3 ms·
So the U.S. is on track to create a half-free university system, very convoluted and with extra steps and gate-keepers, tax funded? (It can of course never be c
by actionfromafar 4y ago
So the U.S. is on track to create a half-free university system, very convoluted and with extra steps and gate-keepers, tax funded? (It can of course never be completely free like some other rich western countries, because communism would ensue.)
Superficially it sounds like the U.S. health system. Please, enlightened people, write something insightful, I'm here for the comments and would like to get a vibe for if the article is a hit piece or has good points. :)
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIt is very much the same perverse incentives. Here, the less valuable education you get the greater the subsidy is. In healthcare, percent profit caps mean that the best way to increase profit is to increase prices
- t_mann 4y agoSimilar thoughts here - just make public universities (almost) free and stop giving out loans, and you'd be where most European countries are. I guess the thing is that once you've added all those extra layers it's hard to roll them back because so many jobs indirectly depend on them now (administrators, bankers, collectors,...), and some of them have quite strong lobbies (cough, bankers, cough).
- anonporridge 4y agoMy understanding is that the trade off in European systems is a much more stringent entrance requirement. So, university is free, but a smaller percentage of people have the scores to get in. Only about 30% of German students go to university, vs 40+% of Americans. This isn't the worst idea. College in the US is overly fetishized and trade schools and/or going directly to work or starting a business is snubbed. The result seems to be a deeply overeducated, but under employable population and an aging trade class that is entering retirement without having fully passed the torch to the next generation.
- t_mann 4y agoNo, afaik that's not the case everywhere. Switzerland, which has the best unis on the continent, is pretty open registration for all nationals, in others it's sort of a mix. Selection happens during the degrees, exams aren't curved.