9 ms·
Why kids are afraid to ask for help
- t_leon 4y agoOne wonders how this differs by culture and over time (if it's highly correlated with more individualistic societies and cultural moments).
- inetknght 4y agoAs an adult: it's not that I'm afraid of appearing incompetent in front of peers. I don't care about that. I just know that my peers are also having their own troubles and I don't want to add my trouble to theirs. When I am truly stuck on something and can't guess what the problem is, then yes I will ask for help. I've found that probably 60% of the time (guesstimate), my peers would guess the same things that I already tried, tested, and failed. In doing so, they've duplicated the time spent trying to solve the problem. Maybe 20% of the time, while doing so, they might spot something that I missed. Maybe another 10% of the time, they'll think of something I hadn't. And the last 10%? Well, that just means it's time to refactor the problem set to avoid what can't be solved. That of course changes if I enter a new problem domain. At that point, I most certainly ask peers for documentation and examples. If I hit a snag then I ask what I did wrong. Most often the cause ends up being inaccurate documentation.
- Shugarl 4y agoAs an adult: it's 80% because I'm afraid of looking incompetent in front of my peers. It can be pretty painful to see people systematically dismiss anything you say, or always seek out a second opinion, for no other reason that they have a hard time believing anything reliable can come out of your mouth. I won't let that happen again.
- giantg2 4y agoWhat's all this talk about peers? I just don't want to seem incompetent to my manager and get fired.
- tharkun__ 4y agoNot saying this is you but this reminded me of two types of people I've witnessed over the years. One of them I would look at as you say `incompetent`, while the other I'd say is `smart`. You're new to something? Ask for pointers if you can't find something relatively quickly yourself. That's `smart`. You're new, the documentation might be inaccurate, out of date or not in the place you'd expect it unless you've already been at the company and learned their structure etc. You're stuck on something and can't figure it out? Ask for some help to double check your own logic. Run them through all of the things you've already tried. This shows that you're not incompetent but have in fact already tried all those obvious things they'd ask you about. Also do actually run them through those steps, don't just talk about you having done them already. Sometimes you've overlooked something the first 2 times and showing it to someone else makes you notice (also see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubber_duck_debugging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubber_duck_debugging if you'd like to first use a non-human just in case). You wouldn't believe the amount of times where I've been the helper and all I had to do to help was to ask them to run me through what they had already tried and the above happened. They showed me something as "and see I tried this and then it doesn't ... oooh" ;) Do not ask for help on the exact same thing 5 times in a row. That definitely makes me think you're `incompetent`. Happens way too often too unfortunately.
- watwut 4y agoMeh, what you call smart can be easily used against you. Many people fix their opinions of you quickly and won't change them later. Will instead seek to patronize you going forward no matter what you learned. Learned that the hard way. I am not going to ask beginner questions in new social group. Way better is to Google them in the evening. People will treat you better as a result I swear.
- tharkun__ 4y agoI might not have been accurate enough. I don't mean to ask about things that are easily Googled. I really meant things that are company specific. If you ask me a question that I will then Google myself to answer you, I will also very probably form a not so great opinion of you, agreed. I also expect you not to wait until the evening to Google it if it gets you stuck right now. Also I agree that not all companies reward this. Not all people do either and it's unfortunately necessary to 'hide your smarts' so to speak. That doesn't change my overall opinion though. At a good company / in a good team, you're going to be able to do that smart thing. And yes I see this all the time when onboarding new people. They're not used to it and 'hide' things. Ultimately it takes most of them way longer than it should to onboard and I might form a less than great opinion of them. On the contrary there was a team lead recently that asked lots and lots of "dumb questions" early on and asked them quickly as they came up. Instead of taking 2 weeks and still not being properly set up for everything, he was up and running without any issues within a day and could start working on stuff.
- blooalien 4y agoIn my case, it's not even fear of appearing incompetent. It's fear of being accused of or treated as if I'm incompetent when I'm clearly not. This past couple few decades the average population have become more and more downright vicious, cruel, and absolutely sure of themselves, even when they're utterly wrong about something they say or do, and as that problem grows, I become less able / willing to open myself up to that sort of potential abuse. I've got things rough enough already without that additional stress. In addition, there's what a previous commenter said about knowing that others also have their own things they're dealing with, and I kinda don't wanna be the guy who adds to that any if I can avoid it (just in case they're not that other type of person I mention here).
