4 ms·
Hm? I'm not a particular fan of Microsoft, but his stated opinion here is reflective of a broader trend in software design, one that's coming from both companie
by woodruffw 4y ago
Hm? I'm not a particular fan of Microsoft, but his stated opinion here is reflective of a broader trend in software design, one that's coming from both companies and the open source community. I don't see the brainwashing.
- userbinator 4y agoHis "opinion" is not only reflective, but amplifying, and that's the scary part. The companies are the ones pushing this "security" stuff, because they want to stop us from doing things like jailbreaking --- and eventually running any software they don't approve of. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32905587 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32905587 He used to write very useful utilities which did things that Microsoft didn't officially support or otherwise approve of. That's what made him famous and respected. Now he's using his position to amplify what is effectively a completely opposite viewpoint and betrayed what gave him that respect. I'm no fan of MS now, and I guess neither Russinovich anymore, but they both used to be far less user-hostile.
- shadowgovt 4y agoPerhaps his years of experience in the space have given him some perspective that leads him to a position other than the one we might have inferred from his previous work. I can tell you the way I felt about security and open architectures at 25 is very different from the way I feel about them now.
- userbinator 4y agoYears of being exposed to the corporate propaganda has had an effect on everyone. I also feel very different now than I did 2-3 decades ago, because I realised the importance of freedom and how we are slowly losing it.
- woodruffw 4y agoI don't think Microsoft's interest in Rust boils down to preventing jailbreaking. It'd be far, far cheaper to lobby the US government to ban it. (Jailbreaking has always been an arms race, and memory corruption exploits may eventually reach their natural end. But that'll probably be because of things like PAC, not Rust. When that happens, I expect jailbreakers to move onto the next low hanging fruit.)
- dtornabene 4y agobizarre. not even sure what that linked comment is supposed to do for your argument here. The idea that rust is some plot by "companies" to "prevent jailbreaking" is ..... rough, man.
- userbinator 4y agoThey're not trying to burn the frog but boil it slowly. This is just another one of a series of small steps.
- pessimizer 4y agoYou're not crazy. The attacks that Microsoft (and others) are most worried about are attacks from their own customers.
- dtornabene 4y agoits absurd, and you're slandering a bunch of free software devs who care quite deeply about security and user safety, in service of a total conspiracy theory that quite frankly comes across as trolling. Good luck with that. If by chance you are in fact sincere I have no idea what even to tell you, its just a batshit crazy notion. But odds are strong that you know exactly what you're doing, so, keep at it I guess, whatever winds your clock.
- userbinator 4y agoPeople thought Stallman was a crazy conspiracy theorist back then. Now you'd have to be quite strongly brainwashed to not see how prescient he was.
- dtornabene 4y agotrolling, trolling, trolling, keep them doggies rolling, rawhide!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dcow 4y agoIf you think memory-safe languages are some anti-jailbreaking/rooting conspiracy... well, have you heard of Java? No. Rust saves countless hours of frustration by eliminating frustratingly-hard-to-debug mistakes that humans commonly make when writing programs. Rust is pedantic, so you don't have to be. Rust saves companies money because Rust software requires noticeably less maintenance. Try it sometime. Don't worry, I guarantee that man will always be able to break what man can make. You don't need to demonize better software hygiene out of fear that companies will perfectly lock down their devices.
- userbinator 4y agoIt's not just about jailbreaking or rooting. A lot of other user-hostilities can be defeated because something isn't quite as secure as it could be, and from that perspective, making things "more secure" is active hostility. "We are not truly free if we do not have the freedom to make mistakes." I guarantee that man will always be able to break what man can make Not with the rise of strong crypto. Java isn't used for OS-level stuff (and I'm glad that it isn't.)
- dcow 4y agoHave you been paying attention? People are glitching chips now to read private keys out of hardware wallets and to bypass secure boot signature checks. And if that's not possible, then you chip the device and bypass its primary boot loader. Even with the rise of strong crypto people still find weaknesses. Your assertion about strong crypto defeating man's ability to break software simply isn't true. You must be from the thin period of history around 2008 for about 10 years where pwning your device had been predominately done in software. Regardless, you certainly have a warped perception of security. My OS not behaving as it should because someone forgot to remove a pointer from a ring buffer after its data was freed thus allowing malware to compromise my hardware and my personal information--possibly my livelihood--just so you can jailbreak your phone easier is so insanely idiotic it's beyond me. The right solution, if you care about owning your hardware, is to buy a device where you're allowed to replace the secure-boot keys with your own so that you can participate in the advances in security that we've made over time. Or pass a law that requires companies that sell hardware to provide boot loader unlock keys similar to what we did with SIM cards. Also, java has been used for embedded, real-time, and system level stuff. The Android system notably, ran Java when it was born. And likely so does your bank card. There are ways to have secure programming languages and secure boot and also own your hardware without yelling at the clouds and wishing them rain 2008 back down on you...
- UncleMeat 4y ago"We have to have to keep our systems unsafe so we can have rooting exploits for our devices" is an interesting viewpoint. I can understand why somebody would demand the ability to safely access root, but demanding unsafe code is just wild.