markets say it is at the moment that they say it If you reflect on this carefully you may change your mind. The market makes mistakes too - we just can't tell very easily because in any given case it is much more likely that the market is right than the person disagreeing with it. But in this case, the market is admitting that it was wrong.
- notinfuriated 4y agoIf I knowingly create a pallet of fake gold bars and sell them to an unsuspecting idiot for far more than they're worth, then was that "real" wealth? I'm not sure what the distinction between real or fake wealth is here. If someone overvalues an asset, whether through lies or ignorance, does that make a difference? Or it's all real as long as someone else is fooled to purchase the asset? Either way, it's silly for people to talk about accumulated wealth of a nation in a way where trillions can be erased from one day to the next, typically when someone finally realizes that debt valued at X is not actually going to be repaid in full and is therefore only worth Y (less than X). I don't see how that's core to capitalism, and I don't believe the system we've been in has much to do with capitalism other than the relatively free exchange of goods. There should be another name for whatever this system is, which mixes elements of capitalism and socialism, but more finely controlled by spreadsheets handled by large banks. I believe it's been called "financialism" in the recent past. In this system, wealth is some cell in a bank's spreadsheet, and one day they realize they fucked up and it's all "gone. Meanwhile, there was a small minority of other people participating in the market who knew about the fuck-up ahead of time and were able to profit off of it by properly valuating the asset/liability.
- efficax 4y ago> If I knowingly create a pallet of fake gold bars and sell them to an unsuspecting idiot for far more than they're worth, then was that "real" wealth? I almost want to say this is an impossible question to answer. At the time it was, until it wasn't. Likewise, suppose I have an art collection. A bunch of Van Goghs. One of them is a forgery but nobody knows it's a forgery. Is it worth millions?
- savanaly 4y agoDeals made on the basis of the valuation of future wealth were always gambles by both sides. The folks who cashed out made a profitable bet on future information and could have just as easily lost out. Their experience has no influence on the real wealth (in goods, not money) of the nation.
- eli_gottlieb 4y ago>economies are wile coyote running past the edge of a cliff before they look down. that’s capitalism baby Please say psyke before I join the communists.
- rcarr 4y ago> Wealthy is destroyed by war and disaster, or ground away slowly by consuming without creating. Would the war in Ukraine not be a contributing factor to this? Essentially it is a proxy war between US/Europe and Russia. Yes no assets on US soil have been destroyed but the US has sent trillions of dollars of weapons to the Ukraine and that money has to come from somewhere.
- trasz 4y agoIt’s not a proxy war, because US and EU aren’t fighting at all - they are merely providing support. Compare with eg Syria, where US was actually taking part.
- pessimizer 4y agoIt's not a proxy war because the US and EU are using a proxy?
- trasz 4y agoIt's not a proxy war because Ukraine is not a proxy - they aren't defending because US or EU told them to, they are defending to survive.
- rcarr 4y agoI feel like your definition of proxy war must be stricter than mine. The west is supplying weapons, training, intelligence etc. There’s no American boots on the ground officially but I would be surprised if elite western units weren’t involved in covert operations disrupting Russian assets around the world in some capacity. My definition of a proxy war is that of a war fought between two sides in a third country that is not part of either’s territory. If Ukraine had not been supplied with western weapons, training and intelligence on an ongoing basis then this war would probably be looking very different right now so it meets my definition at least. I’d say this also aligns with the description on wiki: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proxy_war https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proxy_war
- airza 4y agoA third possibility is that economic activity which was not previously wasteful (...?) is no longer feasible; that is, businesses which planned a future in shipping things that are made with wheat or eat wheat or use gasoline or are shipped with gasoline can no longer use those plans and have to cut output accordingly.
- defterGoose 4y agoI'd just like to point out that (1) is the same thing as losing wealth since all the wealth is essentially made up anyway. If the majority believe that the economy is strong, it is, and vice-versa.
- antisthenes 4y agoOnly if you're measuring it in dollars. Wealth, fundamentally, are durable assets that provide benefit to a standard of living or efficiency (to you individually or to society) Let's say you have a solar installation nominally worth $10k in year X. Due to a temporary rise in labor costs, someone comes along in year X+2 and says, "Golly gee, now your installation would cost $15k to install, so you have gained wealth!" Then, as labor costs normalize again, in year X+4 you do a home appraisal, and your installation comes in at $10k again. Have you lost wealth in this scenario? You still have the same installation that generates roughly the same amount of energy for you and lets you be less dependent on the grid. The reason it's silly to measure large amounts of wealth in dollar values is that it generally doesn't get traded in cash in these amounts, ever. Even when companies are bought for billions, they are usually purchased with exchange of stock, and only partly with cash and financing. What's made up is not wealth, but the dollar valuation of large amounts of wealth. In the real world where people need to eat food every day and run their HVAC on stable electricity, wealth is anything but made up.