- failedengineer 4y agohey hey, this is exactly what happened to my engineering career right here. "This code will never be used." "Oh, ok." proceeds to write garbage to test out various features and different ways of doing the same thing "Hey, this code is garbage and lacks consistency. Lets show it to everyone to warn them about this guy. We won't mention it until letting him struggle a couple years, but make sure he doesn't get any interesting work."
- m463 4y agoMany times I don't ask for help because explaining my problem is so involved that it makes more sense to just plow ahead. https://dilbert.com/strip/2003-08-07 https://dilbert.com/strip/2003-08-07
- daedalus2027 4y agoadults tend to pass judgement over understanding too quickly
- giantg2 4y ago"Until relatively recently, psychologists assumed that children did not start to care about their reputation and peers' perceptions until around age nine." I mean, these psychologist did grow up and spend time as a child, right?
- wudangmonk 4y agoI guess this speaks volumes of the sort of "science" you can expect from psychologists.
- antod 4y agoThat they won't rely on their own anecdotes/assumptions and actually research something? Sounds like what science is supposed to be right?
- j-bos 4y agoPerhaps, but there's a line between distrusting anecdotes and being silly. After all, parachutes do actually prevent deadly stops. https://www.bmj.com/content/363/bmj.k5094 https://www.bmj.com/content/363/bmj.k5094
- hinkley 4y agoOnly relatively recently did someone pay money to prove that yes, in fact, circumcision hurts. Before that the 'common wisdom' was that babies don't process pain. Said no parent, ever. There's a lot of patronizing that goes on in organized medicine/psychology, and juvenile medicine seems to get a double helping of it.
- mynameishere 4y agoI believe they used to perform major surgery on babies using the same non-evidence-based reasoning. I think the real reason is the combination of 1) tortured babies can't file lawsuits but 2) Parents whose babies die from anesthesia can file lawsuits. So, follow the money as with everything in medicine.
- concinds 4y agoYet another example of trying to solve psychological/emotional issues through cultural changes. The root problem is low self-esteem; it's internal, not external; it takes deep inner work, not a change in social norms and teacher behavior. It affects some kids deeply, and some not at all. It's not "caused" by the culture or the environment, but by parenting. Psychology is stuck in a weird place. Most cultural knowledge of "self-esteem" comes from self-help crap, when it should be coming from psychologists. What if we lived in a world where everyone knows how to recognize low self-esteem, how to interact with insecure people effectively, and how to help them build their self-esteem durably, as opposed to these proto-team-building-exercises they're proposing here? The traditional thinking is that you fix emotional issues through therapy sessions; but if we changed the culture to become more emotions-aware, people would know how to help each other and themselves far better. The fact that so many pop-psychology books sell so much, is proof that there's a deep need for this. Some studies say 70-80% of people have some degree of low self-esteem. Depending on the study, 50-70% of the whole population have an attachment disorder, and literally lack the ability to form healthy emotional bonds. You don't fix that through culture. "Instructors could create activities in which each student becomes an 'expert' on a different topic"? Come on man. They have to let go of the old DSM-5 model of "10-15 of the population is crazy, everyone else is perfectly fine". Psychologists have a far bigger role to play in society than they currently do. Fixing psychological and emotional problems through cultural change just doesn't solve anything. Fix the root cause. You would literally fix both the low self-esteem that inhibits people from asking questions, and the bullying that results from being seen as "dumb".
- bminor13 4y ago> but if we changed the culture to become more emotions-aware, people would know how to help each other and themselves far better. > Fixing psychological and emotional problems through cultural change just doesn't solve anything. By my reading, the two quotes are in direct opposition to one other. It sounds like you are advocating for cultural change - just a different type/approach than is currently used?
- concinds 4y ago
- watwut 4y ago> Until relatively recently, psychologists assumed that children did not start to care about their reputation and peers' perceptions until around age nine. Did they really? Cause anyone in contact with kids must have seen status seeking/preserving behaviors much sooner. The teachers compensate for it by checking on kids instead of expecting then to ask everything by themselves. The other thing is, there is right amount of asking questions. Some of it is too much and more independence is needed. Some of it is too little - and kids need to learn to guess the right amounts.
- User23 4y agoAnd that's doing the children a disservice. We are a status oriented species and trying to pretend that the game doesn't exist is just raising them to be ill-equipped for the reality they will inevitably face. The challenge you mention continues for one's entire life. There is a real tension between maintaining enough humility to learn and otherwise benefit from others while presenting as high enough status to get others to conform to your desires.
- noindiecred 4y agoOr maybe seeking status isn’t the way to go?
