3 ms·
"You meet a man on the street and he says, “I have two children and one is a son born on a Tuesday.” What is the probability that the other child is also a son?
by ghshephard 15y ago
"You meet a man on the street and he says, “I have two children and one is a son born on a Tuesday.” What is the probability that the other child is also a son?"
The fact that one of the sons is born on a Tuesday, is blonde, has freckles, got an A+ on his math paper is irrelevant to the gender of the second son. The author's entire reasoning misses the entire point of the Monty Haul paradox where Monty Haul specifically reveals a door known _not_ to have the Goat, thereby immediately modifying the probabilities of the remaining door.
In this "Tuesday Boy Problem" - no such selection takes place. There is no paradox. There is a 50% chance that the other child is a boy and a 1/7 chance that they were born on a tuesday (or a monday, wednesday, etc...).
Note - The wikipedia article on this topic does a much better job discussing the ambiguity involved in asking the question - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boy_or_Girl_paradox http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boy_or_Girl_paradox.
The sad part of this, is that if you had _selected_ a family in which at least one son was born on a tuesday, then you would have modified the probabilities of the other child being born a son - but no such selection was done here, therefore no probabilistic impact on the chance of the other child being a son.
- _dps 15y agoThere is a shorthand and implied understanding in mathematical word problems (else they would be formulas!). As soon as you ask "what is the probability" you are implying either a sampling/generative process, or a subjective (e.g. Bayesian) probability framework. I think it's clear this is the former case. The generative model implied for each child is: pick uniformly from boy/girl, and pick uniformly from Mon-Sun. The generative model for the father is: generate two children. This generative process has a well-defined outcome distribution and it is completely reasonable to ask "what is the probability of generating an outcome with two boys, given that you generated an outcome with a Tuesday boy?"