6 ms·
When I was a kid in the 1980s, we heard about Soviet government propaganda to its citizens, including via Pravda. We were also taught how great the US is, by c
by neilv 4y ago
When I was a kid in the 1980s, we heard about Soviet government propaganda to its citizens, including via Pravda. We were also taught how great the US is, by contrast, that it doesn't do those things.
Later, I thought I'd learned (maybe misheard?) that US could engage in propaganda or psyops, but that there were strict rules not to do it against US citizens.
That seems like good guidance, and I'd welcome an honest review that checks whether we're living up to standards that have been an inspiring part of our national character in the past, and leads to any corrective action.
Maybe US collective leadership realizes a way here that we can build upon our ancestors' great ideals, and follow through further, not drop the ball.
- unity1001 4y ago> Later, I thought I'd learned (maybe misheard?) that US could engage in propaganda or psyops, but that there were strict rules not to do it against US citizens. That law was repealed in 2010. Since then its all out propaganda.
- tablespoon 4y ago> That law was repealed in 2010. Since then its all out propaganda. Cite? I'm aware there was some kind of awkward law that meant to block domestic access to VOA-type stuff (IIRC, because it was feared the VOA or State Department was infiltrated by Communists or something like that) that got repealed, but that's a far cry from "since then its all out propaganda." I mean, I don't think I've even seen a single VOA article in our local newspaper.
- black6 4y agoThe Smith-Mundt Modernization Act of 2012 opened the door for materials produced by the US Department of State and the Broadcast Board of Governors to be spread within the borders of the US.
- tablespoon 4y ago> The Smith-Mundt Modernization Act of 2012 opened the door for materials produced by the US Department of State and the Broadcast Board of Governors to be spread within the borders of the US. What's been the actual effect of that? It's been 10 years, and I can't recall seeing a VOA story reposted in a local outlet or radio stations switching to a VOA-based format.
- somenameforme 4y agoIt's rather more broad. The text from the bill itself, "The Secretary and the Broadcasting Board of Governors are authorized to use funds appropriated or otherwise made available for public diplomacy information programs to provide for the preparation, dissemination, and use of information intended for foreign audiences abroad about the United States, its people, and its policies, through press, publications, radio, motion pictures, the Internet, and other information media, including social media, and through information centers, instructors, and other direct or indirect means of communication." I don't understand the implications of that, because I don't know the details of the law beforehand. But something that's clear is that it opens the door to some very nasty stuff - especially if there is no obligation for source/identity disclosure.
- ImHereToVote 4y ago"What's been the actual effect of that?" What is the mainstream medias opinion on Julian Assange?
- takoid 4y agoAdditional context: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2013/07/americans-finally-have-access-american-propaganda/313305/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2013/07/america...
- IncandescentGas 4y agoNot that that law mattered before it was repealed. Here's a nytimes articles from 2005. > To a viewer, each report looked like any other 90-second segment on the local news. In fact, the federal government produced all three. The report from Kansas City was made by the State Department. The "reporter" covering airport safety was actually a public relations professional working under a false name for the Transportation Security Administration. > This winter, Washington has been roiled by revelations that a handful of columnists wrote in support of administration policies without disclosing they had accepted payments from the government. https://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/13/politics/under-bush-a-new-age-of-prepackaged-tv-news.html https://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/13/politics/under-bush-a-new...
- pessimizer 4y agoIt's bizarre that Armstrong Williams was the only person to pay a price for a massive government manipulation program, but it's typical. Judith Miller got to take responsibility for the entire Iraq war.
- Spooky23 4y agoThere are lots of instances like that. During the 1991 gulf war, they rolled out the “babies thrown out of incubators by the hun^H Iraqis”, I remember a 60 minutes segment after 9/11 talking to the Afghan government in exile, which consisted of a bunch of dudes in cube farm in Virginia.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoAnd Gulf War II was steamrolled with a ton of astroturfing "journalism". I will never forget the cheerleader role the New York Times played in the Iraq Invasion, from the straight-up swallowing of Colin Powell's false "evidence", egregious saber rattling "articles", it was depressing. "The paper of record" officially killed the fourth estate during that time period, and journalism has never recovered. I was a dumb 20something, and even I could see the vast conflicts of interests, the military industrial complex frothing at the mouth, the Cheney-fronted petroleum bigwigs cackling, and the callous political calculus of starting a war just to have a more important administration. Or the worst of all: trillions of dollars and a million dead iraqis just so Bush Jr could "show up" Bush Sr.
