8 ms·
Why Figma Is Worth $20B and Other Observations from the Adobe Acquisition
- PaulHoule 4y agoIt's not as big as Creative Cloud (which isn't really a cloud-based product), but https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adobe_Experience_Cloud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adobe_Experience_Cloud is a real SaaS product which strikes me as closer to Figma than CC in terms of how it goes to market. XC and other server-side products seem to generate a bit less than half the revenue of CC. Adobe has made some effort to cloudify CC but I think those efforts have been pretty weak.
- ec109685 4y agoGreat thread talking about how difficult it is to bolt on cloud to a non-cloud native product: https://twitter.com/amaldorai/status/1570516169848918017?s=20&t=BT7jq3HHdtF-hFmZ4qDB2w https://twitter.com/amaldorai/status/1570516169848918017?s=2... Admittedly, Microsoft was able to do this to a decent approximation for Office, but it’s still far from as capable as their desktop apps.
- king_magic 4y agoI went into this about to eyeroll the hell out of anything arguing Figma is worth $20B, but actually walked away thinking "huh, I kind of buy that argument".
- pavlov 4y agoWhen you're selling something unique, its worth is whatever somebody will pay for it. Figma is worth $20B because: 1) Adobe can afford $20B, 2) there were other bidders to whom Figma was worth something substantial but not quite $20B. It's the same logic that made WhatsApp worth $19B in 2014 to Facebook specifically. Others were interested, but one buyer was really determined to have it.
- mamonster 4y agoWeird article. Point 1 is exactly correct: This is a purely defensive play designed to protect their existing market cap. Figma and Canva put the once ironclad Adobe cashflows at risk, simple as. In that sense, paying 20 billion to protect and enhance your market cap is a no brainer. Point 2 and 3 however I disagree with heavily. Figma purchase is exactly about Adobe's failures to build a good competitor, its not like Figma is this new arrival, people were raving about it for quite some time already and Adobe had a lot of time to respond. This purchase shows that Adobe's cashflows are nowhere near as secure as they were thought to be, hence the rerating on the stock is not a simple blip. And that Lina Khan should stay off this? Give me a break, this is exactly what she should be targeting if she is serious about antitrust. Adobe + Figma bundle destroys this market for anything not named Canva for at least 5-6 years. The idea that FTC should reward innovation by allowing monopolistic/oligopolistic buyouts for big prices is how Whatsapp and Instagram ended up with Facebook.
- WillAdams 4y agoThe thing which kills me is that Adobe won't do an on-line text editor which supports styles which will then seamlessly import into InDesign. Surely they're not making that much from InCopy licenses that this wouldn't pay off in the long-term.
- karaterobot 4y agoIn my mind, points 2 and 3 conflict with point 1. If Adobe actually believed Figma was an existential threat to the future of their business, and they decided to use their current dominance to subsume it, that's equivalent to admitting failure at some level. And if that's true, then they're trying to stamp out any meaningful competition, which is the kind of thing the FTC should at least be paying attention to.
- ghiculescu 4y agoWhat is the antitrust risk? As both you and the author say, there’s viable alternatives in the market - and this deal will encourage more of them. It’s unclear how any consumers are harmed by this.
- PaulWaldman 4y agoThere are two questions: 1. How repeatable is Figma and is this analogous to Dropbox? Now every major cloud vendor provides a Dropbox clone. Dropbox's market cap has been stagnant. Figma may have suffered the same fate if Adobe built their own clone or acquired an alternative product. 2.How will it be integrated with Adobe's traditional products? If this means less design focused users can create quick mockups to send to actual designers within Adobe's cloud, it's a win. Alternatively heavy users of Figma, without current exposure to Adobe, are now brought into the Creative Cloud ecosystem. I also wonder what this did to Canva's valuation. Last year at the time, Canva raised $200MM at a $40B valuation.
- apocalyptic0n3 4y ago> Figma may have suffered the same fate if Adobe built their own clone or acquired an alternative product. Adobe already tried this with Adobe XD. The designers I've spoken to consider the software a joke, which is why Figma has continued to grow in popularity so quickly and why Adobe believed this price tag was required. After the announcement, there were multiple reports saying Adobe contacts said XD would be discontinued (or at least support dropped to just a maintenance level). There's also the third-party Sketch, but that is Mac-only. As for Canva... that serves a different market doesn't it? XD, Figma, and Sketch are all focused on rapid prototyping and app design. Canva is focused on social media and presentation design. I've admittedly never looked too far into Canva, though, so I could be wrong.
- ec109685 4y agoI think canva over time is going to go up market more effectively than Adobe can go down market (or maintain status quo). Adobe’s products are monstrously complex, “single player”, and not inherently web native, and that permeates everything they do. Maybe Figma will let them compete more effectively with Canva now.
- pjmlp 4y agoThose designers most likely aren't doing native development, which is where Adobe XD used to be relatively good, in fact was introduced as one of the first Adobe products being on Windows store.
- moralestapia 4y agoWhat baffles me in this (and other similar) acquisition(s) is, Adobe is a great company and for sure has great developers on its sleeve. It would cost them much less than 20B to develop a Figma clone and just offer it as part of their suite, they wouldn't have an issue positioning it in the market. Heck, with about a million and a talented team you could build a pretty decent Figma alternative, so why did Adobe pay an extra 19,999(!) million? Is it the community? The brand? Didn't want to risk it? To put them out of bussiness (just as Adobe could've made Figma, Figma as well could've started building their own Illustrator, Photoshop, etc...)? So, why?
