5 ms·
What's interesting is that saving the results of a previous operation to memory and recalling/clearing them (M/MR/MC buttons) has been standard in calculators s
by paxys 4y ago
What's interesting is that saving the results of a previous operation to memory and recalling/clearing them (M/MR/MC buttons) has been standard in calculators since the very beginning. It just has the most non-obvious user experience in the world so most people don't even know about the feature.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoA light dawns, thank you.
- kube-system 4y agoBeing able to visually see the number would be helpful. I haven't seen any that visually show what is stored in memory until you recall it. It would be pretty neat if pocket calculators had a second line for that feature.
- tyingq 4y agoYeah, the current Windows calculator has a tab that shows the memory, and I do use it. It would be nice on a physical calculator.
- pleb_nz 4y agoIt can also be confusing and hard to use for a lot of people and once it's failed for a user once or twice, they'll likely give up with it. I have even succumbed to copy n paste as the cognitive load is less and safer. This however is very obvious and I think it's a great idea. If I had iOS I think I would install it.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoIt's not just that people don't know about the feature. I'd argue having the side-by-side calculator views is fundamentally different (and much better) than just having a memory-store/memory-recall button. E.g. in this app, you get to see the full equations that went into a particular set of calculations as you go back and forth.
- jonny_eh 4y agoExactly, the problem with memory buttons is it's easy to forgot (ha!) what's in the memory. With the sibling calculator, you can see everything.
- layer8 4y agoYou also can’t perform another calculation with the stored value (other than M+/M-) while also keeping the current accumulator.
- psychphysic 4y agoI constantly want this feature. Everywhere. Making meetings on the outlook app on my phone for work is a complete and utter chore. I can't look at emails at the same time. While I end up popping everything out on my PC on my phone that's not possible. This is basically the same thing and on a desktop I'd pushed I end up dumping all the info in the scratch pad of an Emacs session phones just don't let you do that.
- jorvi 4y agoI believe Samsungs have this feature. I wish iPhones either supported it in landscape, or got a feature called ‘slide-over’ from iPadOS, where you can float another app on top of your current app, off-screen to the right. There’s a little edge you can then grab and pull over your current app to quickly peek or copy info back-and-forth. When you’re done you just slide back the ‘slide-over’ app. It’s a really clever feature. And I know swiping on the gesture bar exist, but it doesn’t have nearly the same rapid fluidity of slide-over.
- mrb 4y agoOn standard Android phones you can do it. I just tried split screen (GMail on top, Google Calendar at the bottom) and you can create or edit a calendar event while having an open email on top. Looks like this on my phone (Android 13): https://ibb.co/51skSCw https://ibb.co/51skSCw
- 4y ago
- quickthrower2 4y agoI use M, MR, MC buttons but having 2 calculators is kind of cool too, it is a fun idea.
- samstave 4y agoWhen I was a little kid in the 80s, there was a SQRT function on my calculator and I would typ in numbers then hit that button and log the results in a scratch pad... and the thing is that even using the M/MR/MC feature was foreign to me...
- ketozhang 4y agoThe design is horrible and a relic of skewmorphism. Single tally memory is useful on small screens. I just wish they’d display the stored value somewhere.
- jonahx 4y agoThe design is: 1. Not skeuomorphic. 2. Indeed, flat. 3. Almost identical to the iPhone native calculator, except it uses round-edge rectangles instead of circles.
- schadara 4y agoFrom the second image, it appears he set the cornerRadius too high and the buttons became almonds. If that’s what he was going for, then perhaps it IS skeuomorphic? /s
- stevage 4y agoIt's skeuomorphic in the sense that the layout is very similar to a physical calculator.
- DrewADesign 4y agoNope. Skeumorphic design uses ornamentation, like textures and interaction animations, to mimic the aesthetic of a physical object. You don't even need to adopt an existing standard interface layout to be skeumorphic. Make those keys look rubber or give it a mock LCD display and you'd be skeumorphic even if the buttons were in a circle around the display.
- cyanydeez 4y agoEh, that's not the problem being solved. I have the same issue programming when I get popups for various autocomplete or method description or whatever. Typically, I'm actually focused on the previous line like a hook into my thought process and almost need that hook to get into the next section. This app is just a simple example of how people visualize the steps into complicated stepping alongside logic.
- RedShift1 4y agoI press both C and CE multiple times on my calculator to reset it so juggling those 3 M buttons is probably a bridge too far for my brain.
- closewith 4y agoDespite an applied maths degree and a career in informatics, TIL that C is Clear Everything and CE is Clear Entry. Naively, I always assumed the opposite.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoChording them together means “fuck it”
- bitwize 4y agoSome scientific calculators have a button marked AC for "all clear", also sometimes in a distinctive color so you know it's important. Features like that appear aimed at people like you and me, who aren't specially trained in calculator use and have to reacquire familiarity with what the buttons do when we use the machine upon occasion.
- 4y ago
- xani_ 4y agoI just learned RPM instead of figuring that out. RPN calc with 3-4 lines of stack display is just more convenient
- cjohnson318 4y agoI was reading about doing log-log calculations on slide rules the other night, and I can tell you that M/MR/MC is even worse than that.
- bee_rider 4y agoWe could also think of it as a spreadsheet with 2 cells.
- irrational 4y agoI know about the feature, I just have no clue how to use it and don't use a calculator enough to bother looking up how to use it.
- michaelgrafl 4y agoI know this feature, but I'd much more prefer the workflow of having two calculators side by side.