3 ms·
I'm more interested why it isn't possible to just fork the thing and maintain a version that's plugin enabled. Isn't Chromium completely open source? Especiall
by moffkalast 4y ago
I'm more interested why it isn't possible to just fork the thing and maintain a version that's plugin enabled. Isn't Chromium completely open source?
Especially for Brave, Vivaldi, Opera, etc.
- AshamedCaptain 4y agoDeveloper effort.
- moffkalast 4y agoDon't underestimate the power of spite.
- AshamedCaptain 4y agoSpite is at times my main source of motivation, and still leaves me physically uncapable of following the rate of breakage of upstream Firefox (i.e. I cant keep my patches up to date), which I'm assuming it's actually a more sensible upstream when compared with Google.
- Macha 4y agoI actually think not - the few third party gecko browsers abandoned ship to webkit/blink/chromium over the years
- josefx 4y ago>Isn't Chromium completely open source? No, especially not if you want to watch videos, the DRM plugin is a binary blob that only Google approved browsers get to run. Then there are all the Google services that will break in unexpected ways in your browser, sometimes just because your user agent isn't identical to Chromes if past reports from Firefox users are any indication. Basically expect to be shit on by the biggest internet giant around at ever possible corner.
- ElCheapo 4y agoI mean, if the DRM wasn't a blob it would be open source. Andnif it were open source it wouldn't be DRM...
- heavyset_go 4y agoIt's possible to have DRM that's open source using cryptography.
- easrng 4y agoSecure DRM requires that your device have keys that are burned-in that you can't access. It's impossible to have an open implementation of a non-broken DRM system.
- josefx 4y agoIt could be controlled by a third party that isn't trying to dominate the browser market. And Google already caused issues years ago when it side loaded that plugin on open source distros and initially refused to provide an option to disable this behavior in chromium.
- whoisthemachine 4y agoFirefox supports all DRM content I have come across, clearly there are ways to implement DRM that don't involve Google.
- josefx 4y agoOpen Addons an Themes, click on Plugins, by default you should see a line that says "Widevine Content Decryption Module provided by Google Inc." . Note the Google Inc. .
- whoisthemachine 4y agoFair, and I didn't know that or had forgotten it, but I think Firefox is still relevant to the parent's comment, and the context of the topic: > No, especially not if you want to watch videos, the DRM plugin is a binary blob that only Google approved browsers get to run. So it might be better to say that you don't need to be locked into Google's browser (or a fork of its OS base) in order to consume a wide variety of online content, and you can thus avoid this issue with Chrome extensions entirely. And at least with Firefox it is just a plugin, so presumably could be replaced with a binary blob from someone else if Google's influence became worrisome enough (and I do wonder, isn't it already worrisome enough??).
- heavyset_go 4y agoThe amount of work it would take to fork Chromium and maintain a working secure browser with MV2 hooks into the browser internals would be so large that you'd need a dedicated team whose job it is to constantly backport upstream Chromium changes and ensure they still work with the old MV2 subsystem. That would take a lot of time and money.
- moffkalast 4y agoWell you don't need to implement every stupid thing big G thinks should be in it, just the really critical stuff. Even if you freeze all features right now you'll probably still have a better renderer than gecko for 5 years into the future. I mean right now I bet a lot of people will simply not update to MV3 and continue using the last known MV2 build into perpetuity until certs break or something else. I sure intend to.
- heavyset_go 4y agoBackporting from an entity that is hostile towards MV2 makes me suspect that Google isn't going to play ball and make maintaining an MV2-compatible Chromium fork easy.
- marwis 4y agoIn addition to what others said, forks are not allowed to use Google services such as Chrome Sync or Translate.