6 ms·
Set this theory against the fact that there was zero net inflation in the US from 1800 to 1914, and endemic inflation since. What changed in 1914? The US switch
by WalterBright 4y ago
Set this theory against the fact that there was zero net inflation in the US from 1800 to 1914, and endemic inflation since. What changed in 1914? The US switched to a fiat money system.
Clearly, it has something to do with fiat money.
(The Revolutionary Government also had massive inflation, and the Confederacy, too. What characteristic did they share? Fiat money.)
If shortages caused inflation, then one would expect to see corresponding deflation when those shortages eased. But that doesn't happen.
- digdugdirk 4y agoThe most inflationary currency in history, pegged to a gold standard: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungarian_peng%C5%91 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungarian_peng%C5%91 Economies are complicated dynamical systems, I think we can all agree that there are many possible variables in the inflation equation.
- WalterBright 4y agoHere's the critical sentence from your cite: "It was valued at 12,500 korona, and defined as 3,800 to one kilogram of fine gold – which meant that the pengő was pegged to the gold standard, but without exchange obligation." Which means it can be inflated at will. The US did the same thing, pegging the dollar to gold, then inflating the paper money. The result was fiscal collapse leading to the Great Depression. The fix was to make it illegal to exchange dollars for gold, making the "gold standard" a complete fiction.
- neffo 4y agoI think you are conflating a few things. What you have to remember with the gold standard is that the supply (or probably more correct, holdings) of gold determine the money supply when a gold standard is in place, as does the price of gold (the conversion rate). A reduction in the money supply (fear of deflation, leading to bank runs) and a massive withholding of production are generally the two key events cited as causes of the Great Depression. The later being the reason for the massive public works programs of the time were started. The inflation of the US currency happened much later. Roosevelt banned private holdings of monetary gold and gold certificates, incentivized gold imports and gold production which lead to the inflation. That was nearly 5 years into the depression though.
- WalterBright 4y ago> supply (or probably more correct, holdings) of gold determine the money supply when a gold standard is in place It does not when the money is not convertible to gold. Such is a fictitious gold standard. The bank runs in the Depression were caused by inflation devaluing the value of a dollar by about half since 1914, yet was still convertible to gold. People suddenly realized they could DOUBLE THEIR MONEY by converting their paper money to gold. So they ran to the banks to do this. Of course, there wasn't enough gold to support that, and the banks collapsed. The runs did not stop until FDR made it illegal to exchange dollars for gold. > The inflation of the US currency happened much later Check the historical inflation figures. The dollar lost half its value 1914-29.
- overboard2 4y agoAccording to the wikipedia article, the pengő was very stable while it was pinned to the gold standard.
- fuzzfactor 4y agoThe hyperinflation for them took off after all the coins had been hoarded eventually during the more gradual devaluations beforehand. Regardless of being officially pegged to gold this is where they went wild printing all new notes for which there was no physical backing. Leaving their precious metal reserves more valuable to other countries than their own. They probably continued to hoard them anyway. >Economies are complicated dynamical systems, I think we can all agree that there are many possible variables in the inflation equation. No doubt about it, there's simultaneous equations for which solutions are not well-known, obvious, or forthcoming.
- antipurist 4y ago> In one of the last acts of World War II, the Szálasi government took control of banknote printing and issued notes without any cover In this example, the only important variable was M, as expected.
- neffo 4y agoThe 1800s were hardly an economic paradise though, the wild inflation/deflation cycles were destructive. Long-term stable, 2-3% inflation appears to be a good thing. It's not overly destructive to savings, but it's an incentive to invest in something productive in the long-term. Deflation does occur when shortages ease in those sectors (see oil & gas prices), but inflation due to shortages does increase the general price level (including wage prices) and there is a degree of 'price stickiness' in the economy (workers generally don't get pay cuts - layoffs are easier perhaps) so the higher price level remains. You might expect below average inflation in the short term, but inflation expectations probably linger to some degree.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhy doesn't deflation occur? Deflation occurred on the gold standard, as prices are not that sticky. Besides, a general price increase doesn't occur without an increase in the supply of money relative to the value in the economy. That doesn't happen unless the printing press is run. > The 1800s were hardly an economic paradise though, the wild inflation/deflation cycles were destructive. Every one of those was caused by government meddling with the currency. Why is 9% inflation (what we have today) not destructive? It certainly is destructive to my finances.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Why is 9% inflation (what we have today) We have approximately 0% inflation today (at least, the monthly—not the headline 12-month trailing, but the actual amount for the month—number for the last two months has been between 0% and 0.1%; 0% to a little over 1% annualized.) The 12-month trailing is 8.3%, but it takes a while for the 12-month trailing to reflect current conditions, when there is a change, for reasons explained by the name.
- WalterBright 4y agoI see. So whenever monthly inflation goes up, it's transitory, and when it doesn't, there is no inflation. Meanwhile, prices on a lot of things I buy doubled.
- fuzzfactor 4y ago>they often think it is just a case of governments printing too much money. The exorbitant banknotes we see in this collection are more like each government's response to inflation once it has gone completely out-of-control. In some sense they are trying to arrest the free-fall at an artificially imposed numerical point, by basically normalizing the losses already incurred up until that time. Just goes to show how much easier it can be to manipulate the value of fiat currency compared to coin of stored value. Seems like when stocks & bonds are denominated in fiat currency, in order for the securities to maintain their relative value, whilst maintaining volatility within tolerable ranges, the only direction for the currency to ever trend is being downward in value by comparison. When stock certificates represent overwhelmingly more stored value than their equivalent in legal tender, that's not when you're going to have the most prosperity overall. This is not the way free enterprise started out. We recovered well from that most recent devaluation is something that no ordinary wage earner said ever.