- Lutger 4y agoI don't really understand why not doing it to US citizens makes it ok. I can imagine one would find it permissible to use such techniques against your enemies, but this is very clearly also about your allies. To the US, American lives are all that really matter? I mean, there's also the policy that torture is ok but not against Americans and not on US territory, hence the secret CIA torture spaces during the Gulf War and guantonomo bay (simplifying a bit here). Isn't that obviously wrong? How can one maintain that their country is the greatest with such dubious ethics? I mean specifically using the argument 'doing objectionable things only to non US citizens' as part of the case for America's greatness seems...odd at best. I feel like I'm missing something here. A cultural gap maybe. Or is American superiority deemed so self evident that it legitimates itself in a circular justification? I don't want to sound combative, though I probably do, but really I want to understand how this works for Americans.
- Implicated 4y agoWe (Americans) don’t all feel this way. Personally, I feel the same way you do when I read things like this. I’m puzzled how it’s ok for anyone that wasn’t assigned an American citizenship in the birth lottery.
- neilv 4y agoI think different Americans have different awareness and thinking about those questions. I'd started to address that in my message, then awkwardly edited it out (see last sentence) before posting. It's easy to persuade that we should be honorable towards ourselves. Outside of ourselves are much more complicated and contentious geopolitical questions, I don't know the answers, and I thought negative reactions to raising that would defeat the smaller point.
- zmgsabst 4y ago> How can one maintain that their country is the greatest with such dubious ethics? Compared to who? > I mean specifically using the argument 'doing objectionable things only to non US citizens' as part of the case for America's greatness seems...odd at best. That is a rule of law (for their citizens) better than much of the world.
- 4y ago
- nimbius 4y agopropaganda can seem innocent enough at first, but its most insidious trait is that it eventually poisons and undermines even the most essential functions of your government not only during a crisis but through even its most mundane operational capabilities. institutions once intended to act and think critically and challenge orthodoxy in the service of advancement of the nation now become an artifice for furthering a dead ideology or deleterious policy. Whatever good you thought US propaganda could do to bolster things like patriotism or civic duty, it does exponentially more damage by crippling the basic ability to challenge paradigms or uncomfortable situations and decisions that if avoided may very well plunge your state into ruin.
- zoomablemind 4y agoIndeed. Propaganda, just as disinformation, in the long run results in mistrust and cynicism. I guess, this may hamper critical thinking and eventually can polarize the society by overweighting the groups on the extremes of the spectrum and padding the middle with the cynics.
- angrycontrarian 4y ago> Propaganda, just as disinformation, in the long run results in mistrust and cynicism. The notion that facts which are unapproved by the government are disinformation, is the propaganda.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoOne of my history teachers in high school had a large stack of 'Soviet Life' magazines that he said we could read if we wanted whenever we were done with our work but he warned they were propaganda. I was surprised by what I read because I was expecting it to be stories about the evils of capitalism and the mighty strength of communism but instead it was mostly 'slice of life' stories about average people in the various Soviet republics. Took me a while to figure out that was the propaganda. Part of that was due to my preconceived notions of what propaganda would look like because I had been primed by popular media in the US to expect it to be "you capitalist pigs" rants instead of one that pushed the narrative that the Soviets were peacefully trying to go about their lives without bothering anyone. I often wonder if that's why our teach made them available to us so we'd figure that out on our own.
- itronitron 4y agoAs long as the DOD employs military recruiters they are engaging in psychological operations.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- behaveEc0n00 4y agoThey privatized it by passing technical propaganda research to universities who modeled it into behavioral economics, marketing, advertising. Social media is built with such research in mind. Society will never stop trying to wrap a big fuzzy one size fits all blanket around everyone’s thoughts. We intentionally manipulate biology that religion stumbled upon. A philosophy of “oh well there is this separation of powers written down on paper” does not stop graft, nepotism. Tribalism is innate to human biology; words on paper don’t just shut our bodies innate traits off. Thinking a law prevents intentional propagandizing is quaint and naive. They just call the same behavior and mechanics “behavioral economics” and viola; it may have all the mechanics of propaganda, but trust us, it’s not propaganda.
