2 ms·
> Company-run pensions are indeed dead in America, for good reason, being replaced by 401k plans. Why would you want your retirement security tied to your forme
by mschuster91 4y ago
> Company-run pensions are indeed dead in America, for good reason, being replaced by 401k plans. Why would you want your retirement security tied to your former employer? What happens when the company mismanages the pension, or the company fails?
What happens when the economy tanks? The fact that so many Americans have tied their post-work existence to "stonks only go up" is a damn perverse incentive for the US government - as it now has to think "what will the stock markets do if we introduce political measure XYZ" every time. Strong environment regulations for oil and power companies? Regulation for social networks? Is this a good idea when a lot of your people have a sizable exposure to these in their retirement accounts?
Meanwhile, here in Europe, pensions tend to be financed by the pension contributions of the current working generation. It's not perfect, far from it, but at least our pensioners don't have to fear random shit wiping out a third of their pension funds (assuming a 100% investment into S&P 500 [1]). We don't tie neither our pensions nor our healthcare to our employer (or even to being employed).
[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1175227/s-and-p-500-major-crashes-change/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1175227/s-and-p-500-majo...
- midoridensha 4y agoI don't understand what you're arguing about. We have *the exact same thing*. It's called "Social Security". Did you somehow not read that part of my message? It's not tied to the stock market or employers; it's entirely government-run.