- teknopurge 4y agoAdobe already had xD - a direct competitor to Figma. Adobe purchased Figma for many reasons; if you want a single reason why Adobe purchased Figma it's because Figma was successful: all the things that go into executing a vision at scale.
- ghiculescu 4y agoIt’s nuts to think Adobe could clone Figma for $1M. That’s a headcount of 2-4, working on it for a single year. That’s off by several orders of magnitude.
- pier25 4y agoI agree, but even if it cost Adobe $1B to build something like Figma, why spend the extra $19B?
- ghiculescu 4y agoBecause what if it wasn’t as good, and nobody bought it? Then they are where they are today minus 1B spent. This seems to be what happened with their XD product.
- pier25 4y ago> This seems to be what happened with their XD product Hmm I don't know. I mean, yeah XD absolutely failed, but when Adobe released it in 2016 Figma wasn't nearly as popular as it is today. My guess is when Adobe decided to build XD (a couple of years before 2016) they were trying to compete with Sketch. So they probably missed the collaborative web-based aspect that made Figma popular. And maybe XD was just an underbudgeted experiment to test the waters, not a serious product like Photoshop. Edit: I just realized Figma was released in 2016. I was probably thinking of InVision.
- toss1 4y agoThe author's final point is extremely good. The result of this should spawn a herd of Figma-like companies, since a good exit and big payout is strongly assured by both a validated market and backstopped by the likelihood of an Adobe buyout. >>I’m not making a legal argument here about the FTC and how you define antitrust, monopoly, etc with regards to M&A. I’m just saying I think it’s stupid and short-sighted to block a transaction like this. Adobe is giving their pound of flesh. Figma is being incredibly well-rewarded for innovation. And if you remove the potential for acquisitions by the market leader from the startup playbook you’ll actually get fewer startups going after the market leaders. And that has worse ramifications for the economy and for consumers than incremental consolidation like this. Especially since there are plenty of other tools available to accomplish one or more of the same functions Figma does.
- rr888 4y agoPossibly but customers quickly learn that these Adobe alternatives quickly disappear, so avoid. I know because I bought a bunch of Lightroom-like applications that are no longer supported.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pier25 4y agoAn angle I haven't seen this mentioned anywhere is... what if this was like Apple buying Next? Adobe wouldn't be really buying the product for market reasons, but rather the expertise and leadership. Or who knows, maybe they want to put the Figma CEO at Adobe's helm in a couple of years.
- bearjaws 4y agoFigma to me was what 'back to office managers' have dreaded, my entire last jobs return to office was predicated on the fact that 'you can't beat a good white boarding session'. Figma is the best white boarding software I have ever used and it has made our team far more productive than I ever imagined. Once they start rolling out more end to end features (e.g. towards inDesign) Adobe was going to be losing out.
- hotdamnson 4y agoWould it be actually legal for the Figma owners to sell the company to Adobe, create the new company, say Figma2.0 and create similar(better) product from scratch, also advertise it as creators of original Figma come up with Figma2.0?
- dcdc123 4y agoThat depends entirely on the contract with Adobe which almost definitely would prevent that.
- outside1234 4y agoIt's also hard to imagine the founders _want_ to do that. It is a slog to get a company from nothing to this. If anything, they probably want to tackle some other problem.
- pacetherace 4y ago1. Generally the buyer will sue for IP infringement or accessing confidential business data if ex-founders leave immediately after selling the company and build a competing product 2. The buyer will generally put terms in the M&A contract that forbids the main guys of the acquired company from building or working on competing products for a year or two
- jasode 4y ago>legal for the Figma owners to sell the company to Adobe, create the new company, say Figma2.0 and create similar(better) product from scratch, Not possible for this type of acquisition. It was reported that this was a cash+stock deal. The typical acquisition contract means the Figma founders would likely have "golden handcuffs" to stay on as employees of Adobe where their Adobe stock would vest over several years. (Say 4 years.) The contract also means they have a standard "no compete" clause and can't quit and start similar company for several years.
- duped 4y agoIt's rather bold to lay out the FTC's case to block this acquisition, then argue that they shouldn't. The point of antitrust isn't to make sure companies have a pound of flesh exacted or acquirees get rich - it's so companies can't use their market cap to monopolize industries and jack up prices to consumers.
- cpurdy 4y agoIt's also important to understand the uplift that an established company can have on sales. * Adobe has a subscription model in place, with a large number of customers * Adobe has bundles already, and this could allow them to expand some of those bundles or introduce new bundles * Adobe may be able to (successfully) charge more for the same product, because they're a bigger company that charges more already for other stuff I list these items because I got to witness an acquisition of a product company first hand (I was the founder and CEO) and the acquiring company was able to derive on the order of 10x revenue from the acquired product, vis-a-vis the trailing 12 months before acquisition. $20 billion is a steep price, but if the product fills an important gap, if aggregate demand (and fit with the other products) is strong, and if Adobe can drive sales effectively, then it is possible that the acquisition could pay off quickly. On the other hand, I've seen quite a few failed acquisitions that will never pay for themselves; nothing here is a given.