3 ms·
Well, it's a multiparadigm language, so both :-) I'm being facetious, but it really is both: it's too unstable in ways that are bad, and also too stable in oth
by woodruffw 4y ago
Well, it's a multiparadigm language, so both :-)
I'm being facetious, but it really is both: it's too unstable in ways that are bad, and also too stable in other ways that are bad.
Edit: since you updated your comment: Rust is not in the same position as C++. C++ has an unstable ABI that it cannot break; Rust has an unstable ABI that it can (and regularly does break). Rust works around this with developer tooling; C++ largely ignores the problem and requires developers to learn the secret rules through blood and tears.
- jcelerier 4y ago> Rust works around this with developer tooling; how does that work for companies that may use proprietary rust libraries? the proprietary lib authors won't recompile their shit for you just because you upgraded to the latest rustc
- woodruffw 4y agoAs pointed out, the C ABI is stable. If companies absolutely feel the need to distribute Rust shared libraries and cannot guarantee the compiler being used, then it's a reasonable choice. I suspect that isn't very common, however. More realistically, the answer is to change the interface: Rust is pretty popular in software architectures where the unit of operation is a networked or IPC'd service; vendors can distribute binaries that communicate at that layer instead.
- jcelerier 4y ago> vendors can distribute binaries that communicate at that layer instead. they could do this in C++ also but they overwhelmingly don't, I don't see why they would in any other language for the same target applications
- woodruffw 4y agoFor one, because it's easier in Rust (this goes back to the developer experience and tooling again). But we've now gone from "here's how Rust and C++'s ABI guarantees differ" to "proprietary vendors might not have the easiest time in either language," which is a significant deviation.
- saagarjha 4y agoThe real answer is that Rust doesn’t really seek a solution for this problem. That’s fine, but C++ does and it pays an appropriate price for doing so. That’s just how things are.