3 ms·
> Lots of OSS has existed for decades without compromising on any freedoms, including pricing. We can't start making up freedoms whenever we're annoyed. Free b
by pessimizer 4y ago
> Lots of OSS has existed for decades without compromising on any freedoms, including pricing.
We can't start making up freedoms whenever we're annoyed. Free beer has never been part of the equation, explicitly.
> The issue with Libreoffice is that it is open source and third parties can undercut the price set by the Document Foundation. by simply releasing it themselves.
It's going to be hard to undercut €8.99, with the guarantees of authenticity and being current that you're going to get from the Document Foundation. There will, of course, be a free place (or more than one free place) to download it, but the site will be so ugly that only techies will know to trust it. And if there were a free version in the Mac app store competing with the Document Foundation version, it would be very suspicious.
Also, it's important for everyone in FOSS to charge Apple owners. They're rich and can afford it.
I remember that it used to be tough (10+ years ago) to find a compiled version of GIMP for Windows without paying. I thought it was a good thing, and still do.
> The only issue is with corporate entities struggling to turn OSS into exploitable monopolies and control points.
The GPL guards against this, so copyleft is an option if you don't want to do free work for giant corporations (without them having to do free work for you.) This won't defend you against the efficient provision of your application as a service, but maybe if your application can be delivered like that, consider going lightly proprietary. You're not going to outcompete FAANG in providing web services.
- benj111 4y ago>Also, it's important for everyone in FOSS to charge Apple owners. They're rich and can afford it. I feel this should be turned into a meme or something.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoFree beer was always implied. There's nothing in OSS licenses that prevents people charging for OSS software. But also absolutely nothing whatsoever that encourages that or requires people to honor such a commitment. Kind of the whole point. It's very easy to undercut 8.99. Just compile the binary once and distribute it via any of a wide variety of download services. The marginal cost of that is close to zero when amortized over lots of users. So close that it might as well be zero. "important for everyone in FOSS to charge Apple owners" OK, thanks for making my point for me.