5 ms·
I see. So whenever monthly inflation goes up, it's transitory, and when it doesn't, there is no inflation. Meanwhile, prices on a lot of things I buy doubled.
by WalterBright 4y ago
I see. So whenever monthly inflation goes up, it's transitory, and when it doesn't, there is no inflation.
Meanwhile, prices on a lot of things I buy doubled.
- iso1631 4y agoYour own personal inflation may be different to the typical rate encountered by the typical person US Gas prices are $3.68 a gallon, down from over $5 a few months ago. That's hardly inflation. https://gasprices.aaa.com/state-gas-price-averages/ https://gasprices.aaa.com/state-gas-price-averages/ Picking a random date about 6 months ago it was $4.25 https://web.archive.org/web/20220310032222/https://gasprices.aaa.com/state-gas-price-averages/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220310032222/https://gasprices... Lumber prices are down 65% since March, about the same as this time last year, and indeed back in 2018 https://markets.businessinsider.com/commodities/lumber-price?op=1 https://markets.businessinsider.com/commodities/lumber-price... This is not symptomatic of hyperinflation, it's symptomatic of supply being lower than demand, causing an increase in supply or a decrease in demand, which takes time
- WalterBright 4y ago> US Gas prices are $3.68 a gallon, down from over $5 a few months ago. That's hardly inflation. If gas prices drive inflation, why are we not seeing deflation from the gas price drop?
- sangnoir 4y agoHave you factored in human greed?
- Brusco_RF 4y agoYes, I have. I greedily want to keep as much of my money as I can so I buy the cheapest goods available, sending money to the greedy corporation who offers goods at the lowest price. This stubborn hand-wavy argument that prices stay high due to greed smacks of economic illiteracy and White House propaganda.
- sangnoir 4y agoCharging prices the market will bear is considered "hand-wavy" or propaganda now? If I raise the price of a gizmo I'm selling by 20% because my costs went up, why would I reduce the price when my costs go down but demand is still high? I like my increased profits, and so does my competition. The myth of perfect competition is a exactly that: established companies do not engage in races to the bottom, "cartel" behavior is emergent.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhy do gasoline prices go up and down all the time? same for airline ticket prices? I'm afraid your theory has a lot of 'splainin' to do.
- sangnoir 4y agoYou've cherry-picked 2 outlying low-margin, high-velocity products where there is a race to the bottom. I counter your gas with smartphones, where Apple and Samsung are ratcheting up the price year over year, while competitors like LG are bowed out. Why couldn't LG compete at lower prices, and chose to exit the smartphone market entirely? How does your perfect competition theory explain why tuition prices have been going up over 5+ decades, vastly exceeding inflation?
- prottog 4y agoThe same tuition prices that has the full faith and credit of the federal government behind it driving it up?
- WalterBright 4y ago> Why couldn't LG compete at lower prices, and chose to exit the smartphone market entirely? Because Apple keeps making the phone better. > How does your perfect competition theory explain why tuition prices have been going up over 5+ decades, vastly exceeding inflation? I didn't espouse a "perfect competition" theory. That's your strawman. Anyhow, tuition prices have gone up because the government provides rivers of cash to prospective students. The pool of students thus has gone up drastically, and because of limited supply of colleges, and vast demand by students with fistfuls of cash (and little sense), the tuition went up. A lot.
- iso1631 4y agoGas isn't the only input into prices. Salaries are up 10% in a year for example. Changes in costs also take time to filter through the economy, and indeed in the last 2 months prices have come down (CPI in June was 296.311, in August it was 296.171)
- dragonwriter 4y ago> So whenever monthly inflation goes up, it's transitory, and when it doesn't, there is no inflation. No, when consumer prices (not inflation) goes up, there is inflation, and when they don’t, as they have not (overall) in the last two months, there isn't. That’s the definition of inflation. > Meanwhile, prices on a lot of things I buy doubled. So... assuming that's over a 12-month period, there are some things that you buy that have been affected vastly more by inflation than even the highest overall sector of the CPI (fuel oil, +68.8% over 12 months.) Not sure what general importance you want assigned to this or why.
- mise_en_place 4y agoThe CPI is not calculated honestly. If you use the CPI tabulation from the 1970s inflation will be way higher than what the current govt statistics from BLS state. For example, Owner’s Equivalent Rent is used, not actual rent that many families are struggling to pay. In addition, the Fed’s core inflation number is ex food and energy prices, which is also misleading.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The CPI is not calculated honestly None of your argument supports that it isn't calculated honestly, just that you don't like the particular choices. And it doesn't help that you misrepresent them. > For example, Owner’s Equivalent Rent is used, not actual rent that many families are struggling to pay. Actual rent is used for renters. Owner’s equivalent rent (imputed rent) is used instead of asset purchase costs to assess the consumption cost of housing separate from the cost of acquiring a durable asset for homeowners. > In addition, the Fed’s core inflation number is ex food and energy prices, which is also misleading. The headline number is the full CPI, not core CPI. Core CPI is also reported, and may be used for some purposes by certain consumers of CPI data, but it's not the headline figure/main measure, so disagreement with its appropriateness as the main measure is fine, but a beating a strawman.
- notahacker 4y ago> For example, Owner’s Equivalent Rent is used, not actual rent that many families are struggling to pay. This is simply false. Firstly CPI includes both rent and owners equivalent rent, weighted in proportion to the people that rent and own houses respectively. Secondly, OER is calculated based on estimates of current rental prices. Plus of course including OER rather than treating rent as something homeowners don't have to worry about tends to increase CPI when rents rise fast... > In addition, the Fed’s core inflation number is ex food and energy prices, which is also misleading. "Core inflation" is a separate time series to the CPI, clearly reported as an alternative measure excluding volatile energy and food prices to compare with CPI. The only "misleading" is people ranting about how a separate dataset created specifically for comparison purposes proves dishonesty on the part of those calculating CPI...