- User23 4y agoGaining status without seeking it is a very high status behavior.
- murphyslab 4y ago> we asked 576 children, ages four to nine, to predict the behavior of two kids in a story. One of the characters genuinely wanted to be smart, and the other merely wanted to seem smart to others. [...] > When children themselves are the ones struggling, it seems quite possible they, too, might avoid seeking out help when others are present, given our findings. Their reluctance could seriously impede academic progress. There's another side to the issue of “reputational” expectations which I've seen too many times in academic situations: People who only ask questions in order to look smart rather than to learn something. They know the answer, or at least think they do, and ask an inexperienced grad student a question about their area of expertise, even if it is at best tangential to the topic. That opposite process also can impede progress, since it tends to drown out genuine questions and less is learned in the process. Rarely do such questions enrich the conversation the way that a good “naïve” question does.
- idlehand 4y agoI have received this comment a few times in my career, "why don't you ask for help more"? Usually there is a simple reason: I am not having the same problem for very long, but whenever things are going smoothly they get done very quickly. The other, very common reason is that in the process of gathering the information I need to ask the correct question, the answer usually presents itself. The final reason is force of habit. I went through a school system where the teachers spend all of class, apart from presenting the material, helping the weak students keep up.
- hosh 4y agoI wonder how much of that is culture? For example, Dr. Carol Dewek studied kids with "growth mindset". Kids with such a mindset see failure as a path to more growth, whereas kids with "achievement mindset" do not. I also think about things like: - https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2018/06/09/616928895/how-to-get-your-kids-to-do-chores-without-resenting-it https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2018/06/09/6169288... ... Note here that the kids at the ages of 5, 7, etc. discussed in the article, will brag to each other about how helpful they are. However, their parents have been building their skills when they are toddlers and try to be helpful. - There is an in-depth article about implementing the "old enough to run errands" in America. Again, the author did not just throw their kid out on the street. They invested a lot of time skill-building. - The Montessori method, which emphasizes developing the capacity to be independent. Failure happens often - A study on toddlers and babies, and the effects of seeing how long adults struggle on how much they will continue to try something before giving up - Fred Rogers, commenting on leaving in footage where adults struggle and fail, and things don't go according to plan. My son is 20 months old, and my wife and I have been incorporating ideas from above. I might show him that it is possible to do something, and let him try (and at times, fail, and learn from the failure). We also prompt him by asking him if he wants help. Or put it another way: curate the environment, like you would when designing a video game levels to teach how to play, and smoothly increase the difficulty.
- Arrath 4y ago> - There is an in-depth article about implementing the "old enough to run errands" in America. Again, the author did not just throw their kid out on the street. They invested a lot of time skill-building. I often think about the chores and trips I took with my dad growing up, and how he slowly and cleverly worked me up to doing things. For instance when we would stop at a gas station, unless I had to go to the bathroom I had to stay in the car as it was dangerous, I might get hit by a car etc. But I could help by gathering any trash and handing it to him. Then as I got older, I could help by getting out and washing the side mirrors, then the door windows and finally the windshield once I could reach. The genesis really was that it was boring to sit in the car and I wanted to do something, and he capitalized on that. Same thing when we would take the recycling to the drop off point. First I had to stay in the car (you'll note a consistent theme here: I couldn't just stay at home at my leisure while chores were going on) and watch, then I could help with the light things like the cans, then the newspapers, then the glass. ....I'm still salty that I had to mow all 2 acres with a push mower for years and years, and he only bought a tractor with a giant mower deck after us kids moved out, though. The cheeky old bastard.
- contingencies 4y agoIn our house we actually have an informal "best question of the day" award which encourages us to share inquiries. It is intended to reinforce and reward curiosity and healthy attitudes to learning in children and seems to work. Other learning hacks: Complement questions. Admit when you don't know stuff, but then immediately look for answers, sharing your method and findings. Play scrabble with kids and allow arbitrary lookups to a permissive and multilingual dictionary such as wiktionary: a great way to learn amazing words, etymology and geography. Keep a globe around to reinforce geography while viewing documentaries or explaining things (eg. etymologies and language families). Keeping an HDMI output budget microscope connected to the TV for shared exploration of things (broken toys/circuitboards, botany, etc.). Gifting tools to children and encouraging their use to solve problems. http://earth.nullschool.net http://earth.nullschool.net when the weather changes. Bringing kids to work.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoIn my country, the (college) school year is ending and new one is starting (on oct 1st), and of course, some students didn't pass enough exams, some failed a year, but want to do exams for the next year, some want to know if they can get another chance at an exam, if they can blame covid for not finishing something, etc. Every college here as a students office, with an email address and a phone number (available few hours per workday), and they still rather ask an incomplete question on reddit (without specifying which college, what year, how many exams missing etc), than call the student office and just ask the only people who can actually answer the question correctly. So yeah... it's not just the "young" kids, but "older kids" too, old enough that making a phonecall shouldn't be an issue anymore.
