2 ms·
> Can you expand on this? What do you mean by "psychological purpose"? Is it just something mundane as "symbol of support in a political rally"? It's collectiv
by anigbrowl 4y ago
> Can you expand on this? What do you mean by "psychological purpose"? Is it just something mundane as "symbol of support in a political rally"?
It's collective, coordinated, and directs attention toward an individual on stage, as opposed to an individual expression of support like clapping or cheering - which many people might do simultaneously but isn't normally coordinated outside of a music performance. The 'as one' hand slamming you mentioned emphasizes the coordination here; it's novel, but basically an iteration on the original gesture.
> The complaint is that the twitter poster decided to sensationalize that rally by calling something it's not.
The tweet is somewhat hyperbolic and sensationalized, but while it's not exactly the same I really think it's more similar than different - it's a choreographed gesture of support for a political figure at a political rally involving a straight arm salute. As I said earlier, harping on the cosmetic differences sidesteps the very obvious question of 'does this look like a nazi rally to a casual observer?' And that matters, because political rallies aren't intellectually rigorous exercises in philosophical inquiry, they are theatrical performances designed to motivate political behavior through emotional arousal.
> That's all well and good if you want to demonize those groups, but what do you call people who actually want to systematically murder jews?
Groypers (this is an in-joke). We also have open neo-nazis who are explicitly aligned with the historical national socialist movement to the point of fetishizing it. The broader right wing authoritarianism that obtains in multiple countries at present can be generally described as fascism without any loss of precision or clarity. This doesn't have to refer to the-Italian-party-once-headed-by-Benito-Mussolini. Obsessing over typologies is sometimes a coping mechanism to avoid engaging with an issue, like having an argument about meteorology to avoid admitting you should have brought an umbrella.
- gruez 4y ago>As I said earlier, harping on the cosmetic differences sidesteps the very obvious question of 'does this look like a nazi rally to a casual observer?' But to an casual observer, what makes a rally a "nazi rally"? If you go around saying that a politician just held a "nazi rally", what pops in your head? You seem to think that the answer to both is something along the lines of "collective, coordinated, and directs attention toward an individual on stage", but I doubt most people believe that. This sort of behavior isn't limited to just political rallies for white supremacists, it's used by basically everyone. Calling right-wing or even white supremacist rallies as "nazi rallies" makes as much sense as calling left wing rallies as "Bolshevik rallies". >The broader right wing authoritarianism that obtains in multiple countries at present can be generally described as fascism without any loss of precision or clarity You don't see the problem here? You just equated "right wing authoritarianism" with "nazis" and "fascism". What does "right wing authoritarianism" mean, anyways? Is it just people who are more right wing and authoritarian than you by some arbitrary amount? If a politician is called a "nazi" or a "fascist", his policies could be anywhere between "more funding for the police and stricter immigration enforcement" and "round up minorities and send them to death camps".
- anigbrowl 4y ago> But to an casual observer, what makes a rally a "nazi rally"? A combination of Nazi-style iconography and right wing/reactionary rhetoric. I've yet to see a 'left wing rally' in the US but I suppose that could take in center-left rallies by politicians like Bernie Sanders. And people do label such events as a bunch of commies. I'm not sure what you have in mind with 'Bolshevik rallies'. I can't think of anything visually distinctive about historical examples, and when I think of Communist party events I think of very formal affairs in auditoriums as you might see from China or North Korea. I'm having trouble imagining an American equivalent. > You don't see the problem here? You just equated "right wing authoritarianism" with "nazis" and "fascism". What does "right wing authoritarianism" mean, anyways? If you're struggling with very common political theory terms used in a wholly conventional way, perhaps you should consult a dictionary instead of asking me to stand in for one.
- gruez 4y ago>A combination of Nazi-style iconography and right wing/reactionary rhetoric So a rally with people raising their fists[1] and arguing for state expropriation and/or redistribution would be a "communist rally"? >And people do label such events as a bunch of commies. And you think that's a fair label? >If you're struggling with very common political theory terms used in a wholly conventional way, perhaps you should consult a dictionary instead of asking me to stand in for one. Sounds like you're trying to dodge the issue, which is that politics lies on a spectrum and there isn't an obvious point between "wants more funding for cops and tighter border control" and "wants to round up and kill a particular ethnic group" that defines "right wing authoritarianism". Even if you were somehow able to come up with a principled definition, I doubt that it's something that most people would agree with, which means practically speaking all these phrases essentially boil down to "people with politics that I find too extreme". [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raised_fist https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raised_fist
- dbfx 4y agoEven hn has some supertweeters, fascinating.