4 ms·
I don't follow chess. I've heard of Carlsen in passing but that's about it. As far as I can make up from this story, Niemann admitted to cheating online as a c
by jeroenhd 4y ago
I don't follow chess. I've heard of Carlsen in passing but that's about it.
As far as I can make up from this story, Niemann admitted to cheating online as a child (not exactly uncommon) but as of yet there's not an ounce of proof that he cheated against Carlsen.
What I don't understand is that people just take Carlsen's side without any proof. Some guy beat Carlsen so he must be cheating? What kind of reasoning is that? Surely the hyper-analytical chess community can provide some kind of statistic to prove that he cheated in the match against Carlsen? A comparison with Stockfish and friends in various combinations, perhaps? _Something_ more than "he beat the best of the best that one time therefore he's a cheating liar".
Until Carlsen and his friends can provide proof of cheating, I can only conclude that Niemann is now the superior chess player. He has now beaten Carlsen twice; once for real, once by Carlsen's resignation.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoPeople have done copious analyses of his game with Carlsen and found no evidence of cheating. And analyses of his tournament play the last two years have also not turned up anything suspicious, suggesting his meteoric rise in rating has been genuine.
- mayankkaizen 4y agoI don't follow chess much except for some headlines. Carlson is legend and Niemann practically nobody. This is very common tendency to side with legends in any field. But in this case, it is not like Carlson lost the game only for the first time so his accusations against Niemann does carry some weight, especially when Niemann himself admitted to cheating (albeit when he was a kid). Since I am totally unaware of Chess world, my first hunch would be 'Carlsen may be right' but I don't want Niemann's career to be destroyed simply based on that hunch. That is where evidence matters. But yes, Carlsen should be careful because if it turns out he made accusations out of nothing or out of spite, his entire reputation is at stake. I hope Carlsen made those accusations based on something solid.
- YetAnotherNick 4y agoThere are other suspicious things as well like fast unusual jump in rating, not having any formal training or group, few suspicious interviews, chess.com saying he cheated in more rounds than he admitted to and not to mention proved cheating online. While any one of them is not a proof of cheating, he has got many unusual things about him.