3 ms·
I hate this one because while it says: "I have two children and one is a son born on a Tuesday." It actually means: "I have two children and only one of
by ars 15y ago
I hate this one because while it says:
"I have two children and one is a son born on a Tuesday."
It actually means:
"I have two children and only one of them is a son
born on a Tuesday."
You are supposed to just assume this modification.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- user24 15y agomore than that, the modification is inconsistently applied; we're supposed to magically know that only one is born on Tuesday, but not that only one is son. edit: accidental downvote, sorry. edit2: but see my top-level reply to OP.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- reitzensteinm 15y agoOK, after rereading the article, I'm wrong about this - that's not what the author is doing. Post deleted to not spread confusion myself...
- tallanvor 15y agoNo, you are not supposed to assume that only one of them is a son born on a Tuesday. The 13/27 probability comes from the knowledge that one is a son born on a Tuesday, but you don't know which child this refers to - the other child being a son born on a Tuesday is covered in the 13/27 probability.
- ars 15y agoNo, the 13 was arrived at by excluding the possibility that the second child was a boy on Tuesday. (Read the article again and see.) Once you include that possibility it's back to 14/28.
- ajanuary 15y agoWhen considering the case that the older son was the one born on a Tuesday, that gives 14/28 possibilities. One of those 14 is the case that both were born on Tuesday. When considering the case that the younger son was the one born on a Tuesday, that gives 14/28 possibilities. One of those 14 is the case that both were born on a Tuesday. But woops, we've already covered the case that both were born on a Tuesday in our first count. Removing the duplication gives the 13/27. You then combine those two probabilities. The 13 wasn't arrived at by excluding the possibility that the second child was a boy on Tuesday, it was arrived at by discounting the case that they were both born on Tuesday as it had already been covered in the previous sub-calculation.
- ars 15y agoNo, you do not remove the duplication. If you have two kids there are 4 possibilities, not 3: BG, BG, BB, GG BG seems to be the same as GB, except that it's not. And it's not in this case either.
- ajanuary 15y agoLooking at your simple example of genders using the same process the article uses to enumerate the combination of gender and days: Assuming Child 1 is a Boy: Child 2 can be: Boy, Girl Assuming Child 1 is a Girl: Child 2 can be: Boy, Girl Assuming Child 2 is a Boy: Child 1 can be: Boy, Girl Assuming Child 2 is a Girl: Child 1 can be: Boy, Girl Combining those gives us the following combinations: Child 1 | Child 2 ---------+--------- Boy | Boy Boy | Girl Girl | Boy Girl | Girl Boy | Boy Girl | Boy Boy | Girl Girl | Girl Clearly there is duplication in there we need to remove any exact duplications before we get to the 4 possibilities you listed. Now looking at the problem in the article again, but using a 2 day week for brevity: Assuming Child 1 is a Boy on Tues: Child 2 can be: Boy on Mon, Boy on Tues, Girl on Mon, Girl on Tues Assuming Child 2 is a Boy on Tues: Child 1 can be: Boy on Mon, Boy on Tues, Girl on Mon, Girl on Tues Combining those gives us the following combinations: Child 1 | Child 2 --------------+------------- Boy on Tues | Boy on Mon Boy on Tues | Boy on Tues Boy on Tues | Girl on Mon Boy on Tues | Girl on Tues Boy on Mon | Boy on Tues Boy on Tues | Boy on Tues Girl on Mon | Boy on Tues Girl on Tues | Boy on Tues In exactly the same way, removing exact duplications gives us 3/7. There is no ordering over the Tuesdays. "The older child being born on Tuesday and the younger child being born on Tuesday" is exactly the same as "The younger child being born on Tuesday and the older child being born on Tuesday". Just like "The older child being a boy and the younger child being a boy" is the same as "The younger child being a boy and the older child being a boy".
- fuzzix 15y ago"I have two children and one is a son born on a Tuesday." If it were about the phrasing you could assume the other child is a daughter - if he were to continue ... "The other is also a son, born on a Friday" it would just sound strange. Perhaps it is all down to his turn of phrase :)
- danparsonson 15y agoNo I don't think that's true. Bear with me :-) There are 14 possible permutations for a child Mon-Sun Girl Mon-Sun Boy which for two children gives a total of 28: Child 1 is Boy, born Mon-Sun Child 1 is Girl, born Mon-Sun Child 2 is Boy, born Mon-Sun Child 2 is Girl, born Mon-Sun Note that we haven't said which child is 1 and which is 2, and in fact we don't know because we haven't been told - this is the important bit. So, for our unknown child to be a boy, it must be one of the following 14 permutations: unknown child is Child 1, boy, born Mon-Sun unknown child is Child 2, boy, born Mon-Sun but one of those permutations is already taken by our known Tuesday boy, so we have to remove one of the Tuesday permutations leaving 13 possible outcomes out of 27. Note that one of those 13 outcomes is 'unknown child is son born on Tuesday' - it's perfectly valid to have both sons born on a Tuesday. Note also that we can't say which permutation we're removing until we know which is Child 1 and which is Child 2, just that one of them is taken. If the original statement were phrased as '... the older child is a son born on a Tuesday' then you would have a constraint on which was Child 1 and which was Child 2 and then the probability would be 1/2 as expected because you would know up front that you were entirely discounting, say, Child 1, AND that the removed Tuesday permutation also belonged to Child 1. But I stand to be corrected!
- ars 15y agoFirst, saying Mon-Sun is confusing almost everyone since most people start the week on Sun, not Mon. (Even in Europe Christians start the week on Sunday.) In any case, as I replied here http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3290118 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3290118 you can not remove the duplication! It's two different situations, even though they may appear the same.
- danparsonson 15y agoajanuary explains the duplicates problem nicely here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3290185 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3290185 so I won't double up. I've spent the last hour and a half wrestling with the same clash between maths and intuition that you're experiencing so I understand your frustration - 13/27 really is the right answer though.