- wildrhythms 4y agoI have a sneaking suspicion that university administration offices are run by a generation of people who don't know that young people do not use the telephone [1] (you did this too). Give students an all-purpose email address to contact, or a number to text, and I think you will find they are much more willing to get the right help. The medium does matter. [1] https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2014/05/09/311082149/not-so-social-media-why-people-have-stopped-talking-on-phones https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2014/05/09/31...
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoThey have an email.. and a phone number.. and office hours.
- robocat 4y agoIn your country is it normal to get help when you ask officials for help? For example: if you have a tax problem can you ask your tax department and get a valid response, or is it a glacial bureaucratic quagmire, with downside risks, backfiring where your questioning costs you? Are school administrators overworked, nasty, or just don’t give relevant advice? Are there hacks around the system that you can only find out through back-channels? Is it a cultural norm to seek workarounds or cheats?
- proc0 4y agoI'm somewhat of a slow learner, and one of the main reasons I would rarely ask for help was because people are not as helpful as they think they are. Most of the time it's a lazy attempt to answer questions at the surface level only, and attempting to follow up with further question ends in frustration quickly. People think they're helpful but in fact have small amounts of patience generally speaking. This was obvious when I was student of really good teachers who made sure to answer literally any question without judgement. Unless you're asking someone who has great confidence in their knowledge, asking a question can lead to an unpleasant situation. I've always scratched my head at this, since to me it's no problem to admit ignorance, but I've come to learn this isn't the case for most people, especially in front of others (i.e. a meeting). IMHO, getting others to ask more questions starts by allowing others to ask you anything without thinking it has multiple layers of meaning and/or intention.
- tolmasky 4y ago> I've always scratched my head at this, since to me it's no problem to admit ignorance, but I've come to learn this isn't the case for most people, especially in front of others (i.e. a meeting). Leaving ego aside, there's plenty of societal conditioning that explains this too. The negative feelings you may feel by not knowing something (i.e. in a meeting, or in a class...) can certainly plausibly be connected to being reprimanded for not knowing something. It's definitely the bizarre case that not having an immediate answer for something can result in "losing" an argument. Obviously this isn't the way it should be, but it certainly is the way it is many time, whether that be in low stakes argument about a TV show in a bar or a high stakes discussion about what technology you should use. But it goes back even further than that I think. In many ways, our entire school structure is designed around the idea that your success is tied to your ability to answer questions on the spot. Political debates are the same way, right? The reality is that the answer to every question in a debate should be some version of "well, I'd go and ask my cabinet and consult experts in this area..." So I don't think it should be that surprising that it makes people uncomfortable to not know something.
- proc0 4y agoRight, good point. I was being a little salty thinking of workplace environments, especially large companies where this "ask more questions" is often said, yet it's not true and can get you in trouble sometimes. I've had experiences with a boss at the time, where asking too many questions on a new task would seem like an avoidance of work or lack of confidence in getting it done. The team had a mindset of "ask anything", yet in some contexts they would interpret questions in a negative light because I guess it can seem like something is wrong and work is not getting done.
- bluedino 4y agoDon't teacher still tell kids someone along the lines of, "don't be afraid to ask questions, at least one other person probably has the same question"?
- panny 4y agoThis is largely the opposite of what I see during Q&As at tech conferences. Typically the asker puts forward a question to show off how much they know about the subject and challege the presenter. Perhaps this is due to the 'leetcode grinding' culture surrounding tech where everyone needs to display their ego.
- steve_john 4y agoYou can make people feel vulnerable. The moment you ask for directions, you reveal that you are lost. Seeking assistance can feel like you are broadcasting your incompetence. New research suggests young children don't seek help in school, even when they need it, for the same reason.
- nomel 4y agoFrom what I've seen, this is no different for adults. Getting adults to ask for help is really difficult, and I've given up trying to pursued it (inorganically), in the workplace. On the other hand, getting adults to give "XY Problem" [1] fueled demands is very very easy. 1. https://xyproblem.info https://xyproblem.info
- Godel_unicode 4y agoDeveloping the habit of repeatedly asking people for help and then taking it when they give it will fix this very quickly. You just have to be willing to go first. People feel much better about asking someone for help if they have given that person help in the past.
