3 ms·
> The USA is the land of opportunity where you can really work your way up to a great lifestyle While Americans tend to _believe_ this, and it may be true in s
by rsynnott 4y ago
> The USA is the land of opportunity where you can really work your way up to a great lifestyle
While Americans tend to _believe_ this, and it may be true in some small parts of the economy, overall the US today has notably poor economic mobility as compared to other OECD countries:
https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2018/02/14/americans-overestimate-social-mobility-in-their-country https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2018/02/14/american...
- safety1st 4y agoI believe his point is correct relative to the tech industry and your point is correct relative to the greater US economy. American tech pays really well and you really can start out in low places and go on to make great money. But overall the situation for the lower and lower-middle class in the US is pretty rough because cost of living has outpaced wages. Both are outcomes of globalization. Tech workers have it so good because the US exports its tech to the whole world, the market for US FAANG is billions of consumers strong and other countries offer limited competition. But other American workers have been replaced/outsourced/offshored in great numbers, entire industries have largely evacuated the US because it's so open to foreign products.
- rsynnott 4y ago> Both are outcomes of globalization. Eh. With the notable exception of Germany, most large developed economies are de-industrialising to some extent (and the UK, for instance, has done so to a much greater extent than the US), but even amongst rapidly de-industrialising countries the US's economic mobility story is not great, these days. As with most things, there is no single easy answer for why this is the case.
- krsrhe 4y ago
- torginus 4y agoI'm sorry, but this is one of those articles that shows just enough statistics to support their conclusion. It misses the fact that the US has a much higher concentration of wealth at the top than most European economies. So the social mobility might be lacking in terms of quintiles, in absolute terms (income in USD or EUR/standard of living), real social mobility might still be higher.
- rsynnott 4y agoI chose this one because it highlights the _belief_ gap, but no matter what way you slice it it's difficult to produce figures showing higher mobility in the US than in many other OECD countries. I think if you were looking at, say, the top 1%, this would be a more interesting argument, but the top quintile household income in the US starts at about 100k, so you’re not talking fabulously wealthy or anything.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI think the point stands. You can look at mobility in terms of percentile, or you can look at it in terms of absolute dollars. Both have different uses. I personally would prefer to see my dollar income increase, but don't care about my income percentile.
- UncleMeat 4y agoThe USA indeed has huge social equity problems. But this isn't really something that ends up harming software engineers. The country is great if you are rich and software engineers very frequently make enough money to be rich.
- s1artibartfast 4y agooverall the US today has notably poor economic mobility as compared to other OECD countries: This is a nuanced point. To get a complete picture, you have to remember that economic inequality is greater in the US as well. That means that you can see more gains with less mobility. On the other hand, there are some OECD countries with low inequality but high mobility. This also makes sense as the income difference is smaller between top and bottom earners. If you take a country like Denmark, the top quintile (20%) take home about 1.8X of the average income. For the US, the top 20% takes home 3.8X the average. The nordics have a Top to bottom quintile ratio (S80/S20) of <4. The US is >8 [1] You should also consider that economic mobility is significantly higher for US immigrants that native born Americans. https://data.oecd.org/inequality/income-inequality.htm https://data.oecd.org/inequality/income-inequality.htm