5 ms·
Old TV's had consumable, user-replacible components (the tubes), and were unreliable due to being hand wired. I don't see the industry moving back to either of
by hedora 4y ago
Old TV's had consumable, user-replacible components (the tubes), and were unreliable due to being hand wired.
I don't see the industry moving back to either of those things.
These days, the repairable parts are likely to out last the display anyway. I don't see TV repair becoming common again. I could imagine them encouraging recycling (and local shopping) by adding a "core" fee like they do for lead acid batteries.
- kmbfjr 4y agoTheir replacements were far less reliable because the ICs were socketed, not soldered onto the board. My old man regularly opened the back of his 1980 RCA to “crack knuckles”…firmly seat ICs that had lifted up from the DIP sockets. The unreliable nature of tube NTSC color TVs was entirely the fault of tubes being pushed to their limits and the need for 600 volt plate supplies.
- hakfoo 4y agoI thought that there was some definite economization-to-death in the later years. From like 1995 until their demise, was there any meaningful enhancement to NTSC tube TVs? There were minor enhancements in on-screen display, flatter glass fronts, and maybe the addition of S-video inputs, but there wasn't really much that could be leveraged as a "premium" set that could demand a higher margin except for maybe a Sony Trinitron. There was no meaningful "Replace your 720-line set with a 1080- or 2160-line one" sales pitch. The obvious way to compete is to go full Madman Muntz and cut every possible corner. I recall in the early 2000s a fairly newish (at the time) RCA 27" tube release the magic smoke, and the discussion on sci.electronics.repair was very much "oh, that chassis design is all but guaranteed to fail catastropically when it does fail, may as well buy a new set". I don't doubt that group had several thousand man-years of repair experience, and they had very little positive to say for any set made after the Carter administration.
- jmbwell 4y agoYeah, inside the enclosure of a modern TV is an LCD panel connected to a board the size of a raspberry pi that holds a SOC and some input connectors. There just isn't anything to be repaired. The minimum unit of replacement is the entire unit.
- nyanpasu64 4y agoHmm, my family once replaced our LG 1080p TV's mainboard after the HDMI ports failed, then the TV stopped powering on past the splash screen at all. The built-in content apps (the early days of smart TVs before they turned into a surveillance capitalism hellscape) are dead, and 1080p non-HDR is obsolete for pixel-peepers, but for our limited use, the screen still works just fine.
- vel0city 4y agoIt kind of depends on the failure modes. There was a wave of Samsung TVs which were a big victim of bad capacitors at the time. Replacing <$1 worth of caps would often salvage the TV. Also, a number of TVs these days fail because of poor phosphor coatings on the light strips causing color issues and uneven brightness. The stuff literally starts falling apart inside the TV. A quick clean and replacement light arrays ( often <$75) will then refresh the TV, making it like new again for at least several more years. Hopefully the replacement light arrays will last longer. Sometimes the power supply, core logic, and inputs will be on separate boards. This means if an input connector gets physically broken it may be possible to replace just the board for the inputs instead of having to replace the entire board. Even then, assuming you can find it the board itself can be significantly cheaper than the entire TV. YMMV on parts availability though.
- robotnikman 4y agoI can see the mainboard being replaceable. The SoC's become slow after a few years on smart TV's and makes using them a pain because of how sluggish and unresponsive the UI becomes That's wishful thinking though, I don't see this happening.
- smackeyacky 4y agoYou'd think TV repair was dead, but we have a local TV repair guy who has a few lucrative warranty repair contracts with some of the bigger brand names. He usually doesn't do much other than replace fried main boards, but occasionally will do a proper repair (where possible) on out of warranty TVs. That work I can't see how he makes money out of it, but he does it anyway. I'm glad he is still going, he is a dab hand at fixing vintage hi-fi which is subsidised by his TV warranty work.