- nomel 4y agoI think this works very well for someone working directly in your domain, but doesn't work so well when you're a domain expert, outside of the others normal domain, since you can have a very small general, or mostly unidirectional specific, overlap.
- throwaway0asd 4y agoMy observation is that children afraid to ask for help grow into adults afraid to ask for help that have learned to mask their cowardice. Primary masking behaviors include: avoidance, blame shifting, excuses, stonewalling, logical fallacies, and so forth. I would say cowardice is a common bed fellow to deception.
- thelock85 4y ago“ Seeking help could even be framed as socially desirable.” Kinda buried an important part at the end of the article. Just last week I was doing a (not so rigorous) literature review on positive peer pressure for a work project, and in the largest meta study I could find, the conclusion was basically that the effect of peer influence depends on what’s cool to kids, and whether or not participation is publicly known to all peers. Anecdotally in a design project for pediatric emergency rooms that I worked on in grad school, our team observed kids not disclosing minor accidents to their parents, oftentimes with the parent(s) swearing that their kid would never not tell them something.
- quacked 4y agoThis feels a bit like shouting directly into a brick wall, but the problem is school. Every year, millions of young children are abandoned by their families [1] far before they learn self-control and placed into the care of jailers [2] who teach them day in and day out that the laws of the Institution trump their needs and desires. Anyone who tries to change self-esteem or fear of collaboration without challenging the practice of giving information to children via the teacher-to-30-student-classroom method will never solve anything at scale, ever. [1] The fact that there exist no good or pragmatic solutions to the abandonment does not mean the abandonment is not occurring. One of the earliest lessons that newly sentient modern children is "you need to leave your home and go to a place where you don't matter". [2] The fact that some fraction of teachers are well-intentioned, and that some sub-fraction of those teachers are actually competent, does not change their role as wardens of controlled and numbered children.
- mlyle 4y agoI think the hyperbole is unhelpful. School can be a place of learning and discovery and joy (most of the time: nowhere is joyful 100% of the time). I admit most of our schools don't attain this. Your answer doesn't leave any room for the improvement of school, merely to castigate the very idea of putting children together in classes. At my school, kids are excited to show up Monday morning-- interesting things are happening in our classes. They come see me and play with robots and do real engineering. They get to see their friends and do sports and coursework that "feels real". Sure, by the time Friday afternoon comes around, we're all done... but we'll be pretty excited to start it all again next week.
- quacked 4y agoI think we just ran into each other just recently when I posted "The Seven-Lesson Schoolteacher", but some other guy started talking your ear off and I didn't feel like stepping in to offer my own opinions. If you look at my response to another sub-commenter, you'll see a few of the things I'd like to add to school, some of which may appear more palatable to you than the abolition of the entire model. Ultimately, I'm gratified that you're a good teacher, but regrettably not only are you one of the few, you also are kept far back from the actual effect you could be having on kids by confining your expertise to the schooling model. You sound more like a mentor that could clearly steer a high number of kids through life from early to late ages, and you could run events and study plans that go late into the night and through the summer. If you were unconstrained by the rules of the school and unbound by the need for a retirement savings account and health insurance, you could run your own always-open institute where you teach whatever you want to whoever is willing to come and listen. The results you'd see under such a model would wildly outstrip the ones you see in school. My goal is to create a society filled with people like you--but that takes individuals who are parented well, and it can't be done under the factory schooling model, where the primary lesson learned is obedience to the institution. The other thing I'd like to point out is that none of the activities you mentioned require school to exist for them to be performed. People visited, played sports and music, and investigated science well before every single child went to school. The difference then was that it didn't "feel real", it "was real". School only provides an age-segregated simulation of greater society, and the more time you spend in greater society the more inaccurate that simulation seems. Regarding the hyperbole, I don't consider it to be hyperbole. Schools are constructed using the same techniques that prisons are constructed, the social cliques run similar to prisons, and in neither place are you allowed to leave or meaningfully challenge or change the rules of the institution. When you are in a school, you are not part of a thriving society, you are a subject that is managed according to the needs of the administration.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoThey are afraid to ask because teachers don't like it, because it disrupts class schedule.
- puyoxyz 4y agoSomewhat related: https://danluu.com/look-stupid/ https://danluu.com/look-stupid/