4 ms·
That's missing the point, I think. Cryptocurrency applications and services are of course subject to the laws of local jurisdictions in which they operate. But
by adastra22 4y ago
That's missing the point, I think. Cryptocurrency applications and services are of course subject to the laws of local jurisdictions in which they operate. But for a decentralized protocol, what law enforcement can do is limited.
Maybe better to consider the same problem in a different domain: encryption. A court can order you to give up your encryption key or password. They can even do this if you don't know or have lost your password/key. But neither the court nor its enforcement agencies can simply issue a judgement to decrypt an encrypted email; your compliance is required. The court can hold you in contempt for the rest of your life for not revealing a key you may or may not have, but they can't force you to decrypt it if the key is lost or you don't give in.
Likewise for cryptocurrency and "code is law" smart contracts. A court (or regulator) could demand all they want that a bitcoin transaction be reversed, or that a DAO smart contract be frozen. But if the underlying protocol works as it is supposed to, and if mining/staking is properly decentralized, there ain't shit they can do to actually enforce that demand.
People transacting on a blockchain are still subject to local laws, and need to comply with relevant regulatory directives. No one of consequence seriously believes that something is above the law just because it happens on a blockchain. But pragmatically, a regulator can control the blockchain about as effectively as NASA could get into space by legislating gravity.
- customkitchen 4y agoHow many people have committed such egregious crimes using blockchains that it is literally worse to spend your entire life in jail than it is to give up your Bitcoins? That scenario you've presented makes absolutely no sense to me. But anyway, it's still entirely wrong because they can still just catch you using traditional means. Like catching you on tape admitting you stole the Bitcoins, or getting a video of you doing it, or getting credible witnesses to say that you did it. Or similarly, to retrieve the stolen coins just get a video of your keyboard while you type the pass phrase to the wallet, or just liquidate the rest of your assets into dollars and pay back the victim that way... Like the whole thing just makes no sense. Even if it did actually work it would still be terrible because the system you describe means that if you get your bitcoins stolen and you catch the thief and he admits he did it and then intentionally goes to jail to avoid having to give the tokens back so they just sit there unused in the wallet just to spite you... you can literally never get them back. Why would anyone actually want that??? I am honestly trying not to make this so outlandish but this is entirely what you just described. It's completely ridiculous. The only thing this accomplishes is if you are trying to destroy money and make someone suffer by taking destructive actions... but like, if you are really an evil and petty criminal person you can also just do that with anything else? Like, rob them at gunpoint and set their cash on fire? Or slash their car tires? No one needs Bitcoins just to be an asshole, you can see that every day on this planet...
- skybrian 4y agoI don't think this works because even if a transaction is irreversible, the court could still impose monetary damages, if it has jurisdiction. Or some other penalty. And it seems hard to keep US machines (or any other country) out of a permissionless distributed algorithm? Effectively, any country could claim jurisdiction pretty easily, if it wanted, by adding a machine to the network.
- adastra22 4y agoI agree on the first point. I think this is fully compatible with what I said too.
- bendews 4y ago> but they can't force you to decrypt it if the key is lost or you don't give in. A very US-centric view is it not? Many places can force you to decrypt something by law. In fact the US does on entry to the country and can refuse entry if you do not comply. > there ain't shit they can do to actually enforce that demand. Watch forks become more commonplace and "official" forks being recognised and non-official forks being barred from use in any legitimate transactions. The courts will have the power to force blockchains to reverse transactions or other fraud this way - at a technical level still quite difficult but if it becomes law then solutions to make it easier will be created. Perhaps to cherry pick transactions just like you can cherry pick git commits.
- mw888 4y ago> Courts forcing forks I wouldn’t be so sure about that, unless you are equally convicted in that court’s jurisdiction’s conviction to outright ban the whole chain from use - because as soon as two courts mandate two different forks, one of them will be banning a chain that the rest of the globe has consensus on. It’s a lot like banning a whole region from sending mail because one person in that region got caught mailing drugs.
- bendews 4y agoRight - but nothing is stopping them from making that law. Countries aren't simply going to adhere to a digital currencies protocol or allow it to avoid regulation because otherwise it goes against the "community spirit". Here we are talking about the hypothetical situation of the U.S claiming complete jurisdiction of Ethereum. The U.S could make whatever laws it likes around the usage of Ethereum, legislate that all nodes have to adhere to these laws and job is done. The rest of the world can say "lolbye" and continue using it like nothing has happened, but in the U.S they would likely have to fork and create a new chain, and those who want to use it legally in the U.S would also have to use this new U.S-regulated chain. From there they can then implement processes to reverse transactions, introduce identification requirements etc.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]