5 ms·
Calling him the Azure CTO is strictly accurate, but HN readers probably know Mark Russinovich better as one of the primary developers of sysinternals[1]. I bri
by woodruffw 4y ago
Calling him the Azure CTO is strictly accurate, but HN readers probably know Mark Russinovich better as one of the primary developers of sysinternals[1].
I bring that up to highlight the weight of his opinion: Russinovich is legendary in terms of his systems programming contributions.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sysinternals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sysinternals
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoIn the 90's before Mark Russinovich became part of Microsoft, he was doing interesting things like adding NTFS support to floppies (search "NTFSFLP")
- throwaway2037 4y agoHat tip! Google found this: https://www.digiater.nl/openvms/decus/vmslt98a/nt/ntfsflp.htm https://www.digiater.nl/openvms/decus/vmslt98a/nt/ntfsflp.ht...
- a-dub 4y agoabsolutely! came here to say just that. also the excellent book "windows internals", which is kind of like the bsd red book, or the magic garden svr4 book, but for systems derived from the windows nt kernel. but perhaps his best work is this: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/downloads/bluescreen https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/downloads/blu... a screensaver that produces a realistic blue screen (kernel panic) for the version of the operating system and kernel that are installed, along with a simulated reboot that lands back into bsod as an infinite bootloop. extra bonus points because it also creates fake disk activity (for the era of hdd lights and hdds that made noise) for extra realism during the simulated boot.
- stavros 4y agoI remember trying to install that screensaver yet always having it crash my system, for some reason. I did wonder how a screensaver can crash the kernel, until I remembered what it's supposed to do. I was embarrassed for quite a while after that.
- px43 4y agoAlso IMO it's best to avoid his fiction books, Zero Day etc. It's been about a decade since I read it, but it was the first book I've ever read where I felt uncomfortable with the level of detail the author went to when describing the breasts of every female character. The random awkward sex scenes thrown in for no reason was a weird choice. Most importantly, there's also a complete lack of understanding of the underlying motivations behind both Islamic terror organizations, and cyber crime groups. I love a ton of things that Mark has built, and I'm glad he's out living his best life. According to the Amazon reviews, a ton of people loved the book, but from my perspective Zero Day is a rare miss.
- weatherlite 4y agoPeople like breasts and random sex scenes though, see Game Of Thrones. He was trying to write for the average person I guess....
- dcow 4y agoActually fascinating. I had no idea. I'm curious if I'll have the same opinion as you after giving this one a read.
- eru 4y ago> Most importantly, there's also a complete lack of understanding of the underlying motivations behind both Islamic terror organizations, and cyber crime groups. Compare https://www.gwern.net/Terrorism-is-not-about-Terror https://www.gwern.net/Terrorism-is-not-about-Terror
- omnibrain 4y ago> a screensaver that produces a realistic blue screen (kernel panic) for the version of the operating system and kernel that are installed I used this one at work for some time. Until I came back from my lunch break and got told by my office mate that he helpfully rebooted my PC because it had crashed in my absence.
- aoetalks 4y agoRe: the screensaver: > Note: before you can run Bluescreen on Windows 95 or 98, you must copy \winnt\system32\ntoskrnl.exe from a Windows 2000 system to your \Windows directory There be dragons
- userbinator 4y ago
- woodruffw 4y agoHm? I'm not a particular fan of Microsoft, but his stated opinion here is reflective of a broader trend in software design, one that's coming from both companies and the open source community. I don't see the brainwashing.
- userbinator 4y agoHis "opinion" is not only reflective, but amplifying, and that's the scary part. The companies are the ones pushing this "security" stuff, because they want to stop us from doing things like jailbreaking --- and eventually running any software they don't approve of. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32905587 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32905587 He used to write very useful utilities which did things that Microsoft didn't officially support or otherwise approve of. That's what made him famous and respected. Now he's using his position to amplify what is effectively a completely opposite viewpoint and betrayed what gave him that respect. I'm no fan of MS now, and I guess neither Russinovich anymore, but they both used to be far less user-hostile.
- shadowgovt 4y agoPerhaps his years of experience in the space have given him some perspective that leads him to a position other than the one we might have inferred from his previous work. I can tell you the way I felt about security and open architectures at 25 is very different from the way I feel about them now.
- userbinator 4y agoYears of being exposed to the corporate propaganda has had an effect on everyone. I also feel very different now than I did 2-3 decades ago, because I realised the importance of freedom and how we are slowly losing it.
- pessimizer 4y agoVery very rarely in my life do I feel affectionate towards Windows (and I've been virtually exclusively Linux/other-unix for a long time.) Sometimes it happened when I was writing dumb VBA in some Excel project, which I find fun for some reason. It happens when I play Windows 95/XP era Minesweeper. It also happens when I touch or have to use any part of Sysinternals. I even like reading the docs for Sysinternals, even though the UI is usually so good you hardly need them.
- ripley12 4y agoI feel the same way about Sysinternals tools. They give me a warm fuzzy feeling, I think acquiring+maintaining Sysinternals is one of the best things Microsoft's ever done. The way they expose OS internals in a powerful-but-user-friendly way is delightful and empowering. I still remember the first time I used procmon; it felt like a veil was removed from my eyes, suddenly I could trivially see everything processes were doing! Sysinternals represents an idealized Windows to me: an OS for power users with a GUI-first culture that differentiates it from Unix. Windows itself might not live up to that dream anymore, but at least we have Sysinternals.
- ekianjo 4y agoAppeal to authority?
- dtornabene 4y agomultiple people, myself included, logged in to comment precisely because the idea that MR is mostly aptly described as "Azure CTO" is a bit much. Glad the op commented the way they did, it also obviated this exact argument by simply establishing who exactly he is and not exhaustive foot stomping recitation of all his work.
- philosopher1234 4y agoAppeals to authority are useful and good. They’re shorthands for doing PhD theses on every topic you encounter. They aren’t bulletproof, though.
- woodruffw 4y agoWe do indeed listen to what authorities on subjects have to say, yes. Mark Russinovich is an authority on systems programming, and his thoughts carry weight because of his track record.
- snickerbockers 4y agoyeah, but he's not an authority on everything written in C/C++. He's entitled to his own opinions, but this scope exceeds whatever experience he has doing sysinternals or whatever it was (idk, i'm a unix guy not a windows guy). He definitely can be criticized and disagreed with. Where does it end? If he says mint chocolate chip is the worst ice cream flavor, am I obliged to agree with him because he made sysinternals?
- Shorel 4y agoNeither thing. It means he has a very informed opinion. That doesn't mean we are forced to agree (I do not), but that we must answer with another informed opinion ourselves.
- 4y ago
- gruturo 4y agoSeconding this. I saw the article before its title was changed, and I admit I dismissed it right away (I know, how improper of me). When I see Mark's name, I stop and read the article.