- scott_w 4y agoThat first theory doesn’t hold because ancient empires such as the Romans did suffer a form of inflation. They just didn’t know what it was when they kept devaluing their currency.
- daniel-cussen 4y agoThey didn't have that word for it, but they would for instance talk about debasement for instance with putting base metals inside the coinage metals, the precious metals suitable for making coins. Although for sure some Romans used the word puffed up like a leather bag full of hot breath to hunt whales (one poet talking about whale hunting in the time of Marcus Aurelius). It's irrelevant. There's the same thing happening, the pauperization of the middle class, tipping the scales. They knew.
- aeternum 4y agoFiat money seems like the result rather than the cause. As nations start to draw down their gold/asset reserves, it makes sense to switch to a fiat currency. Clearly the cause is too much money out and not enough money in to government coffers rather than fiat.
- WalterBright 4y agoGovernments prefer fiat money because they can print all they want without raising taxes. And that's what they've always done with fiat money, going back to the invention of money. It always results in inflation. The reason nobody believes this is because of extremely effective propaganda emanating from every government that prints fiat money. The "Putin Price Hike" is the latest in a long string of lies about what causes inflation. (Inflation was at something like 7% before Putin's War started.) Of course, "the speculators, gougers, and profiteers" are always blamed, too.
- SamoyedFurFluff 4y agoI think we’re getting into conspiracy theory here. You’re arguing that $fact, and the only way $not-fact is argued is propaganda. This means any person who might have a reason to argue for $not-fact is by default a propagandist. There’s no productive conversation to be had from this.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe productive part is realizing you've been flim-flammed. There's no other explanation for the government narrative to completely avoid the truth. Every fiat money government does this - it's not a conspiracy, it's just that it's in their best interests to blame inflation on speculators rather than their own profligate printing of money. I've presented many facts to support this. Economists know it, too. Study it and you'll see for yourself. Another part of the flim-flam is the government is always trying to promote the idea that inflation is good for the economy. Read their explanations. It's all nonsense.
- aeternum 4y ago
- perfecthjrjth 4y agoThat's why the wealthy class buys "real" assets, instead of holding "nominal" assets(currency)
- WalterBright 4y agoI've never held significant amounts of cash because of inflation.
- haskellandchill 4y agoAnd this is generally regarded as a good thing.
- vdqtp3 4y agoBy those who have plenty of income and durable assets and can look down on those who hold cash
- haskellandchill 4y agoit was not meant as a value judgement but a macro economical perspective on encouraging investment in productive assets
- wefarrell 4y agoFiat money is as old as currency itself. Greek and Rome coin values did not correspond to their intrinsic metal content (at least not within their boundaries) and they were regularly debased. The Chinese used bronze coins and paper as currency.
- bildung 4y agoThe USA had dozens of years with >10% inflation or deflation during that period, and even multiple years with over 20% inflation. https://www.minneapolisfed.org/about-us/monetary-policy/inflation-calculator/consumer-price-index-1800- https://www.minneapolisfed.org/about-us/monetary-policy/infl...
- WalterBright 4y agoAnd corresponding deflation which netted out to zero. Two interesting periods of inflation were during the California gold rush, and the Yukon gold rush. It turns out, when gold is the currency, flooding the market with newly mined gold causes inflation, just like fiat money printing.
- gamblor956 4y agoYou need to re-read your history. European nations suspended the Gold Standard in 1914 due to the buildup related to WWI...but the U.S. did not. And we still had 100% inflation. In fact, the U.S. remained on the Gold Standard until 1933, and being on the gold standard did not prevent the Great Depression or decades of inflation. In fact, it played a large part in making it a "great" depression instead of just a regular downturn, and getting off the gold standard was what ended the Great Depression. Similarly, everything you've said about the Great Depression is completely wrong. It was caused by a stock market crash known as Black Tuesday, which was the result of rampant speculative trading on margin. After a series of relatively small dips, a number of investors faced margin calls and had to sell their shares. A few of them decided to liquidate all of their stock holdings, triggering a 12.8% drop in the Dow (Black Monday), which led to many more speculators panic-selling the next day (Black Tuesday).
- WalterBright 4y agoI recommend you read "Monetary History of the United States" by Friedman. I have. We've had stock market crashes before and after. None resulted in a Great Depression. Something else was going on to cause the Depression. The 100% inflation from 1914-1929 indeed was not prevented by the gold standard, but in 1929 people realized they could double their money by converting their dollars to gold. This caused the bank runs which did not stop until all gold exchanges were stopped. The gold standard ended in 1933, the Depression did not begin to end until 1939 when foreign countries flooded the US with armaments orders. What the US did in 1914 was called "pegging". It wasn't really a gold standard, the fiat money was just pegged to gold. Pegging has been tried over and over throughout history, a sham that tries to inflate money while pretending not to. It works for a while, and then always results in a massive and destructive correction. The US's correction was the Great Depression.
- gamblor956 4y agoI've read that book. My professor suggested using it as toilet paper after we were done, and I agreed with him. The Great Depression bank runs were not caused by people trying to swap their cash for gold. Because you couldn't...after 1913 banks generally did not maintain their reserves in gold, and they certainly did not maintain local reserves in gold. At best you could get a promissory note for a representative amount of gold. The fiction that you could actually swap out cash for gold is one of the more bizarre historical conspiracies. The bank runs stopped because the FDIC was created in 1934 to guarantee depositors' savings accounts. Until then, depositors risked losing their savings when a bank collapsed, which is why bank runs were a thing.