- SailingSperm 4y agoAnd they probably do the same thing as 5 eyes[1] to 'stay honest' - have their allies do those things to their citizens and them do it to their allies, then share the intel. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Five_Eyes#Domestic_espionage_sharing_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Five_Eyes#Domesti... (a treaty for joint cooperation in signals intelligence.)
- asdff 4y agoThe U.S. doesn't need to engage in those things when the media apparatus is such that it is in this country. You should read Manufacturing Consent if you want to learn about how the U.S. extremely effectively serves propaganda to its citizens using the apparatus of the mass media. Even just reading about the decisionmaking going on out of public eyes during the Vietnam war would be enough. Gulf of Tonkin incident that kick started the war, for example, we know now was a false flag (1). 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulf_of_Tonkin_incident#NSA_report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulf_of_Tonkin_incident#NSA_re...
- warner25 4y agoI'd like to share a memory as a currently serving US military officer: At the height of our operations in Iraq, around 2006-2007, the main killer of our troops was of course "roadside bombs." In a candid talk with my class of cadets at that time, I remember a senior officer (a conventional infantry or artillery guy) telling us that the top priority had to be reducing this specific threat, above all the stated goals of our mission. His reasoning was that, although we knew roadside bombs were not going to tactically defeat any unit larger than a platoon, the deaths were eroding the American public's support of our operations and would ultimately force us to withdraw and abandon all of the stated goals. He was right, but I remember feeling uncomfortable with his thinking. It wasn't outright psychological operations against Americans, and I'm sure he wasn't tasked with that nor thinking of it that way, but it was trying to influence the opinion of American civilians who are supposed to be in control of the military. Of course public affairs stuff and reports to congress, while meant to inform, are also usually crafted to influence. Anyway, this is how it starts, and I'm not sure it's obvious when a line is crossed.
- lobocinza 4y agoIt was an effort to change the material fact that Americans were dying and not an effort to distort/hide the truth.
- warner25 4y agoYes, but it wasn't to save lives for the sake of saving lives, to preserve combat power or because troops' lives are inherently valuable. The senior officer wanted operations to continue and wanted to prevent the American public from turning them off, whereas my perspective was (and still is): let the public weigh deaths vs. the mission, and if they want the mission to end, then so be it. From his perspective, though, the boss gave him a mission to do great things, and it was clear that he couldn't do those things if public opinion turned and operations ended. Edited to add: I don't think most "influence operations" on Facebook and Twitter, as described in the article, are about hiding or distorting the truth either.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lukas099 4y ago> When I was a kid in the 1980s, we heard about Soviet government propaganda to its citizens, including via Pravda. Lol. Assuming you went to public school, you've already proven that the U.S.G. did propaganda to its people too.
- fuzzfactor 4y agoMedia technology has always had an outsized effect. This is right out of the 1960's. Not exactly the dawn of television, more like about 7:30, 8:00 in the morning when you're finally really waking up: >Propaganda is a subject of great concern in our society today, perhaps more so than in any other society in history. With the advent of television as a complement to the other communications media now available to us, the opportunities to use propaganda in disseminating information, expounding ideas, and offering opinions have increaseed considerably. And, unfortunately, it is far too often the case that propaganda is used to make us accept questionable points-of-view, to make us vote for men who may be unfit for public office, and to make us buy products which are useless and sometimes even dangerous. Therefore, propaganda, or the method of influencing people to believe certain ideas and to follow certain courses of action, is of special importance to each of us. from https://propaganda.games/about https://propaganda.games/about Of course back then almost nobody had even seen a color TV yet, and when color eventually became less rare they were really hypnotic like never before. There's always these well-worn techniques: https://propaganda.games/technique https://propaganda.games/technique This actually started as an academic game during the Cold War, by a TV actor who had first-hand knowledge from associates who were blacklisted a decade earlier as suspected communists, in what can only be seen as an exaggerated over-reaction to actual Communist propaganda itself. https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-20408094 https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-20408094 For both communist and anti-communist propaganda, students were expected to be better off if they were more prepared to see through the BS.
- JaceLightning 4y agoIn 2013, Obama signed legislation that changed the U.S. Information and Educational Exchange Act of 1948, also known as the Smith-Mundt Act. The amendment made it possible for some materials created by the U.S. Agency for Global Media, the nation’s foreign broadcasting agency, to be disseminated in the U.S.