3 ms·
This is a historically narrow view of the situation. We are all living in a post-war era. That war was over whether and how much of the software in the world s
by hinkley 4y ago
This is a historically narrow view of the situation.
We are all living in a post-war era. That war was over whether and how much of the software in the world should be locked up behind proprietary licenses and paywalls. To win the war, Open Source had to produce software that was less awful than the proprietary software it was trying to unseat. It did. Companies went out of business or adapted.
Now everyone is trying to pretend that the choice all along was between someone else's software and making your own. That wasn't the choice, and it's revisionist history to claim otherwise. A war was one, territory was occupied, and the 'treaty' at the end of that war was "make stuff that isn't awful", which is being peeled away layer by layer.
The above is the opening to my thesis as to why SaaS is now trying to eat Open Source: FOSS is abdicating responsibility for quality, and so the only way to get quality is to harass FOSS authors who think we are ungrateful whiners, or pay for improvements on the backs of paying customers who just want software that works, not to be told to put up or shut up.
The only sane way to defend against the re-privatization of FOSS software is to stop treating your users like they need to grow up and realize that you're deflecting. Unless authors accept that you have an ethical responsibility that comes with occupying a corner of the collective consciousness, it's going to be walled gardens everywhere you look.
We aren't paying people to 'steal' your code. We're paying people to act like professionals.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoYou can also get quality by... doing it yourself. That's the Free Software core idea. Don't like what exists? You're free to change it. In fact, you're encouraged to change it, and publish your changes, so others can use your higher-quality version. It's supposed to be a gift economy, not a plunder economy. You're given something for free, with little to no strings attached. All that is politely expected of you is to A) not be a dick, and B) reciprocate in kind, if the situation arises.
- blooalien 4y agoOr you can get "quality" (or support) by paying the author (or some other developer) to support / improve said software within the legal terms of whatever license that software is released under.
- hinkley 4y agoWhich we used to be able to do a lot more. Many of those companies are out of business or merged with a mega corporation.
- q-big 4y ago> and the 'treaty' at the end of that war was "make stuff that isn't awful", which is being peeled away layer by layer. There never was a treaty (not even an informal one!). In businesses, the reason why open source software was adopted was typically because it enabled cost savings (e.g. saving/reducing license costs).
- robocat 4y agoThe metaphor “war” is invalid methinks. Ecological systems or economic competition are far better metaphors, because they are emergent and decentralised, rather than patriotic and authoritarian. “Nature red in tooth and claw”, or monopoly rent and marginal price → 0. Revisionist? The 1T$ Microsoft has not “lost the war”. The biggest FOSS wins have serious corporate sponsorship (OSes, databases, browsers, dev tools, languages, etcetera).
- hinkley 4y agoI think it’s lost on the kids how many people came to open source because they hated Microsoft. That went on for a dozen years at least. That’s the same time period when Eric Raymond and Linus Torvalds and Richard Stallman and a dozen others would have public debates on which flavor OSS should have. Those people all were visionaries, and wrote like it. We had long talks about gift economies too, which even showed up in sci-fi (Kim Stanley Robinson, for one). Linus is the most practical of the three, which is probably why we still talk about him more than the other two. But we wouldn’t talk about any of them if “practical” was the only adjective we had for them. If you want to celebrate Microsoft becoming open source as an ally, knock yourself out. But the older people still don’t trust Microsoft (see also the Scorpion and the Frog), so it’s more of a war trophy. This is probably as “beaten” as MS gets, but they can always wake up.
- robocat 4y agoI am suitably middle-aged and FOSS supporting to find your insinuations offensive. I didn’t say anything about supporting Microsoft, just stating some facts that are hard to argue against (and I note that you don’t argue against them). I think that jumping to conclusions about others is nasty behaviour.
- JohnFen 4y ago> FOSS is abdicating responsibility for quality, and so the only way to get quality is to harass FOSS authors who think we are ungrateful whiners, or pay for improvements on the backs of paying customers who just want software that works, not to be told to put up or shut up. I think you are assigning things broadly to "FOSS authors" that were explicitly disclaimed by most such authors from before companies started using FOSS.
- hinkley 4y agoThen we’re going to keep seeing an erosion of Free software until there’s a renaissance where people begin actively courting the general developer public to vote with their feet again. FOSS won people over by saying we are entitled to useful software without having to mortgage ourselves to corporations. Well, it got what it wanted and now it calls users entitled. You’re damn right they are.
- LtWorf 4y agoWe didn't get it… what we got are gigantic corporations using free software to make proprietary software. Nobody wanted that. Can I download the sources and easily patch the gmail client on my phone as easily as I do that on debian? No. q.e.d.
- hinkley 4y agoYes, because it’s been twenty years of FOSS with zero DevEx. People ran back to corporate walled gardens. Which is just a rephrasing of what I said above. This isn’t “users” and corporations making a mess of the software world together. It’s all of us. As you guys are so fond of telling everyone else, if you don’t like it, change.
- JohnFen 4y ago> FOSS won people over by saying we are entitled to useful software without having to mortgage ourselves to corporations. Well, it got what it wanted and now it calls users entitled. You’re damn right they are. It's not the users that are acting too entitled. It's software producers that are doing it, by failing to perform their essential role of making sure the software they use is adequate for their purposes, and demanding that the FOSS components they're using do their their work for them.
- gorjusborg 4y ago> This is a historically narrow view of the situation. > We aren't paying people to 'steal' your code. We're paying people to act like professionals. I think you have a narrow view of the situation, or you are trying to misrepresent the reality we are living in. We are signing up for OSS-derived SaaS mostly because of the existence of cloud-computing network effects. There have been many fights fought by companies 'acting like professionals' that could accept payment. They are re-licensing their software because developers and companies are utilizing a forked cloud-vendor-specific clones of their work. Forking software to provide it to a captive audience doesn't seem professional, it seems anti-competitive. That said, most popular licenses allow it, so it is legal, but I don't think it is ethical.
- betwixthewires 4y agoYou're revising history here. There was no war. There was only "I'm not using your code unless I can see what it does and do whatever I want with it." It wasn't a statement of conflict, it was one of choosing ones own way without compromise. Then some people said "I like that idea, here, I made this, do what you want with it, but it's not mine, it's yours, problems and all." That's all there is to any of this. There is no ethical responsibility. People doing something for fun for free dont owe anyone any degree of professionalism. If you want to burden yourself with the expectations of others that is your right, but just because you do it doesn't make it some standard everyone has to live up to.
- hinkley 4y ago> There is no ethical responsibility. Then stop calling yourself a software engineer. Engineering has an ethical responsibility associated with all of their work. Go be a software developer with your no responsibility. Work on Dark Patterns. Work on spying on your customers. Work on making “Developer” an epithet so the rest of us can use you as an example to push for actual Engineering status and the protections that go with it. Why do we expect more grace and generosity from the hosts of social gatherings than we do with software that will touch the lives of millions of users? That’s madness. “Oh you don’t like that there are no snacks? Well then bring your own.” would get you blackballed in any other setting. It’s antisocial, which kind of goes with our stereotype. Most of us don’t like it, some of us don’t see how we feed into it.
- betwixthewires 4y agoYou dropped the crux of what i said: "People who do something for fun for free..." It's much harder to paint my position as one of antisocial uncaring evil in light of that.
- robocat 4y agoJeepers, you seem to be making up some argument against a bunch of stuff betwixtthewires didn’t say. Where did they call themselves an engineer? Strawman? They talk about developing as a hobby, not killing civilisation, nor working for Metagoobooksoftle.